The Bengals’ decision to keep Zac Taylor has turned into a fresh talking point, and CBS Sports’ Bryant McFadden didn’t waste much time going after it. In his view, Taylor enters the 2026 season with his seat already warming up.
McFadden pointed to the rest of the AFC North as the backdrop for that pressure. Every other team in the division has moved on from its coaching staff this offseason, while Cincinnati stayed put. He believes that if the Bengals miss the playoffs in January, ownership could decide it’s worth swallowing the final year of Taylor’s deal to make a change.
“Yeah, he survived basically because the organization is cheap, and they do not like to spend extra money,” McFadden said. “The reason why Zac Taylor makes this list for me is because when you look at the last three seasons there in Cincinnati, they've missed the playoffs three straight years in a row, and where they finish in the AFC North is a bit alarming.
Fourth, third, and third in those years; they missed the playoffs three straight years. That's where they finish in the AFC North.
He's only made the playoffs twice in seven seasons.
“Now, granted, in one of those playoff appearances, they made it to a Super Bowl, but that felt like it was 30 years ago, right? It's about what you're doing for me right now, and two teams fired their previous head coaches, and Mike Tomlin stepped down.
So for Cincinnati, it's imperative for you, led by Zac Taylor, to get off to a fast start. Something that has been an issue for them this season is being consistent.
And oh, by the way, they've revamped the entire defense.”
That last point matters. McFadden leaned into the Bengals’ defense as the issue, but Cincinnati has spent to the salary cap this year, largely because of the money poured into that side of the ball. Inside the building, there’s been plenty of confidence about the way it’s coming together, and the early signs have been encouraging.
There’s only one real data point so far - last Thursday against Detroit’s backups - but the Bengals held them to 14 points, including just six through three quarters.
McFadden still wasn’t backing off his criticism.
“Defense has been an issue for them. It feels like it's been an issue for 10 years, and Zac hasn't been there for 10 years,” McFadden continued.
“But it's been an issue for them. They spent a lot of money to improve the defensive area.
So now, Zac, you have to get it done. He's the most experienced coach in the AFC North.
He is the veteran of the group. He has star power on the offensive end.
The quarterback position, the wide receiver position. Brought in Dexter Lawrence, one of the more dominant interior defensive linemen in the National Football League.
Now it's time to get it done because I understand the cheapness of the organization kept his seat warm a year ago, but boy, if he flatlined again. Forget about being cheap.
They might be willing to pay to get him out of the building.”
Taylor does know the heat that comes with the job, and he’s already shown he can win big when the defense is doing its part. The Bengals reached the playoffs in 2021 and 2022, and one of those runs ended in a Super Bowl appearance. McFadden’s point is simple: that won’t buy much now if Cincinnati stalls again.
In Other News...
Bengals Roster Bubble Gets Real For 3 Players Against The Bears
With the starters expected to sit out against the Bears, Cincinnatis second preseason game shifts the spotlight to the players fighting for jobs a little deeper on the roster. For Landon Robinson, Dohnte Meyers and Colbie Young, this is the kind of night that can matter more than the score, because every snap is part of the case they are making for a spot on the final 53.
Robinson has offered the Bengals some intrigue as a defensive tackle who can also line up at fullback, while Meyers brings value with his ability to help as both a receiver and a returner. Young, meanwhile, is in a crowded wideout race and needs to keep showing he can carve out playing time. In a preseason where opportunities will be limited for many, these three have a chance to turn a routine August game into something much more meaningful. [Read more 🡒]
Bengals Still Have One Threat To Their Super Bowl Hopes
Protecting Joe Burrow remains the issue that hangs over the Bengals whenever the conversation turns from talent to staying power. JaMarr Chase underscored it again as Cincinnati looks ahead to 2026, and for good reason: the offense can still look dangerous on paper, but everything starts with Burrow being upright long enough to make it matter.
The Bengals did cut down on sacks allowed in 2025, yet Burrow still took 17 in eight games, a number that helped cut short his season and limited what the offense could become. Cincinnati has not made major changes up front, choosing instead to trust the lines cohesion, but until that unit proves it can keep Burrow clean, the teams Super Bowl hopes will keep feeling fragile. [Read more 🡒]
Bengals Defense Is Showing A Toughness Fans Have Been Waiting For
Cashius Howell has been one of the quieter stories of Bengals training camp, but the rookie defensive end is starting to make his presence felt. His growth showed up in a joint practice against the Bears, where Cincinnatis defense put together one of its sharper stretches and Howell was part of the pressure that helped set up an interception by Dexter Lawrence.
For a defense that spent last season trying to find more consistency, those late-practice sequences matter. The Bengals were working with better chemistry and a more decisive finish, and Howell pointed to that as the kind of standard that needs to carry over once the games count. [Read more 🡒]