Giants Fans Already Think Bengals Took A Risky Swing On Defense

Giants fans remain skeptical as the Bengals bank on Dexter Lawrence to revitalize their defense amidst lingering doubts surrounding his recent performance.

The Bengals made one of their biggest defensive bets of the offseason when they traded for Dexter Lawrence, a move designed to give a shaky unit a real jolt. Cincinnati needed help up front, and Lawrence’s arrival was supposed to answer that need with a proven pass rusher and a three-time Pro Bowler.

But not everybody in New York is mourning the deal. Jake Elman of GMEN HQ, FanSided’s Giants-focused site, argued that Lawrence’s absence from the NFL Top 100 is a sign the Giants were right to move on.

“We’re nearly halfway through this year’s rankings, and Lawrence is nowhere to be found,” Elman wrote. “And although the NFL’s Top 100 isn’t to be taken as gospel, Lawrence’s looming omission speaks to a broader point...

Seeing as the players vote on the NFL Top 100, it’s especially telling that they didn’t force Lawrence onto the list based solely on his reputation.”

That line of thinking is hard to ignore, even if the Top 100 has never been a perfect measuring stick. It’s the same list that somehow had Lamar Jackson at No. 69, which tells you plenty about how much weight it deserves. Still, Elman’s larger point was clear: Giants fans believe the Bengals may have overestimated what they’re getting.

There is some reason for concern. Lawrence did have a down year in 2025, and that matters for a Cincinnati defense trying to climb out of the hole it’s in.

At the same time, the bigger body of work is why the Bengals made the move in the first place. Before last season, Lawrence had been a force, and his career-high nine sacks in 2024 showed exactly why he was such an attractive target.

Now it’s on Cincinnati to prove the gamble was worth it. The Bengals need their defense to be better this season, and if Lawrence can get back to the level he showed before 2025, the move could look a lot smarter by the end of his first year in stripes.

In Other News...

Tee Higgins May Have Earned His Own Bengals Touchdown Call

JaMarr Chase already has a touchdown line that Bengals fans know by heart, and it has become part of the fun whenever Cincinnatis passing game hits big. Now Tee Higgins may be next in line for a call of his own, with the conversation sparked by the upcoming Coyote vs. Acme movie and a Tweety Bird bit that feels tailor-made for a receiver who keeps finding the end zone.

Higgins has put together plenty of scoring production over the last two seasons, including a strong finish last year, which is why the idea has some traction. The suggested phrase would play off the trailers wordplay and give announcers another easy hook, though the real question is whether it catches on the way Tony Romos Chase is on the case! did for Chase. [Read more 🡒]

Bengals Still Have Two Camp Holes Fans Can't Ignore

Training camp has a way of exposing the same kinds of roster questions every summer, and for Cincinnati the focus is again on two spots that could use more certainty before the pads come on. The offensive line still needs dependable depth behind the starters, and the linebacker group could use another body who can compete for snaps and hold up if injuries hit.

One path to smoothing both areas is the trade market, where a few low-cost names could make sense if the Bengals want to add competition without paying a premium. Arizona linebacker Owen Pappoe and Atlanta tackle Jack Nelson have both been floated as fits, with each viewed as the kind of move that would not force Cincinnati to spend much more than a late pick while still giving the roster a better chance to weather camp and the season ahead. [Read more 🡒]

This Bengals Rookie Could Change More Than Fans Realize At Camp

Colbie Young has barely settled into Bengals training camp, but the rookie wideout is already part of a conversation Cincinnati has been trying to sort out since spring. A fourth-round pick, Young arrives with the kind of size and catch radius that can change how a passing game looks, and he gives the Bengals another body to consider behind Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins as they sort through the rest of the receiver room.

The bigger question is how much room there really is for another target to carve out a meaningful role. Andrei Iosivas has been working to hold his place in the rotation, while Mike Gesickis presence gives Joe Burrow yet another option in the middle of the field. If Young can translate his camp work into steady production, Cincinnati may end up with a deeper receiving group than many expected when camp opened. [Read more 🡒]