Joey Votto didn’t exactly hand Reds fans the kind of comfort food they were hoping for.
After a strong turn as a broadcaster during Sunday Night Baseball’s Reds-Cubs coverage, Votto drew praise for the way he broke down the game and carried himself on the mic. But the part that stuck with Cincinnati fans was his read on Elly De La Cruz’s future - and it wasn’t exactly reassuring.
Asked about the Reds’ chances of locking De La Cruz into a long-term deal, Votto was blunt.
"Unfortunately, we can't afford him. He would cost the GDP of a small country," Votto said.
A few days later, Votto went even further on social media and put a dollar figure on what he thinks De La Cruz could land in free agency.
"27/28 yo FA. Can play any position.
Arm + range are 80; those will age gracefully. Has averaged ≈ 5-6 WAR until 24.
One monster year and he's MVP-level. A >.500 SLG + a bit more defensive predictability + he's a clear top-3 player in the game.
Great makeup. My guess: 12/700," Votto wrote on social media.
That projection works out to 12 years and $700 million, a number that would make it clear just how hard it could be for the Reds to keep De La Cruz in Cincinnati if he keeps climbing.
The club has already tried. A couple of offseasons ago, the Reds offered De La Cruz an extension during spring training in 2025 that would have been the biggest contract in franchise history.
He turned it down, which wasn’t surprising with Scott Boras as his agent. Boras has a reputation for pushing clients toward free agency and squeezing out the most money possible.
De La Cruz remains under team control through 2029, but an extension now looks unlikely.
Votto has lived this kind of contract reality from the other side. His own 10-year, $225 million extension, signed in 2012, is still the largest deal in Reds history.
A $700 million price tag would blow past that by a wide margin.
Of course, De La Cruz still has years to go before free agency, and plenty can change before then. There’s no guarantee he ever reaches that level of payday.
Still, Votto’s message was hard to miss: if De La Cruz keeps developing offensively and becomes the player Votto thinks he can be, the Reds may eventually be staring at a problem they simply can’t solve.
In Other News...
Reds Give Carlos Jorge A Shot At A Role They Need Right Now
The Reds made a fresh roster move before opening their series against the Brewers, officially selecting Carlos Jorges contract and putting the 22-year-old prospect on the active roster. To clear space, Cincinnati optioned Ivan Johnson to Triple-A Louisville and shifted Michael Toglia to the 60-day injured list, a reminder that the club is still juggling bodies while trying to patch together a workable mix on the roster.
Jorge brings a different look to the group. A converted infielder with a reputation for defense and speed, he has played 88 minor-league games this season and sits just outside the Reds top-15 prospects. For a team that can use versatility and range right now, the move gives Jorge a real chance to show whether he can help fill a need that has become increasingly important. [Read more 🡒]
Matt McLain Just Became A Bigger Reds Concern Than Fans Expected
The Reds have already shifted into evaluation mode with the postseason looking unlikely, and that puts extra weight on the young players the front office expects to shape the next contending club. Matt McLain is right near the top of that list. After looking like one of the more promising pieces in his rookie season, he has not come close to carrying that momentum forward, and his struggles have become one of the more sobering storylines of Cincinnatis year.
Ryan Phillips of Sports Illustrated recently ranked the Reds 23rd in the league and singled out McLain as a player to watch over the final stretch, a sign of how central this turnaround has become to the teams bigger picture. The Reds need answers from him and from other young pieces before next season arrives, but McLains case stands out because the gap between what he once looked like and what he has been since has grown hard to ignore. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Got A Big Surez Moment In A Loss That Changed Nothing
Eugenio Surezs return to the Reds lineup carried a little extra weight on a night already packed with meaning for him, after he passed his U.S. naturalization exams and got back on the field against the Brewers. Cincinnati needed a lift, and Surez delivered one with a go-ahead three-run homer that briefly put the game in the Reds hands while also moving him into a tie with Ken Griffey Jr. for ninth on the clubs all-time home run list.
The momentum did not last, though, because Rhett Lowder had a rough start and the bullpen could not protect the lead in a 10-7 loss that left the standings unchanged but still stung. Even in defeat, Surezs night stood out as the kind of reminder that individual moments can matter in a season, especially when they come from a player whose place in Reds history keeps getting harder to ignore. [Read more 🡒]