The Chicago White Sox's journey through their rebuild phase from 2017 to 2022 was marked by several challenges, one of which was their hitting philosophy. The team adopted a universal strategy, encouraging players to focus on hitting line drives to the opposite field.
While there was some logic to this approach-thinking that being early on a fastball could lead to powerful pulled fly balls-the downside was significant. Opposite-field hits often result in singles rather than the more impactful home runs or doubles, which can be game-changers.
Applying this one-size-fits-all strategy across the board, especially to top prospects, proved problematic. Players like Tim Anderson might have thrived under such guidance, but for power hitters like Eloy Jimenez and Luis Robert Jr., this approach stifled potential. It wasn't the sole reason for the underperformance of the White Sox's promising core, but it certainly didn't help.
The organization's mindset was perhaps best encapsulated by former hitting coach Frank Menechino's infamous comment following Andrew Vaughn's first MLB home run. Menechino emphasized batting average over home runs, famously stating, "I’ve told Andrew to hit .300.
I don’t care if you don’t hit one home run. Hit .300, work on hitting .300.
Everybody wants to see the home run. … I don’t want to get excited, but f- the home run.
Let’s hit .300."
Add to this the reports of then-manager Tony La Russa instructing players to aim for singles before stepping up to the plate, and it's no surprise that the 2022 White Sox led the league in singles since 2017. This approach, while keeping strikeouts low, limited the team's offensive potential.
Fast forward to 2026, and the White Sox have shifted gears. Gone is the blanket approach to hitting.
Credit for this evolution goes to director of hitting Ryan Fuller, general manager Chris Getz, and manager Will Venable. The new hitting coach, Derek Shomon, has brought a fresh perspective.
Shomon's recent comments highlight a stark contrast to Menechino's philosophy. He acknowledges that while putting the ball in play works for some, it can hinder others, causing their swings and decisions to falter.
Shomon advocates for players to be athletes, encouraging them to take calculated risks and swing freely, even if it means missing occasionally.
This shift in philosophy is evident in the development of players like Sam Antonacci and Colson Montgomery. Montgomery, in particular, is a testament to this new approach. Once struggling in AAA Charlotte, he reworked his swing with Fuller's guidance and has emerged as one of baseball's premier power hitters.
In contrast to the 2022 squad, which often opted for cautious swings even in favorable counts, the 2026 team embraces a more aggressive approach. They're willing to risk a swing and miss early in the count, aiming for greater impact if they connect. This aligns with broader league trends, and the White Sox are not just catching up-they're setting the pace by nurturing players with diverse skillsets like Montgomery and Antonacci.
Derek Shomon's self-proclaimed "baseball untraditionalist" stance aligns well with the innovative approach fostered by Ryan Fuller. While it doesn't guarantee success, it signals a willingness to tailor coaching to individual players' strengths and experiment when necessary. For White Sox fans, this adaptability is a promising sign of the team's commitment to evolving and competing at the highest level.
In Other News...
White Sox May Be Seeing Another Chris Getz Draft Find Emerge
The White Sox have spent much of the summer seeing young players push their way into the conversation, from Colson Montgomery and Miguel Vargas to Braden Montgomery and Sam Antonacci, and that wave of development has only added to the optimism around a club sitting atop the AL Central. With the first pick in the 2026 MLB Draft still ahead of them, the organization is also continuing to mine value from the lower levels, where another recent draftee has started to turn heads with the Kannapolis Cannon Ballers.
Matthew Boughton, taken in the 11th round last year after being pulled away from his Texas A&M commitment, has been making a stronger case by the week that he is more than a lottery ticket. He earned Carolina League Player of the Week honors two weeks ago and has followed that up with a June surge that has him looking increasingly like one of the more intriguing young players in the system, the kind of late-round find every front office hopes to uncover. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox Top Prospect Just Delivered The Breakout Fans Wanted
Caleb Bonemer keeps making the White Sox look smarter for betting on his bat, and his latest showing at Double-A Birmingham was the kind of all-around night that turns heads in a hurry. In a 10-5 win over Knoxville, the 20-year-old prospect came through with his first homer at the level and finished 4-for-5, his first four-hit game of the season and only the second of his career.
Bonemers season line already had him near the top of the organization in several offensive categories, and the power production has become impossible to ignore. The bigger question now is how quickly that bat keeps forcing its way into the conversation, because nights like this tend to change the temperature around a prospect fast. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox Face Obvious Move As Catching Struggles Persist
Kyle Teels return from the injured list gave the White Sox a small boost, but the catching picture still looks unsettled. Chicago has been searching for more production behind the plate, and Drew Romos bat has not given the lineup much help, with his .137 average underscoring how little offensive impact the position has provided.
Korey Lee, meanwhile, has been in Triple-A and has shown better offensive numbers, which naturally keeps his name in the conversation as a possible upgrade in a backup role. For a White Sox club trying to piece together more reliable offense wherever it can find it, the next move at catcher is starting to look less like a question and more like an obvious decision waiting to be made. [Read more 🡒]