If you ask most people right now who the best shortstop in baseball is, Bobby Witt Jr. is going to come up fast. And it makes sense.
The Royals star is already a three-time All-Star, a two-time Gold Glove winner, a two-time Silver Slugger, the 2023 batting champion and last season’s Platinum Glove winner. He’s also finished second and fourth in AL MVP voting over the last two seasons.
But Joey Votto isn’t taking the standard answer.
The 2010 NL MVP joined MLB Now on Friday and made the case that Elly De La Cruz is the shortstop he’d put at the top of the list. Votto’s argument wasn’t built on hype alone. He pointed to the way Witt’s game fits Kauffman Stadium better than De La Cruz’s power-speed profile fits Great American Ball Park.
The numbers show why both players belong in the conversation. Through 134 games entering Friday, De La Cruz was hitting .284/.362/.517 with 29 doubles, 28 home runs, 74 RBIs, 150 hits, 26 stolen bases and a 142 OPS+. Witt, in the same number of games, was at .276/.359/.441 with 30 doubles, 18 home runs, 54 RBIs, 144 hits, 42 stolen bases and a 126 OPS+.
Votto’s point centered on the split between home and road production. Witt has been far more dangerous at home this season, batting .306/.376/.519 at Kauffman Stadium. On the road, he’s down to .245/.340/.360.
De La Cruz has been more balanced. At home, he’s hitting .301/.395/.544, and his numbers away from Cincinnati haven’t fallen off nearly as sharply. On the road, he’s batting .268/.329/.491.
Where Witt clearly separates himself is on defense. He ranks third in baseball with 22 Outs Above Average, fourth with a 16 Fielding Run Value and has 8 Defensive Runs Saved, according to FanGraphs. De La Cruz’s defensive metrics are more uneven: 8 OAA, tied for 33rd; 5 FRV, tied for 62nd; and -6 DRS.
That’s why Votto said defense is the final step for De La Cruz if he wants to join the game’s elite.
"That's probably the last piece of the puzzle [to put] him into the [Shohei] Ohtani, putting him in that [Aaron] Judge, putting him in that 'best player in the sport' -- Pete Crow-Armstrong -- category," Votto said.
In Other News...
Reds Just Made A Lineup Decision Fans Didn't See Coming
The Reds shuffled their roster in a way that changes both the dugout mix and the defensive options available to Terry Francona. Cincinnati optioned outfielder TJ Friedl and right-hander Julian Aguiar to Triple-A Louisville, then brought back right-hander Zach McCambley while also adding infielder and outfielder Oswaldo Cabrera after claiming him off waivers from the Yankees.
Francona sounded encouraged by Cabreras versatility, which could give Cincinnati another piece to move around as it sorts out the lineup and bench. The more interesting question is how quickly Cabrera gets folded into a meaningful role, because the Reds did not just make room for a fresh face, they signaled that they are willing to keep adjusting the roster in search of the right fit. [Read more 🡒]
Joey Votto Just Gave Reds Fans A Bigger Offseason Debate
The Reds offense has become a familiar contradiction this season: plenty of home runs and walks, but also too many empty trips, a league-high strikeout rate, and team ranks that sit low in runs scored and batting average. That imbalance has left Cincinnati searching for a cleaner way to build innings, and it has also reopened an old baseball debate about what matters most when putting together a lineup.
Joey Votto added fuel to it by making clear that he still views batting average as an important measure and believes the Reds should lean more toward contact hitting. For a club already trying to solve its offensive identity, that kind of advice lands in the middle of a bigger offseason conversation, one that could shape how the front office thinks about adding hitters who put the ball in play rather than simply waiting for the next big swing. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Keep Falling Short For One Reason Fans Cant Ignore
Defense has been the Reds quiet problem for a while now, and the numbers have tracked the unease. Cincinnatis Defensive Runs Saved under David Bell was a major issue in 2023 and 2024, then ticked up to slightly above average in 2025 after Terry Francona took over, which at least suggested some progress. For a team trying to build consistency, that kind of swing offered a little hope that the defensive floor had finally been raised.
Instead, 2026 has brought the concern roaring back. The Reds are sitting with the worst DRS in Major League Baseball, a brutal marker for a club that has already spent multiple seasons trying to climb out of this hole. Even with the improvement last year, the broader trend keeps pointing to the same uncomfortable reality: Cincinnati still has a defensive identity problem, and until that changes, every other part of the roster has a tougher path to carrying the team. [Read more 🡒]