White Sox Prospect Finished Strong As Another AFL Arm Raises Concern

Colby Shelton's standout performance in the Arizona Fall League showcases his potential and versatility, concluding the White Sox infielders' mixed season on a high note.

The White Sox sent three infielders from Birmingham to the Arizona Fall League, but only one of them made it through the full run, and Colby Shelton finished with the loudest exit of the group.

Anthony DePino never got onto the field at all after undergoing shoulder surgery instead of reporting. Caleb Bonemer’s AFL stay ended early after he mashed .633 across 13 games, and the organization shut him down at the halfway point once it felt he had nothing left to prove. Shelton, though, kept going longer than the rest and closed with a burst that turned his final week into a showcase.

He drove in four runs in each of his last three games, then capped the stretch with a grand slam in his final appearance on Oct. 29.

That finish earned him Player of the Week honors, although he was already headed home by the time the award came around. The late surge also gave his stat line a quick boost and helped land him at No. 3 on Baseball America’s Hot Sheet.

Over 58 plate appearances, Shelton struck out only eight times while drawing eight walks. After 142 games and close to 600 plate appearances split between Winston-Salem, Birmingham and Glendale, the White Sox had seen enough. He was used mostly at first base because of Glendale’s roster needs, and he said the experience taught him plenty about a spot he had never played before.

“If you can play a bunch of positions, someone can find a way into the lineup for you. The more positions you play, it can’t hurt you,” Shelton told MLB.com after his AFL stint. “I definitely wasn’t perfect at it.

“I definitely learned some new stuff, whether I was in the wrong spot on a wrong count or with the outs or I wasn’t in the right spot for a lefty hitter in the shift or a righty hitter in the shift. So just learning that part, and then it wasn’t anything too crazy. Just getting my feet wet over there.”

Even with that first-base work, second base still looks like his most natural home, though the ability to handle the left side of the infield would still help him in spot duty.

Kaleb Freeman was added to the Glendale roster late, and Grant Magill was the only White Sox prospect to stay in the league for the full schedule. Magill’s bat didn’t make the leap he wanted, and that part of his game will have to wait for spring.

On the pitching side, Mathias LaCombe entered the fall with the biggest question attached to him: could he use the AFL to make a real push for Rule 5 protection? Instead, he walked more than a batter per inning and didn’t make that case.

Pierce George’s fall was even shorter and tougher, ending after his first and only game with a fracture in his elbow. Still, the White Sox pitchers on Glendale’s roster generally held their own.

Garrett Wright posted the eye-catching line of the group, even if the ERA doesn’t tell the whole story. Seven of the eight runs charged to him were unearned, which helps explain how he finished at 1.04 despite allowing 12 hits in 8.2 innings. He was also the youngest of the four other pitchers, while Nick Altermatt and Jonathan Clark are both 26 and Tommy Vail is 27.

In a league where the walk rate climbed to a staggering 16 percent, throwing strikes mattered. For the White Sox arms who could do that consistently, it was enough to leave at least a mark.

In Other News...

White Sox Offseason Plan Puts The Rotation At The Center

The White Sox are heading into the offseason with their rotation clearly at the center of the plan, and one of the most interesting parts of that approach is the idea of moving Grant Taylor from the bullpen into a starting role. GM Chris Getz has signaled that Chicago is looking to strengthen the group from within and through the market, while keeping the focus on pitching depth rather than making bullpen upgrades a priority.

Chicago could still bring in low-cost veteran arms to help round out the staff, but the bigger picture remains about building a sturdier rotation for next season. The club is also weighing its infield prospect situation without actively chasing trades there right now, leaving the pitching side as the clearest area of attention as the winter unfolds. [Read more 🡒]

White Sox Have A Sam Antonacci Decision That Could Reshape 2027

Sam Antonacci gave the White Sox plenty to think about in 2026, and not just because he held down a regular spot for most of the season. Over 140 games, he hit .277 with eight home runs and 20 stolen bases, production that helped him finish ninth in American League Rookie of the Year voting and made him one of the more encouraging young pieces on the roster.

The question now is where Chicago wants to use him next. General manager Chris Getz said Antonacci could see more infield time in 2027, even though he is expected to remain in left field as part of a possible platoon arrangement. That kind of flexibility can be useful, but it also hints at a bigger decision the White Sox will have to make about how best to maximize his bat while limiting the defensive issues that showed up in left, where Baseball Savant credited him with minus-9 Outs Above Average. [Read more 🡒]

White Sox Fans May Need More Patience With Caleb Bonemer

Caleb Bonemers rise has been one of the more encouraging developments in the White Sox system, but the path to Chicago is not as immediate as some fans might hope. General manager Chris Getz said the top prospect will begin the 2027 season at Triple-A Charlotte, even after a strong 2026 campaign and a fall in which he has been expanding his versatility by getting work in the outfield in the Arizona Fall League.

There is also a larger wrinkle hanging over the timeline. A potential MLB lockout could alter when Bonemer finally reaches the majors, though he would still be eligible to keep playing in the minors because he is not on the 40-man roster. For a rebuilding club trying to balance patience with progress, it is another reminder that Bonemers arrival may depend as much on the calendar as on his performance. [Read more 🡒]