The Cincinnati Reds may not be done hearing Elly De La Cruz rumors anytime soon, and the latest chatter points straight to the offseason.
Former Major League general manager Jim Bowden said on 97.1 The FanLA that the Boston Red Sox made a serious run at De La Cruz before the August 3 trade deadline and got turned away. Bowden put it plainly: "The Red Sox and Craig Breslow did call the Reds at the deadline, and made an offer.
A very strong offer for him. They got turned down."
Bowden also said he believes Cincinnati will "absolutely" weigh moving De La Cruz this offseason. He referenced earlier reporting from The Athletic in which Bob Castellini asked Nick Krall and other members of the front office, "Why aren't we the Brewers?" According to that report, Krall answered by showing Castellini a long list of trades he had tried to make but that were vetoed.
There’s another reason the conversation keeps circling back now: De La Cruz already passed on the Reds’ attempt to lock him up long term. He’s represented by Scott Boras, which means he’s headed for the open market after his arbitration window ends following the 2029 season.
That’s why the timing matters so much for Cincinnati. If the Reds are ever going to cash in on De La Cruz, this is the moment when they have the most leverage. Wait too long, and the return only shrinks.
If a deal ever materializes, the Dodgers make the most sense as the team on the other side. Los Angeles has the prospect depth to swing a blockbuster and the money to chase De La Cruz again once he reaches free agency.
The obvious name everyone would want in that kind of package is Josue De Paula. The Reds would absolutely ask, and there’s no reason to think they wouldn’t push hard for him.
But the Dodgers view De Paula as a key piece of their future, and he comes with his own questions. He’s limited defensively, and his long-term home may wind up being designated hitter.
There’s also the reality that De Paula is already MLB-ready and considered a top-5 prospect in baseball. Building around him would change the shape of the return, and even Joey Votto floated the idea that a one-for-one swap for De Paula wouldn’t be outrageous.
A more realistic path, at least in this mock framework, would send Eduardo Quintero to Cincinnati instead. Quintero is 21, doesn’t chase, and put up a .942 OPS with 44 stolen bases in High-A last season. He’s also seen as a center fielder who can really defend, which would give the Reds something they’ve lacked since Billy Hamilton was roaming the outfield at Great American Ball Park.
And then there’s the twist that would make this even more interesting: Mike Sirota. The Reds sent Sirota and a draft pick to the Dodgers in 2025 in the Gavin Lux deal, and now there’s a path for Cincinnati to bring him back. Sirota has 20-20 potential, tore through the minors last season, and showed elite plate discipline with 100 walks and a .461 on-base percentage.
Another piece in the proposed return would be Davalan, the player selected with the compensatory pick Cincinnati sent to Los Angeles in the Lux trade. He hit .292/.402/.535 with 24 home runs and 72 RBI in the minors this season. A second baseman by trade, he’s spent plenty of time in the outfield too, though the Dodgers recently moved him back onto the infield dirt in the Arizona Fall League.
The final piece would be Christian Zazueta, who came to the Dodgers from the Yankees in 2024. He struggled in his first year in the United States, but since 2025 he’s been strong in Los Angeles’ minor league system.
This past season, he threw 103⅔ innings with a 3.65 ERA and 144 strikeouts. At minimum, he profiles as a back-end starter.
Put together, the package would include two top-20 prospects, with all four players landing among MLB Pipeline’s top 100. It’s the kind of deal that would make any near-term push look unrealistic, but given the state of the roster and the looming lockout, it may be the cleanest reset the Reds could choose.
In Other News...
Reds Infield Overhaul Could Hinge On One Surprising Market
The Reds infield picture is suddenly looking a lot less settled than it did a few weeks ago, with the club weighing how to replace KeBryan Hayes at third base while also sorting out what comes next at first. One option on the table is shifting Sal Stewart across the diamond, but the bigger ripple effect may come from how Cincinnati handles second base and Matt McLain, whose uneven play has made the position part of the broader offseason conversation.
That is where the market gets interesting for a team trying to stretch its budget without leaving holes elsewhere. If the Reds decide to add at second base, it could free them to solve more than one problem at once, and the pool of available options gives them a few different ways to do it. The question now is whether Cincinnati treats that spot as a priority or uses it as the key that unlocks the rest of the infield plan. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Suddenly Face A Costly Closer Decision This Offseason
Emilio Pagn gave the Reds a steady finish in the back half of the 2026 season, and that late surge has now turned into an offseason dilemma. His work down the stretch made him one of the more interesting bullpen arms on Cincinnatis market, and it also put the club in position to decide whether it wants to keep leaning on a veteran closer or shift the late-inning job elsewhere.
Cincinnati now has to weigh the cost of bringing Pagn back against the possibility that another team will push the bidding higher on the open market. If the Reds choose not to go that route, the conversation quickly turns to the internal options already in house, with the bullpen hierarchy potentially changing in a hurry before next season even begins. [Read more 🡒]
Emilio Pagan Just Put The Reds In A Tough Offseason Spot
Emilio Pagan gave the Reds exactly what they needed down the stretch, settling into the late innings and stabilizing a bullpen that had to lean on him heavily in the second half. His run was a strong one by any measure, with a 1.71 ERA, 18 saves and 29 strikeouts in 26 1/3 innings, the kind of finish that can change how a front office views the back end of a staff.
Now the question is whether Cincinnati gets to keep that version of Pagan around. He has declined his $10 million player option for the 2027 season and will become a free agent, leaving the Reds with a familiar offseason dilemma: try to bring back a reliever who looked like a fit in the ninth inning, or start mapping out a search for a new closer if he lands elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]