The Cincinnati Bearcats got knocked back to reality on Saturday in a 49-25 loss to No. 6 Utah, and the biggest problem was hard to miss: they simply didn’t execute on third down.
Cincinnati finished 3-for-11 on third down, a rough 27.2% that left too many drives going nowhere. Utah, meanwhile, stayed in control by going 7-for-11, good for 63.6%.
That gap told a big part of the story. The Bearcats were never able to string together enough clean possessions to keep pace.
There were bright spots on the ground, starting with Cole Tabb. He continued to look like one of college football’s standout running backs this season, piling up 131 yards on just 14 carries. That works out to 9.4 yards per carry, and he added one touchdown to the total.
Gi’Bran Payne also had production with 67 rushing yards, but his fumble undercut the day and wiped away a lot of the momentum he had built. For Cincinnati, that kind of mistake was costly in a game where the margin for error was already thin.
The Bearcats’ offense is at its best when the short passing game is sharp and the run game is humming behind one of the country’s best offensive lines. But when an above-average defense starts forcing problems, the whole thing can unravel fast.
That’s what happened here, especially with two turnovers in the second period and a defense that couldn’t slow Utah down. The result was a 28-point second quarter that blew the game open.
Viewed in the context of the season, the loss is easier to stomach. If someone had told Cincinnati on October 18, the day after its 45-42 loss to West Virginia, that it would split the next two games against No.
8 Texas Tech and No. 6 Utah, most UC fans would have taken it.
But taken on its own, Saturday was another reminder that this team has been wildly inconsistent for much of the 2026 season. That’s the frustrating part. The Bearcats have shown enough to make you believe, then turned around and let games slip away in ugly fashion.
Now they finish with No. 18 Houston, Iowa State, Colorado, and No.
8 BYU still on the schedule. There’s still a chance for Cincinnati to put together its best record under Scott Satterfield, but the big question remains whether the Bearcats can play well enough on both sides of the ball to do it.
In Other News...
Can Jerrod Calhoun Finally End Cincinnatis Big 12 Frustration
Jerrod Calhouns first full season at Cincinnati is already being framed by the same question that has hovered over the program since it entered the Big 12: can the Bearcats turn promise into a conference season that actually changes their standing? The early read on 2026-27 is encouraging enough to keep hope alive, with a schedule that gives Calhoun a chance to show whether his group is ready to handle the grind and the expectations that come with it.
The nonconference slate should tell part of the story, but the bigger test is what happens once league play begins and the margin for error disappears. Cincinnati is still chasing its first NCAA Tournament appearance under Calhoun, and the broader goal is more than just getting back to March - it is proving the Bearcats can stack enough Big 12 success to stop living in the leagues middle ground. [Read more 🡒]