The Bengals don’t just have a special teams problem after Sunday’s 30-27 loss to the Steelers. They also have a personnel problem, and it’s showing up in how they’re using their tight ends.
Erick All Jr. looks like the more complete option, but he’s still getting fewer snaps than Drew Sample by a wide margin. That’s the kind of decision that stands out when you watch Cincinnati try to piece together an offense that keeps leaving points out there.
Sample has been on the field far more often, including 29 snaps against Pittsburgh compared with 12 for All. The issue isn’t that Sample is some dominant blocker carrying the run game on his back.
He isn’t. His PFF run-blocking grade sits at 58.4, and his pass-blocking grade is a rough 26.5 on 13 reps this year.
All, meanwhile, brings more juice. His run-blocking grade is 45.1, but the bigger difference is what he offers as a receiver and as an athlete. He’s the kind of tight end who can actually stress a defense, while Sample has been described as the opposite of explosive.
That matters because Cincinnati’s play-action game has not been working, and the offense has been leaning more on heavier personnel and snaps under center. When the Bengals line up that way, the tight end in the flat or as the outlet is often Sample, and that’s not exactly a matchup defenses are losing sleep over.
The result is predictable: teams can see run coming more often, which hurts Chase Brown, and Cincinnati can’t punish defenses off play-action when Sample is the one most likely to be asked to handle that role.
The numbers only sharpen the point. Sample finished last season with 15 catches on 20 targets for 106 yards and a touchdown in 17 games. Through three games in 2206, he already has four catches, but they’ve gone for only 19 yards.
All’s usage has been limited, but there are signs of what he can add. He’s already gotten two designer touches on screens for five yards.
As a rookie playing on a bad knee, he caught 20 passes for 158 yards. Now he’s healthier than he’s been in years.
And that’s the part that should matter most for Cincinnati. All can help in the run game, but he also gives Joe Burrow another viable target and makes the offense harder to predict when the Bengals go under center. That would let them avoid so many uncomfortable pure dropback situations and take some pressure off the quarterback and the line.
At this point, the case is pretty simple: the Bengals should be playing Erick All Jr. more.
In Other News...
Joe Burrow Clutch Debate Just Took A Turn Bengals Fans Needed
Joe Burrows latest showing against Pittsburgh fit the familiar Bengals frustration chart: plenty of production, a strong statistical line, and still a loss after a late fumble swung the finish. In the aftermath, one of the numbers making the rounds was especially harsh, painting Burrow as 1-34 when trailing in the final eight minutes, a stat that quickly took on a life of its own among fans looking for answers about how he closes games.
Ryan Fitzpatrick pushed back on that framing, breaking down Burrows late-game drives and finding a very different picture. His review showed Burrow successfully tied or took the lead in 18 of 27 such chances, a reminder that the biggest clutch debate around Cincinnatis quarterback may be more complicated than a single ugly record suggests, even if the result in Pittsburgh left the conversation hanging. [Read more 🡒]
Bengals Head Into Jaguars Week With Two Major Lineup Questions
Cincinnati kept working through its prep for Jacksonville with the injury report still shaping the week. Dalton Risner is expected to miss the game because of a knee injury, while DJ Turner was limited with a hamstring issue, leaving the Bengals to sort through a couple of important lineup questions as they move toward Sunday.
Joe Burrow and Zac Taylor both weighed in on where the team stands and how it is approaching the matchup, underscoring that this is the kind of week when practice availability matters almost as much as the game plan. The Bengals still have time to settle things, but with a key blocker sidelined and a defensive back managing a soft-tissue injury, the final look of the roster remains something to watch. [Read more 🡒]
Bengals Receiver Injuries Just Put Burrow In A Familiar Spot
The Bengals had to make another quick adjustment at wide receiver after injuries thinned the room around Joe Burrow, prompting the club to sign Mitchell Tinsley to the active roster. Andrei Iosivas is on injured reserve, Colbie Young has been ruled out for the upcoming game against the Jacksonville Jaguars, and the timing leaves Cincinnati again leaning on depth at a spot that has already been tested this season.
Burrow, who has spent plenty of time working through shifting targets and shuffled personnel, offered support for Tinsleys return and pointed to what the receiver has already brought to the team. For a Bengals offense trying to stay on schedule, the move is less about adding a headline name than about keeping enough reliable pieces in place to keep the passing game moving into a game week with some uncertainty still hanging over it. [Read more 🡒]