Dustin May’s new deal with the White Sox fits a very specific kind of free-agent gamble: the one where the upside is real, but the proof is still missing.
At 29, May reportedly landed a three-year, $52.5 million contract with Chicago, and that length tells you plenty. This isn’t the kind of signing made for a pitcher nearing the end of the road, like Chris Bassitt or Nathan Eovaldi. It’s more of a bet that there’s still another level in there somewhere, even if the market has already spent years waiting for it to show up.
That’s the tension with three-year contracts for pitchers in this age range. Teams are buying future value, but they’re also paying for a track record that hasn’t quite matched the raw ingredients.
It’s the same kind of logic that once made Tyler Chatwood such an intriguing free agent in 2017. He had the age, the stuff and the ability to survive Coors Field, which made him look like a fit for a White Sox club that needed pitching but couldn’t spend wildly.
The Cubs saw the same appeal and gave him three years and $38 million, $8 million above FanGraphs’ estimate.
The problem was obvious once the innings started piling up. Chatwood’s control issues followed him out of Colorado, and in his first year with the Cubs he led the NL in walks over just 103 innings. That pushed him to the bullpen, and while he eventually found a role after the initial mess, the bigger upside never really arrived.
May is not Chatwood, mostly because he throws more strikes. That gives him a much better chance to hold down a back-end starter job over the life of the contract, assuming his body cooperates.
But the White Sox probably shouldn’t expect some hidden gear to suddenly appear. His biggest weakness has been there all along: left-handed hitters.
The last two healthy 100-inning seasons tell the story. Against right-handers, May posted a .256/.325/.386 line in 2025 and a .239/.284/.368 line in 2026. Against left-handers, he allowed a .261/.357/.495 line in 2025 and a .269/.358/.397 line in 2026.
There is some progress in that split. He did a better job of keeping lefties from doing damage, and dropping the slugging percentage by 100 points without also dragging down the batting average is no small thing.
Because he doesn’t have a changeup or an over-the-top curveball to really mess with left-handed bats, he adjusted by raising his arm slot and moving from a sweeper to a cutter as his main pitch. That seemed to help a bit.
Still, the issue hasn’t gone away. Lefties remain a problem, and that makes it hard to bank on simple regression solving everything.
His ERA was 4.70, well above his 3.63 FIP, and a big reason was the .350/.398/.513 line he allowed with runners in scoring position. That kind of strand-rate damage usually corrects itself over time.
Even so, in a league that keeps leaning left-handed, May may keep running into too many of those matchups for clean innings to come easily.
Add in the injury history, and this becomes another uncertain starter in a White Sox rotation mix already full of them. That’s why the move is tough to get excited about on its own.
If spring training arrives and May is clearly the second-best starter Chicago added this offseason, then the conversation changes. For now, Sean Burke still stands alone in terms of the odds of supplying a lot of useful innings, and the White Sox would be wise to give him some help.
In Other News...
White Sox Bullpen Plans May Test A Spending Line They Rarely Cross
The White Sox already dipped into the rotation market by bringing in Dustin May on a three-year deal, and now the attention appears to be shifting to the bullpen. Chicago has spent much of its recent history shopping carefully rather than aggressively, which is why any meaningful relief-pitching upgrade stands out on this roster. A Bleacher Report projection from Kerry Miller has the club targeting Adrian Morejon, a left-handed reliever whose recent work with the Padres has made him one of the more intriguing names available.
For a bullpen that could use more impact arms, Morejon would fit as the kind of addition that changes the shape of the late innings rather than just filling a spot. The question for the White Sox is whether they are willing to stretch into a contract range they rarely cross, especially after already committing to May. If they do, it would signal a more assertive approach to building around a pitching staff that still needs help in several places. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox May Need A New Pitching Plan After Latest Trade Shock
The pitching market keeps shifting around the White Sox, and the latest move out of Seattle only adds to the pressure. The Mariners completed a six-player trade with the Royals to land third baseman Maikel Garcia, sending three pitchers, including Bryce Miller, to Kansas City, while general manager Jerry DiPoto said there is no chance of trading another starting pitcher.
For Chicago, that kind of certainty elsewhere only sharpens the urgency to keep building its own rotation plan. The White Sox have reportedly agreed to a three-year deal with right-hander Dustin May, but they are still looking at more pitching help through free agency or trades in a market that is getting harder to navigate by the day. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox Have A Strikeout Arm With One Big Hurdle Ahead
Landen Payne gives the White Sox something every organization wants to keep adding to the pipeline: a right-handed reliever with strikeout stuff and a track record of overcoming adversity. Drafted in 2025 after a strong senior season at Southern Mississippi, Payne has already shown enough in the minors to make the pick look worthwhile, turning in promising work at both Low-A and High-A in 2026.
The next step is where the real test begins. Payne has battled multiple injuries through his college career, and while the White Sox have seen enough to be encouraged, his rise will depend on staying healthy and sharpening more than one pitch. For a reliever trying to climb the ladder, that combination can decide whether he becomes a useful arm or just another intriguing name in the system. [Read more 🡒]
