Why Bengals Fans Are Split On Kyle Dugger Right Now

Former teammate Jason McCourty sheds light on how Kyle Dugger's extraordinary athleticism could make him a pivotal force in the Bengals' defense this season.

Jason McCourty thinks the Bengals may have landed a useful piece in Kyle Dugger, and he likes the fit for a reason that jumps off the screen: versatility.

McCourty, the former NFL defensive back and current ESPN analyst, joined the Bengals Booth Podcast with Dan Hoard this week and spoke at length about what his old New England teammate can add to Cincinnati’s defense. McCourty and Dugger were together with the Patriots in 2020, and McCourty came away with a lasting impression of Dugger’s athletic profile.

"He's a physical freak, and that was the one thing that was so impressive when he first got there," McCourty said about playing with Dugger. "Big safety can play in the box, but has the range and athleticism in the back end to get sideline to sideline, and I think for Dugger over these last few years, trying to find a fit within different schemes has been a bit of a challenge, and I think for him getting back to the basics, this is a spot where Cincinnati, I think, needed help at the safety position.

"Bryan Cook, a sure tackler, I think he's going to help a ton, especially with leadership in the back end, and you get a guy like Dugger, you have (Jordan) Battle there, Geno Stone struggled a little bit a year ago, so getting other guys in there that not only can play out there but also can force communication throughout that back end. I think Dugger, if he can get back to the player he was, he's a chess piece, not that he has to be a starter there, but if you have a guy that you can play in the box in some of those dime situations, but also a guy that you can play in base at safety, that scheme flexibility goes such a long way."

That kind of role would fit what Cincinnati appears to be after. Dugger has dealt with sub-50 Pro Football Focus grades over the last two seasons and has totaled just two pass breakups in that stretch, compared with nine across the 2022-23 seasons combined. Even so, there’s still a path for him to rebound as he enters his Age-30 season.

McCourty also made it clear he’s been paying attention to the energy Joe Burrow has brought throughout the offseason. With a revamped defensive group now in place to help support the offense, he sees reason for optimism around Cincinnati.

"I think just as an NFL fan, Joe Burrow is one of the very best players in our league," McCourty told Hoard. "So, hearing his excitement about this Cincinnati team, and I think a lot of analysts are excited about the moves they've made on defense, obviously, the returning stars that they have on the offensive side of the ball, but hearing Joe Burrow be that fired up about this team, just his offseason.

He's mentioned the Super Bowl multiple times. He's mentioned winning a ton of games in Cincinnati.

I think it goes a long way."

McCourty’s full conversation with Hoard is available on the Bengals Booth Podcast.

In Other News...

Bengals Took A Massive Swing To Save Burrows Window And Its Blowing Up

With Trey Hendrickson gone to Baltimore, Cincinnati had a clear incentive to get aggressive about fixing a defense that had been its biggest weak spot. The club answered by swinging for Dexter Lawrence II, a move designed to add real force up front and keep Joe Burrows window from narrowing any further.

Not everyone is sold on the price, and the debate around it has only grown louder since the deal was made. Some around the league see it as the kind of necessary gamble the Bengals had to make, while others have questioned whether it cost too much for a player coming off a down season. ESPN went as far as calling it Cincinnatis biggest and worst offseason move, which only adds to the pressure on the front office to make the bet pay off. [Read more 🡒]

Former Bengals Fan Favorite Faces A Brutal Test Of Trust

Jake Browning is trying to carve out a new role in Tampa Bay after his run as a Bengals backup made him one of the more familiar reserve quarterbacks around the league. Cincinnati fans remember the stretch in 2023 when he stepped in for Joe Burrow and helped keep the offense afloat, showing enough poise to make his case as a legitimate option whenever the team needed him. Now he is back in a familiar kind of competition, working behind Baker Mayfield as he looks to secure a place on the Buccaneers depth chart.

The wrinkle is that the job is not sitting there for Browning by default. Analysts around Tampa Bay see a real battle for the backup spot, with Connor Bazelak also in the mix, and Browning arrives with both proof of what he can do and fresh questions after a difficult recent stretch. For the Bengals, it is a reminder of how quickly a trusted reserve can move from being a safety net to a player with something to prove, and Browning still has a chance to show he can be that reliable option again if Mayfield ever goes down. [Read more 🡒]

Bengals Still Havent Made The Cheap Linebacker Move Fans Want

The Bengals have spent plenty of time talking around their linebacker problem, but the issue itself has not gone away. It remains one of the clearer weak spots on the roster, which is why the search for a fix keeps circling back to the same kind of affordable veteran help that could steady the middle of the defense without forcing a major roster overhaul.

One name that keeps surfacing fits that mold as well as anyone because of his background, athletic profile and recent production. He has moved around enough to offer some lineup flexibility, and the case for adding him is built on a blend of run support, coverage and pressure ability that the Bengals could use right now, even if the front office has so far stopped short of making the move fans have been waiting for. [Read more 🡒]