Rikuu Nishida’s path to becoming a real part of the White Sox picture is going to look different from the usual prospect story. The 11th-round pick from the 2023 draft is still on MLB Pipeline’s Top 30 list, has climbed to Triple-A, and already got a brief look in the majors earlier this year when Chicago needed another outfielder. He even looked like a candidate for another call-up when September rosters expanded.
But the obstacle is obvious, and it’s the one thing that keeps evaluators from projecting him as an everyday regular: power, or really the lack of it. Nishida carries a 20-grade power tool, the lowest possible mark on the 20-80 scouting scale, and that kind of offensive profile usually makes it hard for a player to stick in a starting role. His overall FV grade is 40, which generally points to a bench player.
The numbers tell the story. Nishida has hit exactly two home runs as a pro, one in Single-A Kannapolis in 2024 and one in his Triple-A debut in Charlotte.
He appeared in 12 games for the White Sox this season and didn’t record an extra-base hit. In Charlotte, where he has spent most of the year, he has six doubles, two triples and that lone homer, which adds up to a .323 slugging percentage against a .289 batting average.
Rikuu Nishida had his arm tested early in his debut …
And he threw a perfect strike 🎯 pic.twitter.com/mXLtABXEIJ
- MLB (@MLB) May 25, 2026
That kind of power output makes Nishida unusual, even with his speed. The more useful question is whether players with that same weakness have found ways to matter in the majors. The answer is yes, but only if something else in their game is loud enough to carry the load.
Ozzie Smith is the most generous example. He played 19 seasons, reached the Hall of Fame and finished with just 28 home runs.
Even so, he wasn’t a strong offensive player by the numbers otherwise, with a .666 career OPS, an 87 OPS+ and a .337 on-base percentage. What made him special was defense: he was probably the best defensive shortstop ever.
That kind of greatness can cover for almost anything.
Nishida doesn’t have that kind of defensive home. He’s mostly played second base and the corner outfield spots, and those corner positions usually come with more bat than glove.
Second base is more up the middle, but it still doesn’t carry the same value as shortstop or center field. So the challenge for Nishida is different.
He doesn’t need to become a legend. He just needs a role that makes sense.
That’s where Myles Straw comes in as a better comparison. Straw is in his ninth major league season and also came up with 20-grade power.
He’s a multi-position defender, though center field is his most common spot, and he’s solid without being elite. At the plate, he brings on-base ability that looks a lot like Nishida’s.
Straw’s career line is .245/.314/.319/.634 with a 77 OPS+.
He doesn’t usually play every day, but he does get regular big league run. That’s the lane Nishida is trying to find. If Straw is the right comp, Nishida may never be an everyday player, but he could still be a useful piece on a major league roster.
There’s also a small bit of encouragement in Straw’s power track record. Even now, after years in the majors, he rarely leaves the yard.
His career high is four homers, and he has had seasons with none at all. In 2022, he played 152 games without a home run.
He was even lighter on power in the minors, never hitting more than one in a season before reaching the majors. That leaves open the possibility that Nishida could add a little more pop with more chances, which would help his offensive line look a lot more workable.
Still, the key to Nishida’s future is not going to be power alone. It’s the skill that already stands out: his on-base ability.
He also runs well, and his OBP has often sat at or above .400. This year in Triple-A, it was .424 against tough competition.
That kind of table-setting skill matters. It can change an inning and it can change a roster spot.
He doesn’t look like a starting right fielder or even a starting second baseman, but there’s a clear path to usefulness. Nishida could fit as a platoon leadoff type against left-handed pitching, and that would still count for a lot.
If the White Sox can find more playing time for him in 2027, that OBP could translate into real value. Nishida’s game is built around a skill set you don’t see every day, and that alone gives him a chance to carve out a future.
In Other News...
Guardians Just Made This White Sox Division Race Personal
With two games left in the regular season, the AL Central race has turned into something more than a simple standings watch for the White Sox. Chicago has stayed alive by winning its recent games and, importantly, it still owns the head-to-head tiebreaker over Cleveland, which means the path to the division title is still there even with the Guardians holding a one-game edge.
Cleveland helped create the latest layer of tension by finishing off Kansas City with a five-run ninth inning built mostly on walks and a two-run double from Angel Martnez. Martnez then added fuel during the clubhouse celebration when he was caught on camera making a disparaging comment about the White Sox, a moment that only sharpened the edge of a race already tight enough to make every out feel personal. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox Remember A Former Infielder Who Took An Unusual Path
Jeoff Long, a former infielder who spent time with the Cardinals and White Sox, died Sept. 25 in Elsmere, Ky., at age 84. His baseball path was a little different from most, starting out as a pitcher before he made the switch to the infield and eventually reached the majors for parts of two seasons.
Longs baseball career was only one chapter of a longer life. After he left the game, he became an accomplished amateur golfer and later worked in management for the Cincinnati Drum Company, leaving behind the kind of off-field resume that fit his uncommon route through the sport. [Read more 🡒]
Colson Montgomerys Breakout Now Comes With A Brutal White Sox Concern
Colson Montgomerys season has become one of the more fascinating power-and-miss stories in the league, a reminder that a breakout can still come with a glaring flaw attached. The White Sox infielder has piled up 31 home runs, giving the lineup a legit middle-of-the-order threat, but he also set the American League single-season strikeout record and matched the all-time MLB mark with his 223rd punchout.
For Chicago, the power is real enough to matter, and so is the concern that comes with it. Both Montgomery and the White Sox have acknowledged the strikeouts as an issue, with his swing and hitting approach now part of the discussion as the season winds on and the organization tries to figure out how much of this profile can be sharpened without dulling the pop. [Read more 🡒]