The Reds’ catcher situation could get uncomfortable fast if Tyler Stephenson walks, and Cincinnati may not have many appealing ways to patch it.
Keeping Stephenson at the trade deadline looked, at first glance, like a missed chance. The catcher market had more buyers than sellers after Shea Langeliers got hurt, and the Minnesota Twins’ surge removed some of the best names from the board. Then Baltimore’s return for Adley Rutschman only made the decision sting more.
But there’s another side to that move. Stephenson is headed for free agency, and while the Reds could have tried to bring him back after trading him, doing that would have been much tougher. If Cincinnati wants to avoid a messy winter behind the plate, reuniting with the 30-year-old has to be near the top of the list.
The reason is simple: the alternatives are thin.
Alfredo Duno is there in the system, and the 20-year-old is carrying a huge amount of weight for the Reds’ farm. But rushing him would be asking for trouble. He’s the crown jewel, and the organization has to treat him that way.
Jose Trevino is under contract for one more year, with a club option for 2028, but he’s a glove-first veteran who would be stretched as the everyday starter. And for a Reds team that already has trouble scoring, it can’t afford to hand out an automatic out every night.
If Stephenson leaves, Cincinnati would likely have to shop the free-agent market. That pool is not exactly overflowing.
Ryan Jeffers is the most attractive name, and he’s putting together a huge year in Minnesota with an .880 OPS that could set him up for a strong payday. Even so, his career line of .244/.329/.429 is not that far from Stephenson’s .259/.337/.426.
Carson Kelly of the Cubs comes next, but the 32-year-old is a step or two below Jeffers and Stephenson in overall impact. After that, the options drop off sharply.
Stephenson’s case isn’t just about a weak market, either.
Jeffers has been red-hot, but he also missed nearly two months with a broken hamate bone and has only 295 plate appearances this season. Stephenson’s overall numbers took a hit because he opened the year in a deep slump.
Through the first two months, he hit .199/.299/.326. Since June 1, though, he’s been at .286/.352/.495, which is very close to Jeffers’ production over a similar stretch of 230 plate appearances.
The defensive gap is narrower than it might look, too. Jeffers is above average at blocking pitches, below average in controlling the running game, and about average as a framer.
Stephenson is elite at blocking, sitting in the 97th percentile, while also struggling some in throwing out runners and framing. But he has one extra weapon: he’s an ABS challenge wizard, which helps make up for some of the framing issues.
That leaves Cincinnati with a value play in front of it. Jeffers is likely headed for a top-of-the-market deal, while Stephenson should be more affordable. For a Reds club with no obvious replacement, that makes Stephenson the cleaner fit.
The message is straightforward: re-sign Tyler Stephenson, and if Alfredo Duno truly becomes ready down the line, the Reds can always move Stephenson then. Missing on this would leave Cincinnati in a brutal spot, with very few good answers left.
In Other News...
Reds Just Sent Edwin Arroyo A Tough Message Before Dodgers Series
The Reds got a bit healthier in the infield ahead of a big series, activating KeBryan Hayes from the 10-day injured list and sending Edwin Arroyo to Triple-A Louisville. It is the kind of roster move that says as much about performance as it does about health, and for Arroyo it comes after a rough stretch in the majors that never quite found a rhythm.
Arroyo went 1-for-18 with seven strikeouts in six games, a difficult line for any young player trying to hold onto a spot. With fellow rookie Juan Brito having outperformed him and settled into that role, Arroyo now heads back to Louisville with the Reds making a clear short-term choice as they prepare for the Dodgers. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Just Added Outfield Insurance For A Stretch Run Concern
The Reds have added a little more outfield depth for the final weeks of the season, signing veteran Dominic Fletcher to a minor league deal. Fletcher last appeared in the majors in 2025 and comes to Cincinnati after using a release clause to leave Triple-A with the Pittsburgh Pirates, giving the organization another experienced option to stash in the system as it looks to protect itself against late-season roster wear.
It is the kind of move that rarely grabs headlines, but it matters for a club trying to stay nimble with the schedule tightening up. Cincinnati has gotten plenty of impact from Elly De La Cruz, who continues to rate among the Reds best position players and one of the top shortstops in the league, so the front office can afford to keep building the margins around the roster while the stretch run sorts itself out. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Fans Have A New Ownership Rumor To Watch
The recent sale of the Los Angeles Angels has stirred up a familiar kind of chatter around baseball, and now the Reds have been pulled into it. According to MLB insider Bob Nightengale, rival owners believe Cincinnati could be the next club to change hands, a notable bit of speculation for a franchise whose current direction has long been a source of fan frustration under the Castellini family.
For now, there is no official indication the Reds are actually on the market, which is what makes the rumor worth watching rather than treating it as fact. Still, any mention of a possible sale lands with some weight in Cincinnati, where executives have faced plenty of scrutiny and the question of ownership has become part of the larger conversation about where the organization is headed next. [Read more 🡒]