Stephen Vogt got the Guardians exactly where they wanted to be: Game 5 of the American League Division Series. The problem now is the part that comes next - figuring out how to get through it on the mound.
Cleveland’s 9-5 win over the White Sox on Thursday at Rate Field came with a heavy price tag. Vogt emptied plenty of his bullpen, stretched closer Cade Smith beyond the usual lane, and then had to call on Gavin Williams, the starter who had been lined up for Saturday’s winner-take-all game at Progressive Field, to finish the night.
That was not the original plan. Williams was supposed to stay on schedule for Game 5, with Vogt saying before Game 4 that he would throw a bullpen session during Thursday’s game if Cleveland was in position to win. Instead, Williams ended up warming in the ninth with the Guardians protecting a five-run lead and then took over in relief for the final three outs.
Does that mean he’s out as the Game 5 starter? Not automatically. But it definitely puts Cleveland in a bind.
“The script tonight got ripped up in the third,” Vogt said. “And when you have to go to the bullpen early, you’ve got to get creative in a win-or-go-home.”
The trouble began when rookie Parker Messick lost his command in the third inning, forcing Vogt to go to Shawn Armstrong earlier than expected. Cleveland later used three pitchers in the fifth, which kept chipping away at the group of arms it had left.
By the time the game reached the eighth, Vogt had already tapped into his high-leverage relievers. Hunter Gaddis was still available, and Daniel Espino was another possible option with Cleveland holding a comfortable lead. Vogt instead chose Smith.
That was notable enough on its own. Smith had thrown only 19 pitches while recording six outs, five of them strikeouts, in Wednesday’s Game 3 win.
On Thursday, he needed 19 more pitches to get through the eighth, then came back out for the ninth. That’s when the night turned.
Smith gave up a leadoff homer to Miguel Vargas and then walked Munetaka Murakami, which brought Vogt to the mound again. Williams entered from there, allowed a single to Sam Antonacci, struck out Andrew Benintendi on three pitches, got Kyle Teel to ground into a force out, and watched Braden Montgomery line out to Steven Kwan in left to end it.
Vogt said Williams was only available for one inning, though that still wasn’t the preferred route.
“Obviously, didn’t want to have to do that,” Vogt said. “But in that moment, with Cade - Colson Montgomery, it was a great at-bat off Cade pushing the pitch count up. It was time to go get Gavin.”
He added that he wanted Williams to face a hitter before the tying run could reach the plate.
Now Cleveland has questions hanging over two of its biggest pitchers. Smith finished Thursday with 31 pitches after also working two innings Wednesday.
Williams, who threw six innings in Monday’s Game 2 loss, now has just one day of rest after his relief outing before a possible Game 5 start. Vogt still said Smith would be available Saturday.
“Outside of Cade, don’t feel like we’ve really overextended too many bullpen guys,” Vogt said. “Cade is a warrior and he steps up for these guys every night, and I know he’ll be ready to go on Saturday.”
White Sox manager Will Venable noticed the workload Cleveland had to absorb just to keep the series alive.
“Small victories there, I think,” Venable said when asked about forcing Smith to work and getting Williams into the game. “I also think that those guys will be ready to go.”
Venable also said Sean Burke will pitch for Chicago in Game 5, though he did not officially name him the starter. Chicago will sort through its arms before settling on a plan.
Cleveland is in the same spot, only with its presumed Game 5 starter already used in emergency relief.
Vogt still could go back to Williams, maybe with a shorter leash than originally planned. Espino, Joey Cantillo and other available pitchers could also be part of another unconventional plan.
And if the Guardians get through Saturday and move on to face Tampa Bay in Monday’s AL Championship Series opener, the pitching puzzle gets even bigger. Vogt isn’t looking that far ahead.
“We’ll worry about that on Monday if we’re fortunate to get there,” Vogt said. “This is what playoff baseball is about. It’s about all hands on deck.”
In Other News...
Reds May Need A Different Player At The Center Of Their Future
The Reds have spent the better part of this rebuild turning over familiar faces and letting a new core come into view, with Elly De La Cruz, Chase Burns and Sal Stewart among the most notable names to emerge since 2022. It has given Cincinnati a different kind of optimism, but also a clearer sense of how much work still remains before the roster looks like a true contender again.
Stewart stands out because of more than just promise. His contract situation and the clubs current lack of depth make him look like the kind of player a front office can build around for the long haul, especially if the Reds decide the immediate path back to relevance is still too crowded to take in one jump. For a team trying to balance patience with pressure, the question may be less about who is already the face of the future and more about who should be at the center of it. [Read more 🡒]
Eugenio Surez And The Reds Suddenly Look Headed In Different Directions
The Reds decision to place Eugenio Surez on outright waivers before Sept. 1 and see no claim come in was another sign of how far the organization has drifted from the player who once helped define its infield. Surezs 2023 season was uneven, with injuries and performance issues interrupting any momentum he tried to build, and the front office has made clear it is chasing a different kind of lineup now. President of baseball operations Nick Krall has pointed toward a contact-first approach, one that simply does not fit Surezs profile.
A reduced-deal return to Cincinnati is still possible, which keeps the door from being completely shut, but the broader message is hard to miss. The Reds are not just sorting through one roster decision here. They are signaling a preference for a different offensive identity, and that puts Surez and the club on separate tracks as they look ahead to 2027. [Read more 🡒]
Reds May Need A Surprising Sal Stewart Shift To Fix The Lineup
The Reds are already looking ahead to 2027, and the focus may land on a familiar issue: third base. KeBryan Hayes has the position for now, but his offense has been a problem, which has pushed Cincinnati to think more creatively about how to reshape the infield if it wants more punch in the lineup.
One option gaining traction is a move that would send Sal Stewart back to third, where he has played before, and allow the Reds to shop for first base from a deeper pool. It is a notable pivot because finding a true impact third baseman through free agency or trade has not been easy, and Cincinnatis farm system does not offer an obvious immediate fix at the position. [Read more 🡒]