Will Venable is stuck trying to squeeze nine innings out of a White Sox team that keeps asking its bullpen to do the work of a full staff. The problem has only sharpened in September, when the starters are not getting deep, the multi-inning relievers are wearing down, and the offense has gone cold enough to leave very little margin for error.
Tuesday’s game against the Guardians was a perfect snapshot. Venable opened with Chris Murphy, which might have brushed up against the Septimo Principle -- using a pitcher who wouldn't normally be rostered well before it was necessary in a crucial September game -- but the White Sox still had a chance to win.
They were one strike away before all three of their best relievers faded in their second inning of work. That’s the kind of night that leaves a manager hunting for scoreless innings from places he probably didn’t expect to look.
Sean Newcomb and Grant Taylor have become the most obvious warning signs. Newcomb followed a 0.00 ERA over 18⅓ innings in August by getting scored upon in five of six September outings.
Over that stretch, opponents are hitting .394/.487/.545 against him. Taylor’s slide has looked different but just as damaging: he has been scored upon in four straight appearances, with a rising walk rate and harder exit velocities on his pitches.
That matters because both pitchers had been carrying more than their share of the load in high-leverage spots. They were effectively covering for a rotation that has struggled to get through even the first half of games.
Pulling Anthony Kay after four innings before things fully unraveled makes sense when a starter is getting hit hard the third time through, but it also shoves the pressure onto the back end of the bullpen. Right now, that pressure is winning.
So Venable probably can’t count on Newcomb or Taylor for two innings anymore. If the White Sox are going to survive these games, they may have to find that extra frame somewhere else first.
David Sandlin looks like one candidate. He has thrown 6, 7, 5⅔ and 5 ⅔ innings over his last four outings between Charlotte and Chicago, and a Colson Montgomery error kept him from tossing six scoreless innings against St.
Louis last time out. He’s a rookie closing out an uneven season, but he might be the White Sox’s second-best starter.
If he comes out clean, the Sox can let him stretch toward quality-start territory.
Hagen Smith is another option, though Venable already admitted the club debated hardest whether to send him back out for a second inning on Wednesday. Smith had been working two innings every other day, and the risk of wearing him down was real.
Still, after how well he had pitched before that second inning Wednesday, he might be the best shot at two scoreless frames to bridge a starter who isn’t going to face the lineup a third time. The catch is that it may require making him unavailable the game before.
Noah Schultz can help create that kind of opening. He finished Wednesday’s loss with two scoreless innings on just 18 pitches, and much of his work in Charlotte over the past month has looked similar. He’s more vulnerable to contact luck than Smith, but when Schultz is around the strike zone and not getting in his own way, he can be a useful source of the unexpected second inning Newcomb had been giving them.
Jordan Hicks is the right-handed answer. He had a rough stretch at the end of April, but over his last three innings -- spread across four appearances in 15 days -- he has allowed just a hit and a walk while striking out six. That kind of line is enough to make him the best candidate to absorb some of Taylor’s burden from the right side, even if leaning on him carries its own risk.
None of those choices is clean. Any one of them could blow up the same way Newcomb and Taylor have.
But with the bullpen thinning out and the offense not hitting the ball out of the park, Venable is being pushed toward the least comfortable kind of decision: the one that is merely defensible. Until the Sox start creating the good kind of low-leverage situations again, that’s what these nights are going to look like.
In Other News...
White Sox Lose Veteran Arm As Another Contender Pounces
The White Sox lost another veteran arm Tuesday when the Phillies claimed right-hander Jose Urquidy off waivers, a reminder of how active late-season roster churn can be for a club with pieces other teams still see value in. Urquidy had already pitched for two other teams this season, and even in a year spent moving around, his track record still carried weight because of the playoff experience he brings from Houston.
For Philadelphia, the move fit a roster need enough that the club made space by transferring right-hander Caleb Kilian to the 60-day injured list. For Chicago, it is another small but telling departure from a staff that has had to keep adjusting on the fly, while contenders continue to look at the White Sox as a source of usable pitching depth. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox May Have One Last Infield Gamble For More Offense
With the White Sox still looking for ways to squeeze more offense out of a roster that has spent most of the season searching for answers, Oswaldo Cabrera has emerged as a possible depth piece worth considering. The former Yankee was recently designated for assignment, and his appeal is obvious for a club in Chicagos position: he has big league experience, can move around the infield and offers a bit of flexibility at a time when the White Sox could use it.
The timing, though, gives any move a different feel. Because the August 31 postseason eligibility deadline has already passed, Cabrera would not be available for a playoff run if the White Sox add him, which makes this more about shoring up the present than chasing some larger October payoff. Cabreras recent injuries and limited opportunities only add to the uncertainty, leaving Chicago to weigh whether a low-risk depth move is enough to justify the roster shuffle. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox Get A Colson Montgomery Scare At The Worst Time
Colson Montgomery gave the White Sox a scare in Cleveland when he was struck on the forearm by a pitch and later exited with a left wrist contusion. Chicago avoided the worst-case scenario, though, as the club said X-rays came back negative and Montgomery is listed as day-to-day.
Even with that early good news, the timing is less than ideal for a team trying to hang onto its playoff hopes. Montgomery has struggled at the plate this season, and the White Sox can ill afford to lose any more lineup stability while they wait to see how his wrist responds. [Read more 🡒]