When the White Sox handed Andrew Benintendi a franchise-record five-year, $75 million deal in January 2023, they were betting on the version of him that had just made the All-Star team in 2022 and won a Gold Glove the year before. That payoff never really came.
In four seasons with Chicago, Benintendi has produced just 0.5 bWAR across 543 games, hitting .244/.307/.396 with 60 home runs and 250 runs driven in. The bat has been below league average, and his defense has slipped enough that he’s no longer an outfield solution.
Still, the final year of that contract may not be as immovable as it once looked. Benintendi is set to carry a $15.1 million payroll number in the last season of the deal, and that’s not enough to make him untouchable.
There’s at least a case to be made that 2026 was his best year in Chicago. He hit .240/.302/.413 with 15 home runs, and his 78 runs driven in ranked third on the team behind Colson Montgomery and Miguel Vargas.
He also came through in big spots, batting .330/.376/.522 with four home runs and 62 runs driven in with runners in scoring position. Time and again, he was the guy who seemed to deliver when the White Sox needed a late-game hit.
The platoon arrangement with Randal Grichuk at designated hitter worked well, too. But Benintendi’s postseason fell apart, as he finished with a .100/.250/.100 playoff slash line.
The roster picture also makes his future murkier. Chicago has plenty of position players who could fill DH at-bats, both in the majors and in the minors, and the club is looking for a right-handed hitting outfielder.
That could open more time at DH for Sam Antonacci, or even Munetaka Murakami if he fully moves to the infield. Grichuk is headed for free agency, though the White Sox could bring him back to pair with one of those options.
Then there’s Caleb Bonemer, who is expected to be in Triple-A Charlotte and on the doorstep of the majors. He’s a hitter who should be getting regular at-bats once he arrives, and while the expectation isn’t for him to open 2027 in the big leagues, he’s close enough to force the issue.
Put it all together, and Benintendi could find himself squeezed out by the time 2027 rolls around. His veteran presence still matters, but the White Sox may decide they have too many younger pieces waiting for playing time to keep him around.
DFA’ing him would be costly, but another contender could be interested if Chicago is willing to eat salary. If a rival GM reaches out to Chris Getz about Benintendi this winter, it wouldn’t be a shock if the phone gets answered.
In Other News...
White Sox May Need To Act Fast On A Veteran Outfield Bat
The White Sox have made it clear they need a right-handed outfield bat, and the market may not offer many clean answers. With the free-agent pool looking thin, the club could be pushed toward the trade market for a more reliable upgrade, especially if it wants to address the spot before the offseason gets squeezed by an impending lockout.
One name that fits the need is Teoscar Hernandez, with the Dodgers reportedly open to moving the veteran as they look to create room for prospect Josue De Paula down the road. Hernandez would give Chicago the kind of established presence it lacks in the outfield, but if the White Sox want to get serious about him, they may need to move quickly before other clubs decide the same thing. [Read more 🡒]
Colson Montgomery Just Put Himself In Rare White Sox Company
Colson Montgomerys 2026 season gave the White Sox something to build around, and it came with plenty of historical weight attached. The young shortstop finished with 31 home runs, a total that put him in rare company for a franchise that has seen plenty of power over the years, while also carving out a place in team history as the standard for left-handed hitting shortstops in White Sox lore.
Montgomerys year did not stop with the regular season, either. He carried that impact into the postseason with a home run in the Wild Card game, and his production held up against left-handed pitching and in high-leverage spots, the kind of traits that can change how a lineup is built around him. For a White Sox team searching for more than just a hot stretch, his season offered something much more lasting: a profile that looks built for bigger stages. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox Pitching Search In Japan Is Starting To Get Serious
The White Sox have been doing more than just window shopping overseas as they look for help on the mound. Chicago has shown interest in Japanese pitchers Hiromi Itoh and Kaima Taira, both of whom have been posted and are now available to MLB teams, and the club sent scouts to evaluate each of them in August and September. Itoh brings a track record with the Hokkaido Nippon-Ham Fighters and has already built a decorated rsum in Japan, while Taira has drawn attention for his power and his ability to work both as a starter and out of the bullpen.
For a White Sox team trying to add pitching depth, the appeal is obvious. Itoh offers the kind of established profile that can make a team feel more comfortable about the transition from Nippon Professional Baseball, while Taira presents a different kind of upside because of his flexibility and raw stuff. Chicago has clearly done the legwork, but the next step will be determining whether either arm fits the club's plans well enough to make a real push. [Read more 🡒]
