Ke’Bryan Hayes has given the Reds something to squint at lately, but the bigger picture still isn’t pretty.
For most of this season, Hayes has been a dead spot in the lineup. Through 68 games entering play on August 16, the Reds third baseman had reached base only 35 times and carried a -0.4 bWAR, which is already a career low.
The bat has been so quiet that the usual conversation around him has barely even been about production. It’s been about survival.
And yet, there is at least a small reason to think this might not stay this ugly forever.
After Hayes landed on the IL in May with a bulging disc, he spent time working with hitting coach Chris Valaika and made changes to his swing. The results were encouraging in a short minor-league rehab stint, where he hit .444/.450/.833 across two levels. That kind of burst hasn’t translated to the majors, but there are hints that something is moving in the right direction.
Statcast backs up the idea that Hayes has been better than his surface numbers show. Among hitters with at least 150 plate appearances this season, he’s been the unluckiest. His xBA and xWOBA are 100 points higher than his actual numbers, and his xSLG is almost 150 points higher.
The contact quality is part of the reason for that gap. Hayes is squaring up the ball at a strong clip, and when he does make contact, he squares it up 45.5% of the time, fourth-best in the majors.
That should be a good sign. The issue is that the ball still isn’t coming off his bat with much force overall.
His hard-hit rate sits at just 38.8%, which helps explain why the expected numbers are so far ahead of the actual results.
There’s also the back. Hayes has dealt with that injury for much of 2026, and it has been a recurring problem in his career. If a back issue is limiting the torque he can generate, that would fit the profile we’re seeing: a player who can put the bat on the ball, but not always drive it.
Still, the last few weeks have offered a real sliver of hope. Hayes is still putting balls on the ground and not consistently punishing pitches, but since July 26 he has hit three home runs, and all three left the bat at 100 mph or more. They also came against pitches that were each about 92 mph, which adds to the sense that the power is at least showing up in flashes.
If that keeps going, the numbers could start to move toward each other. The Reds may not get the disaster version of Hayes forever. At minimum, there’s a path here to something more usable than what they’ve had so far at third base.
In Other News...
Reds Offensive Collapse Is Putting Pressure On More Than Nick Krall
Nick Krall has spent the past year and a half shaping the Reds roster, so the criticism around Cincinnatis offensive slump naturally lands on the front office. The lineup has been near the bottom of the league in most categories outside of home runs, and the overall look of the group has too often been one-dimensional, a sign that the problem goes beyond one bad week or one cold stretch.
Chris Valaika, hired in October 2024 to lead the hitting operation, has also come under scrutiny as several key players have slipped instead of taking the next step. The deeper concern for the Reds is that the declines are showing up in different places across the roster, which makes this feel less like a single-player issue and more like a broader test of how the organization develops and maintains offense. [Read more 🡒]
Reds May End Up Regretting One Deadline Gamble With JJ Bleday
The Reds took a cautious route at the trade deadline, choosing not to shop many of their controllable pieces and instead dealing only veterans Nathaniel Lowe and Caleb Ferguson for modest returns. That approach fit a front office trying to preserve long-term value, especially with young talent still lining up behind the current roster. JJ Bleday was part of that equation, a controllable outfielder whose early-season production made him look like the sort of player a club would be smart to keep.
But Bledays recent stretch has made that decision look a lot less secure. After a strong start, he has hit a long skid since June, and the concern for Cincinnati is straightforward: if the slump keeps dragging on, the trade value they hoped to protect could keep slipping with it. The Reds did not have to move him, but standing pat only works if the player in question keeps enough shine for the next decision to matter. [Read more 🡒]