Nick Lodolo’s latest trip to the injured list has the Reds staring at the same frustrating question again: how do you get the most out of a pitcher whose talent keeps getting interrupted by the same problem?
Lodolo left his last start before the All-Star break after developing a blister on his left index finger, and it’s the same issue that has knocked him out multiple times over the last three seasons. The Reds are frustrated.
Lodolo is frustrated. The fanbase is frustrated.
And despite plenty of loud opinions floating around online, there doesn’t appear to be a simple cure for a problem that keeps coming back.
He has already tried a range of treatments and preventative measures over the years, and the blister still finds him. In 2024, he even altered his grip, only to end up with a season-ending sprain to his left middle finger.
At some point, Cincinnati may need to consider a different kind of solution. One possibility is moving Lodolo out of the rotation and into the bullpen.
That’s not an easy sell for any starter. There’s pride involved, and there’s money involved too. Starting pitchers generally get paid more than relievers, which makes the conversation even tougher.
Still, this kind of move is often where pitchers with command issues or trouble facing a lineup a third time eventually land. Connor Phillips and Graham Ashcraft fit that path.
Lodolo’s case is different, though. A bullpen role might not just help the Reds manage him - it might help preserve his career.
The thinking is straightforward. Longer outings mean more repeated gripping and releasing of the ball, which could be part of what keeps triggering the blister.
Lodolo has also talked before about how the problem gets worse when the weather heats up and he sweats more. Shorter relief appearances could ease some of that strain.
There’s also the roster side of it. If a reliever gets hurt, replacing him is usually far easier than losing a starter, where the damage runs deeper and the ripple effect is bigger.
A bullpen arm is asked for two innings, maybe three. A starter’s absence changes everything.
For this season, the Reds may not want to force the issue. Rhett Lowder and Chase Burns are both expected to have innings restrictions in the second half, which makes a sudden Lodolo shift harder to justify right now.
But looking ahead to 2027, the idea starts to make more sense. That would be Lodolo’s last year of arbitration eligibility, and it could be the time to seriously consider the bullpen path.
There’s another layer here, too. Lodolo becomes a free agent after next season, and if he keeps missing time as a starter, no club is likely to pay him like one. If he can put together a strong season in relief, though, he could change that conversation before reaching free agency after the 2027 season.
For both sides, it could be the rare move that actually works. Lodolo has the stuff, but the availability has never matched the talent. And for a Reds left-hander who keeps ending up on the IL, that old line keeps ringing true: “the best ability is availability” certainly applies to the Reds' lefty, and his availability has been in question the past several seasons.
In Other News...
Reds May Have Found Another Infield Gem Fans Need To Watch
The Reds kept leaning into the infield in the 2026 MLB Draft, taking Alabama shortstop Justin Lebron in the first round and then circling back for another high-upside middle infielder in Virginias Eric Becker. Cincinnati signed Becker for $1.65 million, a deal that gives the organization another young bat with real defensive flexibility, since he could wind up at second or third base if he moves off shortstop as expected.
Beckers college season was interrupted by injury, and that setback helped create the opening for Cincinnati to grab him where it did. Even with the missed time, he carried enough appeal to draw attention as a player with a strong offensive ceiling and the kind of versatility teams covet, which makes him one of the more interesting names to track as the Reds continue stockpiling infield talent. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Injury Update Just Raised The Stakes Before The Deadline
Nick Lodolos latest injury update only adds to the uncertainty hanging over the Reds as the trade deadline approaches. The left-hander has been sidelined by blister issues, and while Cincinnati is planning for him to try a bullpen session, the bigger picture is a roster that keeps getting squeezed by injuries at the wrong time. Blake Dunn and Matt McLain are also moving toward rehab assignments, giving the club a few small signs of progress even as the active roster remains in flux.
For a team trying to stay in the race, the timing is awkward. Lodolo had been the kind of arm that could have shaped the deadline conversation one way or another, but recurring health problems make everything more complicated. With multiple players working back and the front office still weighing its options, the next few days could determine whether Cincinnati adds help, stands pat, or reshuffles around the injuries it already has. [Read more 🡒]
Joey Votto Just Reopened A Painful Truth About The Reds
Joey Votto used a recent turn on MLB Networks MLB Now to revisit a familiar and frustrating chapter of his career with the Reds, and the conversation landed with a little extra bite because of what he was comparing it to. On July 22, Votto was talking baseball on the networks analyst-driven show, a setting he has used before for loose, thoughtful discussions about everything from his favorite hitters to his embrace of analytics.
This time, the subject was momentum, and Votto drew a sharp contrast between Cincinnatis years with him in the lineup and the kind of surge Boston is riding now. He said he never experienced anything quite like a true comeback wave during his Reds tenure, which is the kind of reflection that inevitably sends Cincinnati fans back through the what-ifs of that era and the gap between good seasons and something bigger. [Read more 🡒]