Matt McLain enters 2027 with plenty to prove, and the Reds need that answer to come fast.
Two years have passed since he sat out the entire 2024 MLB season, and the follow-up has not looked like the breakout many expected. In 2025, coming back from a shoulder injury, the struggles made some sense.
He posted a 78 OPS+ and 0.1 bWAR in that return season. But 2026 was supposed to show real progress, and instead the numbers slipped even further.
McLain finished 2026 with a 69 OPS+ and a -0.6 bWAR. His batting average dropped by 35 points from the previous season, and his on-base percentage fell by 26 points. For a player the Reds viewed as part of their next great team, that kind of downward trend is hard to ignore.
Dig into the underlying numbers and the picture gets even rougher. McLain landed in the 1st percentile in Major League Baseball in Batting Run Value at -19. He was in the 12th percentile in strikeout percentage and the 38th percentile in Bat Speed.
Still, there are reasons the Reds haven’t given up on him. McLain continues to offer real defensive value at second base, and he handled shortstop well when Elly De La Cruz was either on the injured list or serving as the designated hitter. The Reds even used him in center field for a few games, which fits their strategy.
At the plate, the issues are obvious, but he still shows some feel for the zone. Last season, McLain was in the 68th percentile in chase rate and was just above league average in walks. That said, his walk rate also dropped nearly 15% from 2025.
Now the focus shifts to 2027, his third season since the shoulder injury. The Reds need to find out whether this is the real Matt McLain, because they need him to be part of the solution if they’re going to get back to being competitive. Elly and Sal Stewart may be the hitters opposing pitchers fear most, but someone else has to rise with them, and among that group McLain may be the most talented.
He was the Reds’ best player in 2023 and gave Reds’ country plenty of hope. Injuries happen, and the Reds mismanaging injuries happens too, but if Matt McLain is going to help Cincinnati win again, 2027 has to be the year he makes it happen.
In Other News...
Reds Suddenly Have A Ninth-Inning Problem They Didn't Expect
The Reds knew they would have offseason decisions to make, but the ninth inning was not supposed to be one of the biggest ones. Emilio Pagan had become a steady late-game option in Cincinnati over the past two seasons, giving the club reliability in a role that can change by the week, and his work helped stabilize a bullpen that needed it.
Now the Reds are staring at a closing job without the reliever who handled it most often. Pagans departure leaves a real void for 2027, and it is the kind of problem teams usually hope to avoid after a season in which the back end of the bullpen had finally found some order. The search for his replacement is now part of the winter agenda. [Read more 🡒]
Elly De La Cruz Trade Talk Just Reopened A Huge Reds Debate
The offseason chatter around Elly De La Cruz has already put the Reds back in a familiar spot, weighing the value of a franchise centerpiece against the kind of interest that can reshape a roster. Bostons interest is not new, either. The Red Sox were reportedly aggressive before the trade deadline, and Cincinnati turned them away, a sign of just how high the bar is for even beginning to consider moving one of the most electric young players in the game.
Nick Krall has left the door open without pushing anyone through it, and thats enough to keep this story alive as winter unfolds. The Reds are not operating from a place of urgency, but any discussion around De La Cruz naturally turns into a larger debate about timing, return value and whether a club built around young talent should ever entertain a deal this big. For now, the speculation is doing what speculation does best, forcing Cincinnati to answer a question it would probably rather avoid. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Face A Big Sal Stewart Decision As Offseason Priorities Stack Up
Sal Stewarts breakout season has already put him at the center of the Reds winter conversation, and president of baseball operations Nick Krall made clear the club is still sorting through what comes next. After Stewart won National League Rookie of the Year, Krall pointed to the rookies defensive versatility and work ethic as reasons the organization views him as more than just a hot young bat, even as the front office keeps a long list of offseason priorities in view.
Krall also framed the bigger roster picture around the 2027 season, when Cincinnati expects to need help in the rotation, behind the plate and in the bullpen. Emilio Pagns future remains part of the discussion, but the Reds are not treating the offseason as a one-note exercise, with Stewarts next step looming alongside several other decisions that could shape how the club builds around its young core. [Read more 🡒]