The White Sox made their trade deadline move with October in mind, and that’s why Huascar Brazoban’s uneven first month in Chicago has landed with such a thud.
Chicago didn’t bring him in to cover filler innings in August. It sent right handers Gabe Davis and Zach Franklin to the New York Mets for a reliever it believed could steady the back end of the bullpen, especially with the AL Central lead in play.
On the surface, the deal checked out. Brazoban had posted a 2.56 ERA in 46 appearances for the Mets, giving up just 15 earned runs over 52 2/3 innings while striking out 49.
That looked like the profile of a veteran arm Will Venable could lean on in tight spots.
The problem is that version of Brazoban hasn’t shown up consistently since the trade.
Before he went on the injured list with a left lat strain on August 25th, he had a 6.30 ERA and 1.80 WHIP in his first 10 innings with the White Sox. The control backed up the ugly numbers, too: six walks, five strikeouts. Those are not the kind of stats that inspire confidence with a one-run lead and the postseason looming.
There was at least a small sign of life Sunday in Detroit. Brazoban came off the injured list and threw a scoreless inning in Chicago’s 8-1 win, allowing one hit and no walks as the White Sox took three of four from the Tigers. For a team trying to sort out its October bullpen, that was a welcome step.
But it was still just one inning.
That’s what makes this such a tricky call for Venable. Brazoban’s work with the Mets suggests there’s a useful reliever in there, but Chicago hasn’t seen enough of that pitcher to hand him the ball with real confidence.
The recent struggles were also more than a one-game blip. Brazoban allowed runs in four of his final five outings before landing on the injured list, giving up seven hits, five earned runs, five walks and two home runs while recording only two strikeouts.
Then he spent almost a month away from a major league mound.
Now the White Sox have to make a decision fast. With six games left after Sunday’s win, they sit one game behind Cleveland in the AL Central and hold a three-game edge for the final American League Wild Card spot.
They got what they wanted at the deadline: meaningful games in September, and potentially October. What they still need is proof that Brazoban can be trusted in them.
Venable doesn’t need Brazoban to replicate his entire Mets season in a week. He just needs enough clean outings to know whether the reliever Chicago paid for is actually back.
In a postseason bullpen, there’s not much patience for trial and error. One walk, one missed spot, and the game can flip in a hurry.
Sunday helped. A couple more outings like that would help a lot more.
Until then, Brazoban remains one of the White Sox’s most uneasy October questions. They already paid the price in prospects for his early-season work with the Mets.
They can’t get that back. What they can still get is a reliever Venable trusts when the games get bigger.
In Other News...
White Sox Make A Surprising Lineup Bet Against Kansas City
The White Sox head into a three-game series at Kauffman Stadium with an eye on a Kansas City pitching staff that is still settling into roles. Chicago announced a balanced lineup against a left-hander, with Miguel Vargas leading off and Randal Grichuk hitting third, a setup that gives the order a different look than usual while the club tries to find the right mix against the Royals.
Kansas Citys probable options add another layer to the matchup, with Anthony Kay coming in after a rough stretch and Daniel Lynch working as a starter since the trade deadline. For Chicago, the question is whether this lineup construction can give it an early edge in a series where the pitching matchup may be just as fluid as the batting order. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox Face A Real Playoff Roster Debate Over Acuna
As the White Sox chase both the AL Central lead and a postseason berth, Luisangel Acuna has become one of the more interesting roster questions on the board. The young outfielder and shortstop has not given the club much at the plate this season, with a .227/.260/.261 slash line and a .522 OPS, but his profile still carries a skill set Chicago cannot ignore when games tighten up.
Acunas speed is the obvious counterweight to the offensive numbers, since he ranks in the 98th percentile for sprint speed and could offer value as a late-game baserunner in October-style situations. For a team trying to balance present production with roster versatility, the debate is less about whether he has tools and more about how much those tools matter if the White Sox get into a short series and every bench spot starts to count. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox Enter A Final Week That Could Change Everything
The final week has arrived with the standings still packed tight enough to keep the White Sox on edge, and the broader playoff picture only adds to the tension. In the National League, the main field is largely settled, while in the American League the Rangers are hanging onto the West by a game and the Guardians are just ahead of Chicago in the Central.
For the White Sox, the more important race is the one they are trying to hold onto themselves. They sit in the final wild-card spot, with Houston, Toronto and Baltimore all close enough to make every result matter, and the tiebreakers hanging over the bracket only sharpen the stakes. It is the kind of last week that can change not just a seeding line, but the entire shape of October. [Read more 🡒]