Former Reds Reliever Just Exposed A Tough Truth About Cincinnati

Emilio Pagn's move to the Tigers underscores the Cincinnati Reds' challenges in building a competitive bullpen and maintaining player loyalty.

Emilio Pagán didn’t just leave Cincinnati for Detroit. He left behind a pretty blunt reminder of where the Reds stand.

Pagán, who was coming off a $10 million option with the Reds, landed a one-year, $11.5 million deal with the Tigers after declining that option. For Cincinnati, that’s a painful number.

He wasn’t some bargain-bin bullpen arm; he was a true closer, and the kind of reliever who usually costs real money. Instead of keeping him in the ninth, the Reds watched him sign early in free agency, right as the league’s General Manager Meetings got underway.

That stings even more because the Reds already had bullpen issues to sort through. Pagán’s exit creates another major hole, and it’s hard not to notice that Detroit got him for just $1.5 million more than Cincinnati had on the table. After three seasons in the Queen City, that’s a tough one for Reds fans to swallow.

There are two ways to look at it. The optimistic version says Cincinnati can use that money elsewhere, which is fair enough given how many roster spots still need attention. But $11.5 million spread across three or four needs doesn’t exactly stretch far.

The harsher read is the one that always hangs over this franchise: the Reds wouldn’t pay up. But Pagán’s own words make it clear this wasn’t only about money, and maybe not even mostly about money.

“I know I can throw in the ninth. I also know I can do other things.

I’ve done it before,” Pagán told reporters in Detroit. “As long as we’re winning games and we’re battling for the division and in the playoffs, that’s all that matters to me.”

That’s the part Cincinnati can’t ignore. Pagán wanted a shot at winning, and after the Reds finished last in the NL Central at 75-87, it’s tough to argue he saw that path in Cincinnati. His follow-up comments made the picture even clearer.

"When the season ended, to be honest, I wasn’t sure what I was going to do. We leaned on my agent, Lee Long with Ballengee, and we came to the decision that it might be smart to be on the open market.

And even still, at that point, to be honest, I kind of thought I’d end up back in Cincinnati. Detroit was a team that I was very interested in.

We spoke with Detroit a good bit before I signed on with Cincinnati the last time, and so I had done my homework a little bit on the organization, on the team, on some of the players that were already there and some that are still on the way. There’s a lot to be excited about,"

That’s a lot to unpack, and not much of it flatters the Reds.

Both clubs were playoff teams in 2025 and both fell back in 2026, but they don’t feel like they’re heading the same direction. Detroit lost Tarik Skubal at the trade deadline, yet the Tigers may have uncovered another ace in Troy Melton, who just signed a six-year, $46.5 million extension after posting a 2.76 ERA over 20 starts. They also have the 2026 AL Rookie of the Year in Kevin McGonigle.

The Reds can point to their own young names. They have the NL Rookie of the Year in Sal Stewart and a more electric young ace in Chase Burns. But the gap shows up everywhere around them.

Detroit’s supporting cast is deeper. Riley Greene brings consistent power and three All-Star nods in the outfield.

Dillon Dingler has become an underrated catcher who might be the best two-way backstop in the league. Max Clark is another young piece on the rise, and the roster has veteran help around those core players.

The Tigers also have more coming. Pagán specifically pointed to the organization’s future, and Detroit’s pipeline includes River Ryan and Zyhir Hope from the Skubal trade, both of whom could matter in 2027. Max Anderson is another infield prospect worth watching, and Josue Briceño has a bat that could play even if he eventually moves off catcher.

That’s where the contrast gets harsh for Cincinnati. The Reds, according to this picture, don’t have the same wave of top prospects ready to arrive in 2027. When you stack the supporting cast, the future help, and the overall direction of the two organizations, Detroit looks like the club ready to push back into contention.

Cincinnati, meanwhile, is left with a much rougher question about how long it’ll take to get there. Pagán chose the rising team, and his decision says plenty about how he viewed the Reds’ path.

In Other News...

Reds Just Lost An Affordable Catching Option They Really Needed

The Reds are still trying to sort out their catching picture with Tyler Stephenson remaining a free agent, and the market has already taken one of the more practical options off the board. Chicago moved quickly to acquire Joey Bart after the White Sox designated him for assignment, which matters in Cincinnati because Bart had looked like the kind of low-cost, roster-friendly addition that could have helped stabilize the position without forcing the club to spend big.

For now, the Reds are left with Jose Trevino and Will Banfield on the 40-man roster, and neither profiles as an everyday answer on his own. That leaves Cincinnati in a familiar holding pattern at a spot where depth matters, especially with the team still looking for a dependable fit behind the plate and the list of affordable alternatives getting thinner. [Read more 🡒]

Reds Could Find An Infield Opportunity Fans Already See Coming

Major League Baseballs non-tender deadline always creates a little roster churn, and for the Reds it comes with a familiar kind of opportunity. Cincinnati is expected to keep all 11 of its arbitration-eligible players, which would leave the club in solid shape as it sorts out its 40-man roster and looks for ways to add depth without making a splashy move.

The more interesting wrinkle is what happens elsewhere. Several players around the league are being viewed as possible non-tender candidates, and that could put infield help within reach for a Reds club that has room to think opportunistically. Minnesota infielder Royce Lewis is among the names being mentioned in that bucket, and if the market opens the way some expect, Cincinnati could be one of the teams ready to poke around. [Read more 🡒]

Reds Just Sent A Tough Message About Their Roster Crunch

The Reds made an early roster decision that says plenty about how tight things are getting this winter, moving on from 22-year-old infielder Leo Balcazar by non-tendering him and clearing him off the 40-man roster. Cincinnati had protected Balcazar from the Rule 5 Draft by adding him last offseason, a sign the organization still saw a useful piece worth keeping in-house as he climbed through the system.

Instead, Balcazars 2026 season in Double-A and Triple-A did not match the trajectory the Reds had hoped for, and the front office chose to open a spot rather than carry him forward. It is the kind of move that can happen quickly in a crowded roster picture, especially for a young infielder whose stock had already started to slip after a step back at the upper levels. [Read more 🡒]