The Cincinnati Reds may not know yet whether they’re headed toward buying or selling at the trade deadline, but they could have a major decision waiting if they choose the latter. Nathaniel Lowe has given their lineup a real lift and now looks like a potentially valuable trade chip, especially as a left-handed power bat. For a player who had to settle for a minor league deal with Cincinnati in mid-February, that’s a serious rise in value.
Jeff Passan has Lowe ranked among the league’s top 100 trade chips, slotting him at No. 45.
That kind of jump turns a low-cost pickup into the sort of asset contenders notice fast. But moving him would leave the Reds searching for offense again, and another minor league signing might already be pointing the way.
That possibility comes in the form of Michael Toglia, the former Colorado Rockies first baseman who could end up functioning as Nathaniel Lowe 2.0. Toglia was Colorado’s first-round pick in 2019 out of UCLA and was once the Rockies’ No. 3 prospect. At 6-foot-5 and 226 pounds, he has the kind of build that jumps off the page, but he never managed to lock down a spot over parts of four MLB seasons.
Last year, he hit rock bottom with a .190/.258/.353 line and a 39.2% strikeout rate in 337 plate appearances, which led to his release. Since joining the Reds on a minor league contract, though, he has been tearing it up in Louisville. He’s up to nearly 20 home runs in fewer than 80 games, and he’s pairing that power with a 14.2% walk rate and a much more manageable 26.1% strikeout rate.
Toglia has made it clear he’s embraced the opportunity. He told Louisville Bats reporter Ben Teitel, "The Reds were really excited about me in the offseason, and I felt that energy right away.
I feel that every team can use slug, and that’s something I bring to the table, along with good defense at first. I felt like this was a good thing for me.”
He also described his approach in simple terms. “I think the best way to walk is to slug,” Toglia explained.
“You have to scare the pitchers out of the zone. That’s the only way you’re gonna walk.
If they’re throwing me homers, I've got to take them. If they’re throwing me walks, I've got to take them.”
That mindset would fit well at Great American Ball Park, a place built for home runs. Toglia’s major league track record still leaves questions, but Lowe’s own recent rise showed the Reds were right not to ignore a risky bat. If Cincinnati decides to test the market on Lowe and gets an overpay, Toglia could be the internal answer waiting in the wings.
It’s a gamble, but one the Reds might be willing to make if the return is strong enough and Toglia keeps hitting the way he has in Louisville.
In Other News...
Reds Face A Huge Alfredo Duno Decision Small-Market Rivals Already Make
The Brewers have turned early extensions into a core part of how they manage young talent, locking up prospects before they ever reach the big leagues and giving themselves cost certainty while those players still have plenty to prove. Cincinnati has watched that model from afar, and it is easy to see why the conversation is popping up now around Alfredo Duno, the organizations top prospect and a catcher with enough upside to make the idea of a long-term deal worth at least considering.
Duno is moving fast enough through the system to make the timing more interesting by the day, with Double-A on the horizon and Triple-A not out of the question before the year is over. The Reds do not have to decide anything immediately, but the broader question is already here: whether a small-market club that needs to keep building smartly should try to get ahead of the market with a player like Duno, or wait and risk paying more once he is closer to becoming part of the big-league picture. [Read more 🡒]
Carlos Jorge Just Gave Reds Fans Another Reason To Start Wondering
Carlos Jorge has been pushing his way into the conversation for a while, and the Reds moved him again as part of the latest wave of prospect promotions. The outfielder went from Double-A Chattanooga to Triple-A Louisville, a sign that his bat has kept forcing the issue as he continues climbing through the system. Jos Acua and Johnathan Lavallee also got the call to Louisville, giving the Bats a little more organizational traffic on a busy development day.
Jorges appeal has been obvious to anyone tracking the minors: a strong batting average, a lively OPS and enough production to earn Southern League Player of the Week honors for May 26-31. He has also already shown he can rebound from a scary collision with the outfield wall last year, which only adds to the intrigue around how far his momentum can carry him now that he is one step closer to the majors. [Read more 🡒]