The Cincinnati Bengals spent the offseason getting plenty of attention for their defensive line moves, but the real wager in this rebuild was sitting one layer behind it.
Rather than chase a pricey veteran linebacker, Cincinnati stayed put with Barrett Carter and Demetrius Knight Jr. That choice looked bold before the season. After one game, it looks even better.
In Sunday’s 33-27 win over the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Knight delivered Cincinnati’s first touchdown of the season by scooping up a Baker Mayfield fumble and returning it 27 yards for the score. The play started when Myles Murphy and Carter helped collapse the pocket, forcing the mistake and giving Knight the opening.
Carter made his own impact soon after. Early in the second quarter, he chased Mayfield down near the Cincinnati goal line, stripped the ball loose and set up Bryan Cook to recover it in the end zone. It was the first forced fumble of Carter’s NFL career, and it helped the Bengals force turnovers on three straight Tampa Bay possessions.
That kind of production is exactly what Cincinnati was chasing when it reshaped the front seven. The Bengals did not replace Carter and Knight after their rookie seasons. Instead, they loaded up in front of them with Dexter Lawrence II, Jonathan Allen and Boye Mafe, betting that the added muscle on the defensive line would keep blockers off the linebackers and let them play faster.
Duke Tobin spelled out the thinking earlier this offseason.
"Probably the best thing we did for our linebacker room is what we did for the D-Line room, and that's going to elevate those guys," Tobin said earlier this offseason.
Week 1 gave that idea real life.
Knight had already shown plenty as a rookie, finishing 2025 with 106 tackles, three sacks and two interceptions. Carter was right there too, piling up 102 tackles.
But Cincinnati wanted more than steady production from the pair in Year 2. It wanted game-changing plays.
It got them right away.
That is what makes the Bengals’ decision so intriguing. They were not asking Carter and Knight to become different players. They were counting on a better defensive front to help them become better versions of themselves.
Carter and Knight also seem tightly connected, and Carter’s reaction to Knight’s touchdown said plenty about that bond. Speaking to CLNSCincy.com's Mike Petraglia, Carter said:
"Damn near brought a tear to my eye. That's my brother.
I'm glad that we were able to make that play, and I mean this in the most humble way possible but we as a defense, we expect to make that play. Those are the plays that is going to get our team to be playing in late February.
So I'm so glad that we kickstarted the season with D-Knight scoring a touchdown. That's my brother for life, and it means the world that he was able to scoop and score."
For one Sunday against Tampa Bay, the formula worked exactly the way Cincinnati imagined it would: a disruptive line, two young linebackers flying around behind it, and a defense that turned pressure into points.
It is only Week 1, but the Bengals’ biggest defensive gamble is already paying off.
In Other News...
Bengals Already Have An AFC North Problem After Week 1
Week 1 did the Bengals no favors in the AFC North race. Baltimore and Pittsburgh both opened with wins, while Cleveland stumbled badly, leaving Cincinnati to take a hard look at a division that already looks like it could be unforgiving from the start. The Ravens got the kind of offensive performance that can set a tone early, and the Steelers leaned on T.J. Watts disruptive afternoon to make their own statement.
For the Bengals, the early standings are only part of the concern. The divisions top end already looks sharp, and even the Browns issues only underline how difficult every week in the North is going to be. Cincinnati does not have much room to waste time sorting itself out, because the teams around it have already begun piling up reasons to make the path to the division feel steep. [Read more 🡒]
Bengals Suddenly Have A Valuable Trade Chip As QB Chaos Spreads
Joe Flacco has become one of the more interesting names sitting around the Bengals quarterback room, not because Cincinnati needs him to start, but because he has shown he can step in and handle the job on short notice. With multiple quarterbacks on the roster and practice squad, the Bengals are in a position that has suddenly drawn more attention than usual as the rest of the league scrambles to stabilize behind center.
Around the NFL, several teams are dealing with injuries and uneven play at quarterback, and that has created a market for veteran depth in a hurry. Flaccos experience makes him an obvious fit for clubs looking for a ready-made option, whether through a trade or another roster move, though no deal has been confirmed and Cincinnati still appears to be holding its cards for now. [Read more 🡒]
Amarius Mims Is Forcing A Bengals Decision They Usually Avoid
Amarius Mims looked every bit like a player who has changed the conversation around the Bengals right tackle spot in his preseason debut against Tampa Bay. He handled his pass protection cleanly and did not allow a pressure, a promising sign for a player whose game has been trending in the right direction since late 2025.
For Cincinnati, the bigger issue is what this kind of development eventually forces them to consider. Mims is not even in extension territory until 2027, but the market for tackles with his profile already points to a hefty price range, and that number could keep climbing if franchise-tag costs rise the way they are projected to. The Bengals usually prefer to avoid getting boxed into a costly decision early, yet Mims keeps making it harder to ignore what comes next. [Read more 🡒]