The 2026 National League Rookie of the Year race has narrowed to a two-man argument, and the numbers are doing most of the shouting.
On one side is Cincinnati Reds All-Star slugger Sal Stewart, who has mashed his way to 27 home runs and a league-leading 94 RBI. On the other is St.
Louis Cardinals second baseman JJ Wetherholt, whose calling card is a slick glove and strong base running. Both have made a real impact in their first year in the majors, which is why the debate has gotten so loud between Reds and Cardinals fans.
That conversation came up during Wednesday’s game between Cincinnati and St. Louis, when Reds broadcaster Jeff Brantley made his own case for Stewart. He also managed to jab Reds third baseman Ke’Bryan Hayes along the way.
During the bottom of the fourth inning, Brantley and radio partner Tommy Thrall were talking through the Rookie of the Year chatter. Thrall said Stewart should be the clear choice if he keeps producing at the plate.
Brantley pushed back hard on the idea that Wetherholt’s defensive reputation should carry him to the top of the race.
"The only reason that Wetherholt is at the top of the list is because of a subjective look at defensive metrics," Brantley explained. "Everybody tries to talk about all this data.
About the defensive alignment, and how people catch the ball, and all of that. If the ball's not hit right at you, it's a base hit.
There are no errors given out anymore. It's crazy!
That's not a good case."
Then came the line that landed with Hayes in the crossfire.
"There is a chance Sal Stewart will have 30 home runs and 100 RBI, and you are going to tell me he is not the absolute blown-away front-runner because you got a guy that everybody says is fielding good? Come on, man!
You got to be kidding me. Then they should make Ke'Bryan Hayes the MVP," Brantley continued while Thrall chuckled in the background.
Hayes has built his reputation on defense, and his two Gold Glove Awards back that up. But his work at the plate has been a well-known issue, and Reds fans have plenty of opinions about that. Wetherholt is not being described as a star hitter, either, but Brantley’s joke made the point with a grin.
Stewart, meanwhile, kept his focus where it usually is. After a three-run homer helped the Reds pull out a 5-4 win, he said, "We haven't been playing to the best of our ability.
It hasn't been going our way, but we know we're better. It's not about me, it's about the fact that we won the game."
The argument may not be finished, but the numbers Brantley leaned on are hard to ignore: Stewart at .259/.334/.476 with 27 home runs and 94 RBI, Wetherholt at .243 with a .722 OPS. If the race stays this tight, the Reds broadcaster made it clear where he stands.
In Other News...
Reds Bullpen Churn Continues As Another New Arm Already Disappears
The Reds bullpen shuffle keeps rolling, and one of the newer additions is already out of the picture. Cincinnati brought in former Padres right-hander Ron Marinaccio to help stabilize the relief mix, but his time with the club was brief, as he was designated for assignment after only a handful of outings. It was the kind of quick turnaround that has become familiar for a pen that has seen a steady churn of arms trying to find a foothold.
Marinaccios departure leaves the Reds back at square one in that spot, with the roster spot opening as quickly as it was filled. Former Padres pitcher Matt Waldron is in a similar position with Toronto after being designated for assignment following four appearances, a reminder of how fragile these bullpen stops can be. For Cincinnati, the larger issue is not just losing a reliever, but doing so before there was any real chance to see whether the fit could last. [Read more 🡒]
TJ Friedl Has Become A Real Reds Offseason Problem
TJ Friedl entered the 2026 season as one of the more established pieces in Cincinnatis outfield, but the year has gone sideways in a hurry. After a far more productive 2025, his bat has backed up sharply, with less contact and far less pop than the Reds expected from him, and the club already tried sending him to Triple-A Louisville in an effort to help him find something closer to his old form.
Instead, the situation has only deepened the Reds winter dilemma. Friedl is no longer a simple lineup puzzle, because the organization has younger outfielders pushing for chances and more flexibility if it decides to move on from him, which means his place on the roster is suddenly tied to a much bigger offseason decision than anyone would have imagined a year ago. [Read more 🡒]