The Reds are headed toward a trade deadline that should change the farm system, but probably not by enough to make anyone feel great about it.
With the deadline set for August 3rd at 6:00pm ET, Cincinnati looks almost certainly out of the playoff picture. The club has won back-to-back road series, but it still sits seven games under .500, 16.5 games back in the division and six games out of the final wild card spot, with all but three teams ahead of it. The front office has already said it is open to moving players on expiring contracts, which is about as clear a sign as you can get that the organization doesn’t believe a late push is coming.
That usually creates an opportunity to restock a thin system. For the Reds, though, the problem is that the farm is already in rough shape.
A big reason is simple attrition: over the last 12 months, Chase Burns, Sal Stewart, Rhett Lowder, Edwin Arroyo, Chase Petty and others have lost prospect eligibility and dropped off prospect lists and farm rankings. All of them were Top 100 prospects at some point, and losing that much talent in such a short span hits an organization hard.
So yes, the deadline should help Cincinnati’s system a little. It just doesn’t sound like it will be a major boost.
The issue is the same one hanging over the roster itself: the Reds don’t appear likely to move the kind of players who would return premium prospects. Even though teams have become more cautious about dealing top-100-caliber talent, those players still get moved from time to time.
Cincinnati, though, does not seem positioned to deal the sort of name that brings back that kind of haul. Nick Krall didn’t explicitly say Hunter Greene is untouchable, but the Reds are almost assuredly not going to trade Hunter Greene.
That lines up with what Kiley McDaniel of ESPN wrote this morning, when he said he expects the Reds won’t add to the system “in a real way, instead acquiring medium upside-types in the upper minors” at the deadline.
The bigger issue is where the organization stands on pitching depth. Right now, it’s shaky across the board.
Even with the graduations of Burns, Lowder and Petty taking a bite out of the system, the reality is that none of the pitchers across the club’s four full-season affiliates - Single-A Daytona, High-A Dayton, Double-A Chattanooga and Triple-A Louisville - project comfortably as more than a fifth starter at the moment, and even that is generous for some of the arms who have struggled this year. The best pitching prospect in the system is still a teenager with fewer than 30 career innings, a second-round pick from last year who has good stuff but not elite stuff.
The draft added some starting pitching depth, but not the kind that changes the conversation. Cincinnati’s first pitcher selected went 94th overall and is not viewed as a major prospect, and none of the pitchers drafted cracked my midseason Top 25 prospects list for the organization. That may help Dayton and Daytona a bit down the road, especially by 2027, but it doesn’t solve the larger problem: the Reds still have too many full-season pitchers who don’t project as big league starters.
If Cincinnati has a chance to target anything at the deadline, it should probably be arms who can at least profile as middle-of-the-rotation or No. 4 starters in Double-A or Triple-A. That kind of depth matters over a full season, when clubs inevitably need three or four pitchers to step in and cover innings. And the Reds simply don’t have enough of those options right now.
Starting pitching depth looked like a strength entering spring training in 2026. It turned out not to be one, for a bunch of different reasons.
That’s hardly a new story in baseball. Pitchers get hurt far more often than position players do, and the Reds are living through that reality again.
In Other News...
Joey Votto Just Changed His Tune On Elly De La Cruz
Joey Vottos view of Elly De La Cruz has come a long way from the caution he felt when the young shortstop first arrived in the majors. Votto admitted he once saw a player with plenty of flash but also plenty of risk, the kind of talent whose strikeouts, errors and recklessness could make it hard to trust the long view. Since then, De La Cruz has given him plenty of reason to rethink that stance, with Votto pointing to the way he works, carries himself and keeps showing up every day.
What stands out now, from Vottos perspective, is not just the tools but the steadiness behind them. He praised De La Cruzs humility and drive, and noted that the Reds have watched him turn raw ability into something more dependable through consistent performance and durability. Votto even placed him in rare company when talking about the shortstop standard in Cincinnati, which says plenty about how far De La Cruz has come in the eyes of one of the franchises most respected voices. [Read more 🡒]
One Reds Deadline Gamble Might Finally Be Worth The Wait
The Reds 2022 deadline haul is still being judged through a harsh lens, especially after the club shipped out Luis Castillo and Tyler Mahle in separate deals that reshaped the roster in a hurry. One of the quieter moves from that summer was sending Brandon Drury to San Diego for Victor Acosta, a return that has tested patience because Acosta spent years stuck in the lower minors before finally giving Cincinnati a reason to keep watching.
Acostas latest step forward came in Dayton, where he delivered a breakthrough game that hinted at more than just a hot night at the plate. For a trade that once looked like a footnote, that kind of performance matters, because the Reds are still waiting to see whether this is the start of a real climb or just another brief flash in a long, uneven development path. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Risk Making Their Ke'Bryan Hayes Mistake Even More Costly
When the Reds brought in KeBryan Hayes from Pittsburgh last July, it looked like a chance to buy low on a slick-fielding third baseman and reshape the roster with Taylor Rogers and Sammy Stafura going the other way. Instead, Hayes has struggled to provide much at the plate since arriving in Cincinnati, and the deal has quickly become one of those moves that looks different in hindsight than it did on paper.
That is what makes the next step so tricky for the front office. Hayes still carries a contract that runs through 2029, and if the Reds decide to move him again, they have to be careful not to turn a disappointing acquisition into a bigger problem by attaching him to other valuable pieces just to clear the books. [Read more 🡒]