Getting the opponent behind the chains is supposed to be the defense’s friend. Force a sack, make a stop on early down, draw a penalty - then squeeze the life out of the drive.
For the Bengals, though, opponents had too many chances to climb right back out of that hole.
In 2025, Cincinnati’s defense faced 21 drives where the other offense started in first and 15 or worse. Fourteen of those drives still ended with a first down, which means the Bengals gave one up two-thirds of the time.
That was the painful part of the answer to a fan query from X user @layneherdt, who asked how often the Bengals let opponents convert after getting into first and 15 or longer. The short version: more often than you’d want.
The Bengals offense had its own version of the same problem 15 times. Cincinnati moved the chains on eight of those drives, a 53.3 percent success rate, and finished with points six times, or 40 percent.
The list of defensive failures reads like a tour of too many familiar kinds of trouble.
Cleveland got the Bengals into first and 20 after a holding penalty, then Joe Flacco kept the drive alive with a 13-yard completion to Cedric Tillman on third and 9. That possession ended in a 5-yard touchdown pass from Flacco to Tillman, part of a 69-yard march in 13 plays that gave the Browns a 16-14 lead.
The Browns also opened one drive at their own 31, then worked through a first-and-15 situation and eventually tied the game at 7-7 early in the second quarter on a 16-play touchdown drive finished by a 1-yard run.
Minnesota found a way to survive being behind the sticks more than once. Carson Wentz hit T.J.
Hockenson for 13 yards on first down, and the Vikings later converted a third-and-1 before settling for a 35-yard field goal. They also got into a manageable third-and-7 before a false start and a Kris Jenkins sack forced a punt.
Just before halftime, they squeezed enough out of another drive for a 62-yard Will Reichard field goal. And with backups on the field and the game already out of hand, the Vikings still ran it on first and 15 and second and 15 before a short completion and a punt.
Denver had its own mixed bag. Bo Nix found Troy Franklin for 23 yards on second and 17, and the Broncos later reached first and goal at the 11.
But Demetrius Knight intercepted Nix on fourth and 1 at the 2 with 1:58 left in the first half. On another possession, Denver completed a 5-yard pass on third and 14 before punting.
A third-and-20 checkdown left the Broncos with fourth and 11, and that drive ended the same way.
The Jets turned first-and-15 into something far more manageable with a Breece Hall 9-yard run and a 5-yard Justin Fields pass, then cashed in on third and 1 with a 2-yard Fields run. That drive reached the Cincinnati 6 before New York settled for a 24-yard Nick Folk field goal and trimmed the lead to 24-16.
Chicago also found ways to work out of trouble. Kyle Monangai ran 9 yards off right tackle to convert a third-and-5. Later, after a Caleb Williams completion to Colston Loveland and a scramble by Williams, the Bears moved the chains again with a 10-yard pass to Cole Kmet and eventually got a 24-yard Cairo Santos field goal with 1:29 left before halftime, after missing a 47-yard try earlier.
Pittsburgh made the Bengals pay for a roughing-the-passer penalty by Myles Murphy, which turned the situation into an immediate first down. A 31-yard catch by Darnell Washington followed, and the Steelers eventually reached the Bengals 7 before settling for a Chris Boswell field goal with 0:10 left in the half. Later, Kenneth Gainwell turned a screen pass into a 28-yard gain on first down, and two plays after that Mason Rudolph hit Gainwell for a 5-yard touchdown and a 27-12 lead.
New England handled first-and-20 the efficient way: Drake Maye threw a 23-yard pass to Hunter Henry right away. The Patriots then bled 7:06 off the clock and added a 19-yard field goal to go up 23-13 with 5:55 left in the game.
Baltimore had one drive where it got 10 yards on first down but still ended in a three-and-out. Another time, Lamar Jackson erased the problem immediately with a 44-yard catch-and-run to Derrick Henry. That drive got all the way to the 15-yard line before Demetrius Knight intercepted Jackson on third and 9.
Buffalo also got itself out of trouble quickly. After Josh Allen scrambled for 8 yards, DJ Turner II was flagged for illegal use of hands, giving the Bills a first down at the 17.
Later, the Bills reached first and goal at the 2 before Turner forced a James Cook fumble that Oren Burks recovered. Buffalo needed one play on another drive, a 31-yard pass from Allen to Dalton Knox, to get to first and goal at the 8, and four plays later Allen hit Jackson Hawes for a 3-yard touchdown with 3:03 left for a 39-28 lead.
Arizona, meanwhile, had a routine three-and-out when time before halftime was tight.
For the Bengals, the bigger takeaway from the numbers is simple: getting an offense behind the chains didn’t nearly end enough drives. And when Cincinnati’s own offense landed in that same spot, it only solved the problem a little more than half the time.
In Other News...
Bengals UDFA Battle Just Got Tougher Than Fans Expected
The Bengals post-cuts scramble often turns on the margins, and this years undrafted class has a few names worth tracking as the team sorts out its initial 53-man roster and practice squad. Jamal Haynes, Liam Brown, Isaiah Nwokobia and Jack Dingle each bring a different kind of appeal, from college production to positional fit, which is why the staffs evaluation matters so much once the deadline starts forcing hard decisions.
Brown has a path if Cincinnati wants more competition on the interior line, while Nwokobia at least gives the secondary another option to consider as the safety room gets sorted out behind the established names. Haynes has some intrigue, too, but his frame and protection concerns make the road steeper than it looks on paper, which leaves one of the group standing out as the most realistic bet to survive final cuts, even if the order of the pecking line is still part of the suspense. [Read more 🡒]
Bengals Suddenly Have A Tough Decision On Howard Cross III
Howard Cross III came into the offseason as the kind of under-the-radar defensive tackle who could carve out a role with effort, leverage and enough disruption to stick around. But the Bengals have changed the math on him in a hurry, adding Dexter Lawrence, Jonathan Allen and Landon Robinson to a group that already includes draft picks Kris Jenkins Jr. and McKinnley Jackson, which has turned an already crowded room into a much tougher climb for an undrafted free agent.
Cross still has one thing going for him: familiarity with defensive coordinator Al Golden, a connection that gives him a clearer path than most fringe linemen would have at this stage. Even so, the Bengals have loaded up on interior help, and the question now is whether Crosss specific skill set is enough to separate him from the pack before roster decisions get serious. [Read more 🡒]
Lamar Jacksons Paycor Success Just Took On A More Frustrating Meaning
Lamar Jacksons run at Paycor Stadium keeps leaving Bengals fans with the same uneasy feeling, because every trip there has ended the same way. He is 4-0 in road starts against Cincinnati at the venue, a mark that puts him in rare company among quarterbacks since 1970 and helps explain why Baltimore always seems to carry a different edge into this matchup.
The frustrating part for Cincinnati is how close that kind of dominance is to getting even more lopsided. Neil ODonnell still owns the best road record against the Bengals at 6-0 in Cincinnati, while Jackson could move into a smaller group of quarterbacks with a 5-0 or better road record against one team if he keeps the streak going. [Read more 🡒]