The idea sounds far-fetched on its face, but the Bengals could at least think about it: a trade that sends Shemar Stewart to Carolina after the Panthers lost his Texas A&M teammate Nic Scourton.
Cincinnati took Stewart 17th overall in 2025, while Carolina grabbed Scourton at No. 51.
The two rookie paths already look dramatically different. Scourton’s season is over after he tore his ACL on the first day of Panthers training camp, and Stewart has had a rocky start of his own after going down with an injury in training camp.
Zac Taylor expects Stewart back sooner rather than later, but the situation has still put his future in a strange place.
That’s where the trade idea comes from. It would be a wild move, and one the Bengals almost certainly won’t make, but the concept isn’t completely without precedent.
Trading away a first-round pick just one year later is rare, yet it has happened before. The Dolphins were involved in the two most recent examples: Pittsburgh sent Miami a first-round pick for safety Minkah Fitzpatrick in 2019 after Fitzpatrick had been the 11th overall pick in 2018, and Tennessee later dealt offensive lineman Isaiah Wilson, the 29th overall pick in 2020, to Miami.
Before that, Cleveland moved Trent Richardson, the third overall pick in 2012, to Indianapolis in 2013 for a 2014 first-round pick.
Scourton’s injury changes the Panthers’ equation. He had shown promise as a rookie, finishing with five sacks, 47 tackles, and seven tackles for loss before the ACL tear shut down any chance of building on that year.
Carolina now has a hole to fill, and that could push it toward a player with name value, upside, or both. Stewart fits that profile.
The Panthers hosted him for a top-30 visit before the 2025 draft, so the interest was real once already.
For Cincinnati, the timing matters too. Stewart’s trade value may never be higher than it is right now, even with the injury.
The longer the Bengals wait, the more that value could slide. And if they chose to cut him instead, the financial hit would be brutal: a $10.3 million dead cap charge.
A trade would be much cleaner, with Over the Cap projecting a $2.6 million dead cap penalty. Cincinnati is already carrying $10.4 million in dead money for Trey Hendrickson ($5.6M), Logan Wilson ($4M), and Jermaine Burton ($526,690), and that total will rise when final cuts begin.
The Bengals can absorb the hit more easily than most teams. They’re $17.4 million under the cap, according to Spotrac.
Stewart’s 2026 cap number is $4.3 million, and Carolina has $10.3 million in cap space to work with. There’s also the bigger roster picture in Cincinnati, where the team still has to work out extensions with DJ Turner, Dax Hill, and Chase Brown.
Still, nobody should expect a massive return if this ever became real. Carolina probably wouldn’t part with a first-round pick, even if the fit made sense. A Day 2 pick would be the more realistic prize, with a backup tackle or a linebacker also mentioned as possible compensation.
It’s a long shot, but the logic is there: Carolina has a need, Stewart has upside, and Cincinnati has to decide whether keeping a troubled first-rounder is worth the roster and cap cost.
In Other News...
Marvin Lewis Reopened A Bengals Debate Fans Know Too Well
Marvin Lewis has reopened one of the Bengals most familiar arguments, and this one goes straight to the heart of how the franchise has operated for years. In talking about Mike Browns approach, Lewis pointed to the long-term planning that has defined the organization, along with a reluctance to spend freely that often shaped how the roster was built and maintained.
Lewis also tied that philosophy to the departures of players during his time in Cincinnati and to the playoff frustrations that followed. The interesting part now is the contrast with the Joe Burrow era, when the Bengals have been more aggressive with spending and roster upgrades, a shift that suggests the franchise knows it has been pressed to adapt even if the old debate never really goes away. [Read more 🡒]
Bengals O-Line Stability Around Joe Burrow Suddenly Feels Far From Settled
The Bengals came into camp talking about continuity up front, with the same offensive line group back from last season and a blend of veteran experience and younger talent around Joe Burrow. But the early buzz has not been about a locked-in five so much as a steady stream of competition, with newcomers and developing players like Demetrius Knight and rookie Parker drawing attention as coaches sort through who can actually hold down key roles.
Health has only added to the uncertainty, since availability and performance have already been tied together in the early stages of camp. For a line that was supposed to offer more stability, the picture now looks much more fluid, and Cincinnati still has some sorting to do before it can feel good about how protected Burrow will be when the games start counting. [Read more 🡒]
Bengals Enter Final Roster Crunch With Tough Decisions Still Looming
The Bengals head into their final preseason game against the Eagles with one more chance to sort out the edges of the roster before the real decisions arrive. Cincinnati has looked organized through camp and is chasing its first undefeated preseason since 2006, but the bigger focus now is the 88-man group that must be trimmed to 53 within 48 hours after the game.
Plenty of spots are still up for grabs, with competition extending beyond the starters and primary backups into the roster bubble and practice squad conversation. The final tune-up should help clarify a few position battles, but for several players, the Eagles game is less about the scoreboard than making one last case before the Bengals start making cuts. [Read more 🡒]