The Reds have become a familiar case study in blame, but the latest round of finger-pointing has only muddied the picture. While Ken Rosenthal and C. Trent Rosecrans both aimed their criticism at ownership, the evidence in Cincinnati points to a broader mess - and Nick Krall is right in the middle of it.
Rosenthal made his case on the Foul Territory Podcast, saying, "I would say it rests, with the Reds, on ownership more than anything else," before adding, "Right now, they're being run by a guy, Bob Castellini, who has not had success. Who has not shown his franchise can be like the Brewers, like the Tampa Bay Rays, like a team in his own state, the Cleveland Guardians. They've not been a successful small-market team."
Rosecrans echoed that view when he joined the same crew. "It's ownership," he said.
"And it has been ownership. You look at the trends in this franchise, since 2007, they've not been able to go quite over the hump.
Or make the big shocking moves. Everything has been on the margins and on the cheap."
There’s no denying Bob and Phil Castellini have been part of the problem. But that doesn’t make Krall a bystander.
Cincinnati has spent real money under his watch, and the return has been thin. Since Krall was promoted to general manager in 2019, the Reds’ major league free-agent haul includes Zach Duke, Mike Moustakas, Nick Castellanos, Shogo Akiyama, Wade Miley, Pedro Strop, Sean Doolittle, Hunter Strickland, Tommy Pham, Wil Myers, Donovan Solano, Luke Weaver, Luke Maile and Eugenio Suárez.
Those 14 signings added up to $176.7 million, with Castellanos opting out of the final two years of his deal. Together, that group produced just 8.5 bWAR.
The money was there. The impact wasn’t.
The same story has played out in the trade market. Since Krall took over the reins from Dick Williams following the 2020 season, the Reds have made a long list of major deals, and the returns have mostly been underwhelming.
Outside of Steer and maybe Rodriguez, the results have been poor. The jury is still out on Williamson, Arroyo and Petty, but none of the 16 players acquired in those moves is anywhere near All-Star level.
A few names do stand out. Gray is helping anchor a Red Sox rotation headed for the postseason.
Mahle was arguably the best pickup at this year’s trade deadline. Stafura has posted a .909 OPS in the minors this season, and Sirota is ranked among baseball’s top 50 prospects.
Encarnacion-Strand, meanwhile, is now having success in Baltimore after the Reds didn’t even need to DFA him.
So yes, ownership deserves its share of the heat. That much is obvious.
But the idea that Krall should be cleared just because he works under the Castellinis doesn’t hold up. The Reds haven’t just spent less effectively than better-run clubs; they’ve spent poorly, traded poorly, and come up short too often to pin this whole thing on the people above the general manager.
In Other News...
Tyler Stephensons Reds Future Suddenly Feels Far More Uncertain
Tyler Stephensons latest injury setback has added another layer of uncertainty to a season that already had plenty of it for the Reds. He left the game against the Los Angeles Dodgers with a hamstring injury, and now there is real doubt about whether he will get back on the field before the year is over. For a Cincinnati club that has already been eliminated from postseason contention, the focus has shifted quickly from standings to what comes next, especially around one of the more important names on the roster.
Stephenson is headed toward free agency after the season, which makes every development feel a little heavier now. The Reds chose to keep him at the trade deadline, a move that drew questions at the time, and this injury only sharpens the attention on what his future in Cincinnati might look like. What once seemed like a straightforward stretch run for a player the Reds still value now feels far less settled. [Read more 🡒]
Noelvi Marte's Future With The Reds May Not Be About His Bat
Noelvi Martes situation with the Reds has drifted into a place where the conversation is no longer just about whether his bat is ready. After being optioned back to Triple-A Louisville in August, he is expected to stay there for the rest of the 2026 season, a development that reflects both his uneven offensive performance and the clubs bigger-picture roster considerations.
Marte has struggled to get on base since returning, with a low walk rate and on-base percentage doing little to help his case for a rapid move back to Cincinnati. His 2024 PED suspension and extended time in the minors also mean he has not accrued Major League service time this season, a detail that could weigh heavily as the Reds weigh the value of keeping a young player around at a low salary cost. [Read more 🡒]
JJ Wetherholt Is Making This Rookie Race Very Uncomfortable For Reds Fans
JJ Wetherholts return from injury has put a little more heat back on a 2026 National League Rookie of the Year conversation that already felt like it could go either way. The Cardinals infielder has become one of the leading candidates in the eyes of advanced metrics such as AXE ratings, and that kind of backing matters when a race starts to tighten around two young players who are making different cases for themselves.
For Reds fans, the uncomfortable part is obvious: Sal Stewart still has the kind of traditional offensive line that keeps him squarely in the mix, even as Wetherholts all-around profile keeps growing louder in the background. The award is far from settled, and the real intrigue now is whether voters lean toward the numbers that measure broader value or stay with the more familiar production that jumps off the page. [Read more 🡒]