Matt Ponatoski is suddenly staring at a real fork in the road.
The Archbishop Moeller High School standout and Kentucky quarterback commit was taken by the Cincinnati Reds in the 18th round of the 2026 MLB Draft, putting his baseball future on a tight clock and forcing a choice between pro ball and the college football path he had lined up at Kentucky.
The Reds’ selection wasn’t a surprise in the sense that Ponatoski was viewed as a player worth drafting. The bigger issue was the possibility that he could end up at Kentucky instead, which is why Cincinnati - along with other clubs - passed on him earlier. Now the Reds will try to get him signed anyway.
Ponatoski has been open about where his preference sits. “I want to be a professional baseball player as fast as possible,” Ponatoski told OverslotBaseball.com in June. “That’s where my heart’s been, and it’s always been.”
His deadline to sign a baseball contract is 5 p.m. on July 27, according to the Lexington Herald-Leader.
Ponatoski had originally planned to be a two-sport athlete at Kentucky, but that path may have shifted after Mark Stoops was replaced by Will Stein. That change leaves his next move even more important, with roughly two weeks left for him to decide whether he’ll head toward the Reds or keep his commitment to play quarterback for Kentucky.
Kentucky has already signed another top quarterback, Jake Nawrot, in the Class of 2028, adding another layer to Ponatoski’s decision.
In Other News...
Reds Fans Wont Like This Trade Deadline Pitching Rumor
Hunter Greenes return to the Reds has already carried the kind of uneven early chapter that comes with any pitcher working back from a lost stretch of time. He missed the first half of the season after offseason elbow surgery, then shook off some rust in his first start back before looking sharper in a follow-up outing against the Cubs, giving Cincinnati at least a glimpse of the upside that has made him such an important part of the rotation.
Still, a third-party rumor has put Greene in an uncomfortable spot as the trade deadline approaches, with speculation that the Reds could at least consider moving him. No official talks have been reported, and the idea is more about outside chatter than anything concrete, but it is the kind of noise that tends to follow a talented arm when health questions and roster decisions start colliding in late July. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Just Made One Draft Pick Fans Never Saw Coming
The Reds draft board took an unexpected turn late when they used a 17th-round pick on Northwestern dual-sport athlete Jack Lausch, a player better known around college football circles for playing quarterback. Lausch also gave Cincinnati something to think about on the baseball side in 2026, when he put together a strong season at the plate and showed enough offensive upside to make him more than just a novelty name on the list.
It fit into a draft that already leaned heavily toward infield talent, with the Reds adding Virginia shortstop Eric Becker in the second round after making their first-round choice. For a front office that came away feeling good about how the day unfolded, Lausch was the kind of late swing that can make a draft class more interesting, especially for a club that is always looking for athleticism and upside wherever it can find it. [Read more 🡒]