The Bengals have one area where they’re reasonably stocked and another that suddenly looks a little thinner, and that gap has sparked a trade idea worth kicking around.
A to Z Sports’ John Sheeran floated a deal that would send Shemar Stewart to the New York Giants in exchange for slot cornerback Dru Phillips, a 2027 sixth-round pick and a 2028 fourth-rounder.
The logic is simple enough: if Cincinnati adds a slot defender, Dax Hill can slide back outside, which would cut down on the need to lean on reserve corners on the boundary. That possibility has become more relevant after injuries to Jalen Davis and Ja’Sir Taylor forced the Bengals to reshuffle their secondary.
Phillips has also done his part to make the idea attractive. According to Sheeran’s report, he has allowed a 63.6 passer rating in coverage this season.
Stewart, on the other hand, has barely been on the field. He has played just 17 defensive snaps through five games, with eight of those coming against Miami. That limited usage is what makes him a logical name to surface in a hypothetical trade discussion, even if dealing away a young pass rusher carries obvious risk.
In the end, it would amount to Cincinnati swapping developmental upside for immediate help at a more vulnerable spot on the roster.
Even so, Sheeran said he doubts the Bengals would actually consider moving Stewart this early in his career. Still, the proposal frames the deadline question neatly: how much should Cincinnati give up from a position of depth to firm up its secondary?
In Other News...
Bengals Fans Have Real Draft Reasons To Watch Ohio State-Indiana
Ohio State and Indiana may be meeting for reasons that go far beyond the Big Ten standings for Bengals fans who have already started thinking about next spring. The game offers a useful look at a cluster of draft-eligible prospects who could line up with Cincinnatis roster needs, and the Bengals recent draft history only adds to the appeal as they continue sorting through where help might be needed.
Among the names worth tracking are Austin Siereveld, Amare Ferrell and Jermaine Mathews, each of whom could draw Bengals attention for different reasons. Sierevelds versatility makes him a logical offensive-line watch, while the secondary picture could be just as relevant depending on how Cincinnati navigates several looming decisions there, making this one of those college matchups that feels a little more important in Cincinnati than it might elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]
Bryan Cooks Bengals Role Just Got Even More Emotional
Bryan Cooks arrival in Cincinnati already carried a local angle, but the timing only adds to it. The Bengals are trying to stabilize a defense that has been hit by injuries, and an early bye week gives the staff a little breathing room as it sorts through the next stretch of the schedule. For a safety viewed as a key piece on that side of the ball, the setting is about more than just fit on the field. It is also about stepping into a room that needs help and doing it in front of the people who know his background best.
Cooks role comes against the backdrop of a Bengals season still taking shape, with the early returns from the draft class under the microscope and a matchup with the Tennessee Titans coming up soon. Around the league, roster movement is happening everywhere, but Cincinnatis interest is more immediate: how quickly the defense can get healthy, how the younger additions hold up, and how much Cook can matter once the games get tighter. [Read more 🡒]
Bengals Have An Unexpected Amarius Mims Problem To Fix Fast
Amarius Mims has already become one of the Bengals more important young pieces up front, but lately the conversation around him has taken an odd turn. The offensive lineman has had multiple in-game cleat failures that have forced him off the field, creating a problem Cincinnati cannot afford for a player expected to help stabilize the line.
Offensive coordinator Dan Pitcher acknowledged the issue and the ripple effect it can have in the middle of a game, when every snap matters and substitutions are never ideal. The Bengals are expected to handle it quickly, because whatever the fix ends up being, they need Mims available and on the field rather than dealing with equipment trouble at the worst possible moment. [Read more 🡒]