SAN FRANCISCO - Chase Burns did not just have a rough night. He took one of the worst beatings of his big-league season, and it came at a time when every inning feels like it matters a little more.
The Cincinnati Reds right-hander was chased in the fourth inning of a 5-0 loss to the San Francisco Giants after a barrage of hard contact turned his outing into a short, noisy mess. Burns, in his first full major league season, gave up two runs before recording an out and five runs before he could get through six outs against a left-handed Giants lineup that kept squaring him up. Even the outs came with authority, and Turner Hill sent a foul ball into the bay.
Until Thursday, the Giants had been the kind of offense a pitcher usually wants to see on the schedule. They came into the game last in the majors in on-base percentage at .305 and were the only National League team scoring fewer runs per game than the Reds, at 4.02 to Cincinnati’s 4.10.
“They kind of ambushed him early,” manager Terry Francona said. “You don’t see that very often.”
Francona said Burns was hurt by missing with his fastball in the zones the Giants’ left-handed hitters wanted and by sliders that weren’t as sharp as usual. The result looked a lot like the ugliest start of Burns’ career last year, when he failed to get out of the first inning at Fenway Park against the Red Sox while tipping his pitches in his second big-league start.
This time, Burns absorbed his third loss and saw his ERA climb to 2.77 from where it sat before the game. The former No. 2 overall draft pick, who signed a $105 million extension last month, had been in a tight race for the top spot in National League pitching WAR at 5.0, with Philadelphia’s Cristopher Sanchez at 7.1 and Milwaukee’s Jacob Misiorowski at 5.5. He also ranked third in ERA at 2.51, behind Misiorowski’s 1.68 and Atlanta’s Chris Sale at 2.20.
The schedule ahead is no soft landing. Burns’ projected remaining starts include the Cubs, the Brewers twice, the Dodgers and the Braves.
He has brushed off the Cy Young chatter all season. The larger concern for the Reds is making sure he gets through his first full season in the rotation and stays on track for the kind of long-term future the club wants to protect.
That’s part of why Francona pulled him in the fourth inning, with Rafael Devers due up again after homering against Burns in his previous at-bat. Burns had thrown 64 pitches and fought through 3 2/3 innings of traffic.
“Once I thought we could get through the game and not have it affect tomorrow, that’s when I went and got him,” Francona said.
Francona has said the club is keeping a close eye on Burns, though there is no “hard and fast” innings limit.
The goal, as Francona put it, is simple: finish the season still making starts.
“We don’t want to be messing around next year thinking, ‘God, we didn’t get him far enough,’ “ Francona said.
In Other News...
Sal Stewart Race Could Leave Reds Regretting More Than Award Snub
Sal Stewarts rise has put the Reds in the middle of a Rookie of the Year race that carries more weight than a typical award chase. Stewart and the Cardinals JJ Wetherholt have emerged as the leading candidates for the National League honor, and under the new Collective Bargaining Agreement, the winner can bring more than bragging rights to his club. A rookie with one year of service time who wins a major postseason award triggers a Prospective Promotion Incentive draft pick for his team.
For Cincinnati, that makes the finish line matter in a different way. Only the actual Rookie of the Year gets the extra pick, so the Reds are not just watching whether Stewart can claim the award, but whether they can turn a strong season into a future draft asset. If Wetherholt edges ahead, that bonus goes to St. Louis instead, leaving Cincinnati to think about more than just an award snub. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Suddenly Face A Bigger Michael Toglia Setback Than Expected
Michael Toglias time with the Reds has taken a sharp turn. After suffering a dislocated right shoulder in a game against the Diamondbacks, he was placed on the 10-day injured list, and now surgery will end his season. It is the kind of setback that changes the short-term picture for a club trying to keep moving, especially when a lineup piece disappears so abruptly.
The timing stings even more with the Reds coming off a win in which JJ Bleday hit for the cycle, a night that gave the dugout plenty to feel good about. Cincinnati will now have to carry that momentum into the next game with Chase Burns scheduled to start, while the larger question around Toglias recovery hangs over everything else. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Fans Just Got A New Reason To Debate Nick Krall
The Astros and Dana Brown going their separate ways before the 2026 season only sharpened a question that has been hanging around the Reds all year: how long does a front office get when the results do not match the expectations? Houston was still competitive in the AL West, yet the organization chose to make a change at the top, a reminder that teams do not always wait for a full collapse before rethinking leadership. For Cincinnati, it lands as an uncomfortable comparison because the Reds were supposed to be building toward something better under their current baseball leadership.
Nick Krall, promoted in 2023, has not delivered the kind of progress the Reds wanted, and the disappointment of the 2026 season has only turned up the noise. Even without a full teardown, the conversation now shifts from individual games to bigger-picture accountability, and that is where the Astros news becomes relevant to Reds fans. If Houston can decide a competitive club still needs a new direction, Cincinnati supporters are left wondering whether the same kind of threshold might eventually apply here. [Read more 🡒]