The Cincinnati Bengals find themselves in a bit of a pickle, needing a versatile linebacker who can double as an elite pass rusher. The solution might just be lurking in the form of a trade, but it comes with a catch-they'd have to negotiate with their archrivals, the Pittsburgh Steelers.
The player in question is Nick Herbig, a linebacker who might be available for the right price. But trading within the division is always tricky. The Bengals would likely need to part with a draft pick, perhaps a third-rounder, or sweeten the deal with a young player still on a rookie contract.
Herbig, drafted in the fourth round in 2023, has shown impressive potential. Last season, he recorded 30 tackles, 7.5 sacks, 13 tackles for loss, and 18 QB hits over 15 games, starting in six.
His edge-pass-rush win rate of 25% led the NFL, even though he only played on the edge 12% of the time. These stats make him a prime candidate for the Bengals, who are eager to bolster their defense.
The appeal of Herbig is clear. He’s young, versatile, and still on his rookie contract.
However, he’s currently behind T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith on the Steelers' depth chart, limiting his starting opportunities.
A move to Cincinnati could offer him the starting role he desires, lining up in multiple linebacker positions.
A trade for Herbig would also mean negotiating a new contract, as he’s heading into the final year of his rookie deal. His market value is estimated at $55.9 million over four years, aligning with recent deals like Devon Lloyd's with the Carolina Panthers.
The Bengals have shown interest in upgrading their linebacker corps, but free agency didn’t pan out. A trade for Herbig could fill this gap effectively, offering a proven player over the uncertainty of draft picks. If their scouting suggests no better options in the draft, Herbig could be the answer to their needs.
Yet, trading with the Steelers is no small feat. The rivalry adds a layer of complexity, especially with past tensions over trades like the one involving Joe Flacco. The Steelers might demand a high price, knowing the Bengals' desperation.
Despite the challenges, the Bengals need to be proactive. Picking up the phone and engaging in tough negotiations with the Steelers could be the first step toward solving their linebacker dilemma. Herbig’s potential impact on the Bengals’ defense makes this an opportunity worth exploring, even if it means dealing with a bitter rival.