White Sox Prospect Voting Is Starting To Reveal A Real Divide

Jaden Fauske overtakes Tanner McDougal in the South Side Sox Prospect Vote, as up-and-comers continue to shuffle the rankings.

Jaden Fauske finally punched through in Round 7 of the 2027 South Side Sox Prospect Vote, and he did it by the slimmest of margins. With 26 of 77 votes, Fauske edged Tanner McDougal after a late deadlock and became the first outfielder to move on. His total came out to 34%, five more than the previous round’s winner, William Bergolla Jr.

That result also keeps Fauske’s stock moving in the right direction. The second-round pick from 2025 was already the No. 11 prospect in last year’s vote, and now he’s climbed into the next tier. The voting board itself barely shifted, though there was one notable new wrinkle: Joely Volchko picked up his first votes of the year, and righthander Mathias LaCombe, who is from France, joined the ballot.

The top of the board remains crowded with familiar names. Caleb Bonemer leads the way at 71%, followed by Roch Cholowsky at 75%, David Sandlin at 30%, Billy Carlson at 38%, William Bergolla Jr. at 27%, and now Fauske at 34%. Each of them drew support from a spread of challengers, but none could catch the leaders.

Some of the most interesting movement in the system comes from the players who have already made their cases in different ways. Casteel, for instance, is the kind of prep arm teams dream about landing in the $150,000 round of 10 picks.

The White Sox had been in regular contact with him, and once the first round broke the right way, he became a realistic target. MLB had him at No. 162 overall, which makes him look like a bargain against his 315th-pick slot.

He brings power and control, and in a system short on pitching, that profile stands out even more.

LaCombe’s path was unusual in another way. He climbed more levels in 2026 than any other White Sox prospect, and more than anyone else the team has tracked in this format over the past few years.

That says plenty about where he started, with just 53 ⅓ pro innings entering the season, and about how well he settled in once he got rolling. His late promotion to Charlotte had more to do with Rule 5 maneuvering than pure performance, but a jump of that size still deserves credit.

Lodise also made a strong impression in his return to Winston-Salem in 2026. His first full professional season went very well, built on a low average and plenty of power.

He fits the organization’s preference for aggressive swings, but he also brings enough selectivity to post huge on-base numbers. The power, too, is looking better than expected.

McDougal’s story is more complicated. He was important enough to reach Chicago in the second half of 2026, but the season did not go the way the organization had hoped.

Forearm tightness knocked him out for weeks early on, and while it did not lead to a second TJS, it derailed what had looked like a straight path to the South Side rotation. For the rest of the year, he was used as a relief arm, and not a particularly steady one.

His brief Chicago cameo ended with one out recorded and three walks.

Javier Mogollón continues to push upward despite a smaller frame and a couple of seasons interrupted by hamstring trouble. The 21-year-old second baseman reached Winston-Salem in 2026 and posted 91 games of production across Low-A and High-A: 14 homers, 57 RBI, a .262/.368/.448 line, 36 steals in 44 tries, 53 walks, 123 strikeouts, and 2.5 WAR. He also returned before the season ended and helped fuel a title run, batting .313/.389/.813 with eight RBI during the stretch.

Cole Prosek, a 19-year-old third baseman from Magnolia Heights, arrived with a monster high school line: 18 homers, 79 RBI, a .545/.678/1.177 slash, 62 runs, seven steals, 31 walks, and just 12 strikeouts in 41 games. Though the White Sox list him as a second baseman, he spent plenty of time at third in prep ball and also has experience behind the plate. Evaluators appear to like him more than Landon Thome, the first-rounder taken ahead of him.

Thome, also 19, put together a huge high school season at Nazareth Academy with seven homers, 29 RBI, a .545 average, and 49 steals in 50 attempts. The pairing of Thome and Fauske on the same ballot is unusual enough on its own, but the White Sox went even further to get Thome, dealing 2023 first-rounder Jacob Gonzalez to Pittsburgh to acquire the pick. He is better known for speed and defense than for power, though the bat is expected to grow.

Volchko remains one of the more intriguing arms in the group. The big right-hander can hit 100 mph and was ranked by MLB as a second-round talent, 68th overall, even though wildness likely pushed him to the White Sox in the third round.

He also delivered a complete-game effort against the University of Texas to help the Bulldogs earn their first College World Series win in 18 years. The organization may eventually use him in high-leverage relief, but he’ll get every chance to start.

Weingartner and George Wolkow were both prep targets who came in lower than their rankings suggested, and both required strong bonuses to pull them away from college. They also share another trait: big arms.

Weingartner even pitched for his St. Augustine Hermits in 2026.

Wolkow’s 2026 season was all about power, even if it came with real tradeoffs. He gave up speed and some of the batting eye he once had, and the raw results were loud enough to show up in the counting stats. But the swing hole is still there, and if the White Sox are asking him to lean almost entirely on his best tool at the expense of everything else, he’s drifting into the Colson Category.

In Other News...

White Sox May Be Eyeing Another Pitching Move Fans Should Watch

The White Sox have already shown they are willing to keep an eye on the Japanese market, and it makes sense given how much attention that path has gotten around the league. After the clubs interest in Munetaka Murakami, Chicago also sent scouts to take a look at right-handed pitcher Kaima Taira, another name drawing notice in Japans Pacific League.

For a team still trying to build out its pitching depth, the possibility of adding help from overseas is the part worth watching. Taira is one target, but he may not be the only one on the White Sox radar, with Shota Imanaga also mentioned as a free-agent possibility if Chicago decides to keep pressing in that direction. [Read more 🡒]

White Sox Rotation Search Just Added Another Intriguing Free Agent

The White Sox are still combing the free-agent market for starting pitching, and the list of names tied to their rotation search keeps growing. Chicago has been connected to several arms as it looks to add a starter who can help stabilize the group, with the club clearly aiming higher than a simple stopgap and hoping to find someone who can fit near the top or middle of the staff.

One more intriguing possibility is Dustin May, a right-hander with recent postseason experience who would bring a different look to the mix. For the White Sox, though, he appears to be more of a depth target than the headline move, which leaves the bigger question of which arm ultimately becomes the priority as the offseason unfolds. [Read more 🡒]

White Sox Rotation Search Just Took An Intriguing Veteran Turn

The White Sox are still casting a wide net in their search for starting pitching, and a veteran name has now surfaced as part of the mix. On the CHSN White Sox Podcast, ESPNs Jesse Rogers said Chicago is talking to free agent right-hander Nick Pivetta, a sign the club is leaving no stone unturned as it tries to bolster a rotation that needs more certainty.

Pivettas appeal is easy to understand for a team looking for help without getting locked into a long-term mistake. He is entering his age-34 season and comes with a recent track record that includes a breakout year in San Diego, though injuries have complicated the picture since then. The White Sox are still weighing internal and external options, so this remains one piece of a broader pitching search, but it is the kind of veteran turn that can matter if the price fits. [Read more 🡒]