The Reds passed on one of the more obvious deadline moves Monday, and now they’re left with a Tyler Stephenson decision they can’t really duck much longer.
With catcher reportedly in demand around the league and Stephenson set to reach free agency after the season, Cincinnati chose to keep its starting backstop instead of moving him. Reds president of baseball operations Nick Krall said the club didn’t get an offer it liked before the deadline expired.
That leaves the Reds in a tricky spot, because if Stephenson walks, they’ll have nothing to show for a player who has given them a strong season. After a sluggish opening stretch, Stephenson is now hitting .256/.342/.417 with nine home runs, 32 RBI, and a 108 OPS+. His first two months were rough - a .629 OPS - but since June 1, that number has climbed to .913.
The bigger issue is what comes next. If Cincinnati doesn’t extend Stephenson, the depth chart gets awfully thin in a hurry.
Jose Trevino would be in line to handle the catching job in 2027, with journeyman minor leaguer Will Banfield as the only other backstop on the roster. Reds fans are eager to see Alfredo Duno make his Major League debut, but that may not happen until 2028 at the earliest.
That’s why the pressure now shifts to an extension, and quickly. A Stephenson deal has been floating around for years.
After he finished sixth in NL Rookie of the Year voting in 2021, plenty of fans wanted Cincinnati to lock him up. Then came the season-ending injury in 2022, which limited him to 50 games.
He hit just .243/.317/.378 in 2023, down from the .286/.366/.431 line he posted the year before. Stephenson bounced back in 2024, only to struggle again in 2025.
He’s making $6.8 million this season, and a two- or three-year extension could be the cleanest path forward for both sides. A deal with an average annual value around $10 million might be enough to get it done. With money coming off the books this offseason, the Reds have the room to make it happen.
In Other News...
Bengals WR3 Battle Is Suddenly Putting Real Pressure On Someone
As the Bengals edge toward their first preseason game, the competition for key backup roles is starting to sharpen, and a few young players are making that evaluation a little more interesting. Colbie Young has put together a promising run in practice, giving Cincinnati another name to watch in the mix behind the top receivers while the staff keeps sorting through the rosters deeper options.
The pressure is most noticeable in the receiver room, where the battle for the No. 3 spot has become less about theory and more about daily execution. Andrei Iosivas has had trouble with drops, which opens the door for Young as the preseason gives the Bengals a better read on who can be trusted when the games start counting, and the same sort of momentum has been building on defense with Cashius Howell standing out as the team continues to evaluate its young talent. [Read more 🡒]
Bengals Linebacker Concern Just Turned Into A Bigger Roster Question
The Bengals have spent much of the summer protecting the offensive core while remaking parts of the defense, and the linebacker spot has become one of the more interesting places to watch. With changes already underway up front, Cincinnati has also seen young linebackers Barrett Carter and Demetrius Knight Jr. settle in and give the staff a better feel for what this group can become.
Still, the question is bigger than just the two youngsters developing in camp. Even with the internal growth, there is a real case for adding a veteran presence at linebacker, both for depth and for the kind of mentorship a seasoned player can bring to a changing room. Bobby Wagner is the name that keeps surfacing in that conversation, and it leaves the Bengals weighing whether to trust the progress they have seen or make another move to steady the position. [Read more 🡒]
Amarius Mims Rise Could Create A Bengals Cap Problem Soon
Amarius Mims has turned a forced opportunity into one of the more encouraging developments of the Bengals season. The rookie right tackle stepped in after Trent Browns injury and has handled the job well enough to make Cincinnati think beyond the immediate fix, because a young lineman who looks like part of the long-term answer can quickly become a lot more than that when it is time to pay him.
The timing matters because the Bengals already have several important contract decisions lining up, and the salary-cap picture could get crowded in a hurry. Chicagos recent commitment to Darnell Wright offered another reminder of how expensive dependable offensive tackles can become, and Cincinnati will have to weigh how much room it wants to reserve if Mims keeps moving toward that kind of tier. [Read more 🡒]