Matt McLain was supposed to be in the Reds’ lineup Saturday night against the Milwaukee Brewers, batting seventh and starting at second base. Instead, Cincinnati made a quick change after the lineup was announced and removed him from the card.
Ke’Bryan Hayes slid into McLain’s spot, while Juan Brito moved over to second base after originally being listed at third. It was a sudden shuffle for a Reds team trying to keep things moving as the lineup took shape.
The change comes against the backdrop of a tough offensive stretch for McLain, even though he has held up well defensively this season. Through 123 games, he is hitting .188/.281/.343 with 32 extra-base hits, including 15 home runs.
That’s a long way from how he looked when he first arrived in 2023. In 89 games that year, McLain hit .290/.357/.507 and piled up 43 extra-base hits along with 16 stolen bases, making it easy to imagine him as a fixture in Cincinnati for years.
But the road since then has been rocky. A shoulder injury in Spring Training wiped out his 2024 season, and he spent time in the Arizona Fall League to get some reps.
Since that injury, he hasn’t produced at the same level. Over the last two years, McLain has posted an OPS well below .700, and at 27, it’s fair to question whether he’ll get back to the player he was in 2023.
While McLain’s status drew the attention Saturday, Eugenio Suarez keeps adding to his place in Reds history. His 211th career home run with Cincinnati pushed him past Hall of Famer Ken Griffey Jr. for ninth on the franchise’s all-time list.
Suarez also joined an exclusive club in team history, becoming just the ninth Reds player to appear in at least 1,000 games while recording 200 home runs, 600 RBI and 500 runs scored. The group includes Joey Votto, Frank Robinson, Johnny Bench and Tony Perez.
Cincinnati brought Suarez back on a one-year deal with a club option for 2027 this past offseason. He hasn’t quite matched the level the front office and fans were hoping for, but he has been better in the second half and has still delivered some big moments.
The Reds are likely to pass on that option after the season, which would send Suarez back into free agency.
In Other News...
Terry Franconas Reds Future Suddenly Feels Bigger Than This Season
Terry Franconas arrival in Cincinnati was always going to be about more than one season, but the discussion around his future is already stretching beyond the immediate push on the field. He has a guaranteed year left on his contract, along with a club option for 2028, and team president Nick Krall made it clear the Reds expect to keep talking with him about where this goes next.
Francona has also given the front office every reason to treat him like a long-term fit. He recently picked up his 2,103rd managerial win, and his relationship with the Reds brass has been described as strong, which matters in a job where trust can shape everything from roster planning to clubhouse tone. For now, Francona is focused on continuing to manage, but the fact that his future is already part of the conversation says plenty about how the organization views him. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Fans Just Got A Clearer Picture Of Who Controls 2027
Nick Krall gave Reds fans a little more clarity about the clubs long-term direction, saying he expects himself, the front office staff and the manager to be back for the 2027 season. For a team still sorting through its identity, that matters because it suggests continuity at the top even as the roster has lagged behind the rest of the division and the organization keeps trying to build around a small core of young players.
Krall also took responsibility for the clubs poor performance, a notable admission for a franchise that has spent much of this stretch looking for traction. Cincinnati has some financial flexibility to work with, but any plan to use it will have to account for a thin roster and the possibility of an offseason lockout, which could complicate how aggressively the Reds can reshape things before 2027 arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers And Rays Just Exposed The Reds Biggest Front Office Problem
The Reds keep finding themselves in the same conversation with the Brewers and Rays, two smaller-market clubs that have again shown how much can be done with sharp player development, disciplined roster building and a clear plan. Cincinnati has talent worth paying attention to, with names like Elly De La Cruz, Sal Stewart and Chase Burns giving the organization a real foundation, but the broader question is whether the people steering the ship are matching that upside with enough urgency and creativity.
For now, the expectation is that the current decision-makers will remain in place, even after another playoff outcome that leaves plenty of room for second-guessing. That matters because the critique around this front office is not about one move or one bad week, but about how the club uses its resources, how it chooses to spend and trade, and whether it can build a roster with the same kind of efficiency that keeps Milwaukee and Tampa Bay in the postseason picture. [Read more 🡒]