Matt McLain May Be At Center Of A Reds Roster Shakeup

As the Reds face tough roster decisions ahead of the non-tender deadline, former top prospect Matt McLain's uncertain future could signal a significant shake-up.

The Reds are staring at a busy week, and Matt McLain is the name that jumps off the page first.

With the non-tender deadline set for Friday, November 20, Cincinnati has to sort through a roster that could lose more than a dozen players. The clock is ticking before the offseason comes to a hard stop on December 1, and the Reds have several decisions to make on their 40-man group.

McLain is the most recognizable player in the mix, and also the most complicated. His rookie season in 2023 looked like the start of something big: he hit .290/.357/.507 with 16 home runs and 50 RBI, then finished fifth in Rookie of the Year voting.

Since then, though, the production has backed up. He missed the 2024 season with a shoulder injury, and over the last two years he has put up a .204/.288/.339 line with a 74 OPS+.

Even with that dip, his glove has kept him in the conversation. Without that elite defense, he may have found himself in the minors during the second half of the 2026 season.

MLB Trade Rumors projects McLain at $4 million in arbitration next year, and that price tag could push Cincinnati to consider other uses for the money. A non-tender feels unlikely, but a trade is very much on the table.

Tony Santillan is another name worth watching. The right-hander’s 2026 season ended with an injured list stint and hip surgery, and while he’s expected to be ready for spring training, the Reds still have to decide which version of him they’re betting on.

In 2025, Santillan threw 73⅔ innings across 80 appearances and posted a 2.44 ERA. This past season was a different story: a 6.42 ERA in just 44 appearances.

That kind of swing makes him a real candidate to be cut loose before Friday.

Brandon Williamson sits in a different spot. He fought to make the Opening Day roster in 2026, but wound up making only nine starts.

Injuries have limited the left-hander to 16 appearances over the last three years, even though he was once viewed as a major piece in the organization. His arbitration number is expected to be modest, around $1.3 million, and with starting pitching so expensive on the open market, it’s hard to see the Reds non-tendering him.

Still, 2027 looms as a make-or-break year for the former top prospect.

JJ Bleday brings another interesting wrinkle. Cincinnati picked up the former Athletics outfielder at a bargain last winter, but his arbitration projection now sits around $5 million for 2027.

If he plays like he did early in the 2026 season, that would be a steal. His numbers fell off after the All-Star break, but he still hit 24 homers, and the Reds’ lack of outfield depth probably helps keep him in the picture.

Even so, a trade later this offseason can’t be ruled out.

Noelvi Marte is the only one of this group not headed for a raise through arbitration, which makes a non-tender less likely. But that doesn’t mean he’s safe.

There was a feeling after the season that Marte’s effort wasn’t there in 2026, and both Nick Krall and Terry Francona were not exactly glowing in their comments about the former infielder turned outfielder. If another team shows interest, he looks like a possible change-of-scenery candidate.

And those are just the more recognizable names. There are several Reds players in even shakier shape, including right-handers Zach Maxwell, Duncan Davitt, Paxton Schultz, Chase Solesky, and Carson Spiers, along with catcher Will Banfield and infield prospect Leo Balcazar.

In Other News...

Reds Just Got More Pressure In A Tyler Stephenson Decision

Ryan Jeffers taking the Twins one-year qualifying offer has already shifted the catching market, and it only makes the next few weeks more interesting for Cincinnati. With one of the more reliable names off the board, Tyler Stephenson suddenly looks even more valuable as a starting-caliber option for teams searching behind the plate. For the Reds, that raises the stakes on an offseason decision they were already going to have to make carefully.

Stephenson has been part of the clubs core conversation for a while, but a thinner market can change the price quickly. Cincinnati now has to weigh the comfort of keeping a known piece in place against the possibility of outside interest pushing the bidding higher, all while sorting through other catcher alternatives. The longer this plays out, the more it feels like a decision the Reds cannot afford to treat casually. [Read more 🡒]

Reds Still Have One Affordable Catching Option Worth Watching

The Reds are still sorting out the catching picture behind Jose Trevino, and the search has a familiar feel: find someone affordable, dependable enough to handle a share of the workload, and possibly capable of stepping into a larger role if Tyler Stephenson does not return. One name that has surfaced is Joey Bart, the veteran catcher who was recently released by the Chicago White Sox and would fit the kind of low-cost gamble Cincinnati has to consider at this stage of the offseason.

Barts appeal is obvious enough for a team in the Reds position. He has already been through the ups and downs that come with trying to establish himself at the major league level, and his recent track record has been uneven, with injuries and trades interrupting his run in 2026. Still, for a club looking to add catching depth without spending heavily, he remains the kind of option worth keeping on the radar while the rest of the market takes shape. [Read more 🡒]

Reds May Have A Costly Answer To Their Third Base Problem

Christian Encarnacion-Strands departure from Cincinnati has only added to the Reds questions at third base, especially after he has settled in and performed well for Baltimore. Now the Orioles crowded infield picture has created a possible opening, with Jordan Westburg drawing trade interest from multiple teams and emerging as a name the Reds could circle as they look for a more reliable answer on the left side of the infield.

Westburg would fit the kind of upgrade Cincinnati has been hunting, but there is a catch beyond the acquisition cost. The Reds are weighing him as a potential solution at third, yet there are durability concerns attached to the fit, which makes this less of a clean fix and more of a calculated gamble for a club still trying to stabilize the position. [Read more 🡒]