Mike Vasil’s hopes of securing a spot in the rotation were unfortunately cut short by an elbow injury that requires Tommy John surgery. In response, manager Venable announced that lefty Sean Newcomb will be taking on a role in the bullpen. Meanwhile, Jonathan Cannon has been optioned to Triple-A Charlotte, where he'll start the season.
This move doesn't come as a major surprise. Newcomb initially aimed for a rotation spot, but after Chicago secured a $1.5 million deal with Fedde, the bullpen seemed a more likely destination for him.
Newcomb’s Spring Training was less than stellar, giving up 10 runs (eight earned) over 12 innings. In contrast, Fedde delivered 8 2/3 innings with just three runs allowed, seven strikeouts, and two walks.
Kay, who returned from NPB with a two-year, $12 million contract, was essentially locked into the rotation. The former Mets’ first-round pick has impressed the most during camp, allowing only four runs and leading the team with 15 strikeouts over 16 1/3 innings. His fastball has been clocked at an average of 95.4 mph, showcasing his potential impact.
Other rotation contenders haven't stood out as much. Smith is the clear choice for Opening Day starter after a strong rookie season.
Although Fedde struggled last year, he’s only a year removed from a solid 2024 split between the Sox and Cardinals. Martin and Burke, considered fringe starters, have outperformed Cannon, who had a decent but unremarkable Spring Training with 11 innings, five runs, and a 10:5 strikeout-to-walk ratio.
The White Sox are in a rebuilding phase, integrating promising offensive talents, but their pitching still lags behind. On paper, this rotation might be the weakest in the American League. However, the addition of Kay brings an intriguing element, and acquiring mid-level pitching prospect David Sandlin by taking part of Jordan Hicks’ contract in a trade with Boston adds depth.
Sandlin, optioned early in Spring Training, could be a candidate for a midseason call-up if he performs well in Triple-A. Prospects Hagen Smith and Noah Schultz, though non-roster invitees, have significant potential. They face challenges with command but are eager to bounce back from inconsistent 2025 minor league seasons.