White Sox 2027 Pitching Plan Is Already Sparking A Big Debate

As the White Sox plan for a future anchored by new pitching roles, Grant Taylor's transition to starter marks a pivotal shift amid questions about stamina and bullpen replacements.

The White Sox are already sketching out a very different pitching picture for 2027, and the most surprising part might be where they want Grant Taylor to end up.

During this week’s GM meetings, general manager Chris Getz joined Jim Bowden and Jim Duquette on SiriusXM MLB Radio’s “Front Office” and laid out a plan that has Taylor moving into the rotation in 2027. At the same time, breakout rookie Hagen Smith is expected to stay in the bullpen for now. Getz did say the White Sox remain open to starting Smith later on, but not at this point.

That’s a notable call, especially with Chicago still trying to solve the same problem that helped derail a strong season: not enough starting pitching depth. The White Sox have not added a new arm this offseason yet, but Getz’s comments offered an early look at how they may approach the rotation next year.

Taylor’s case is the tricky one. He has been building toward a multi-inning role during the 2026 season, but he hasn’t thrown more than 100 innings since before college, if at all.

That matters, because Chicago already saw what can happen when its starters wear down late in the year. The 2027 season is expected to be shortened, which would help Taylor, but it still doesn’t change the fact that he has never carried a starter’s workload.

There’s also the injury history to weigh. Taylor had Tommy John surgery at LSU, so the White Sox never got a real chance to see whether he could handle a full starter’s load in college.

His four-inning save in October showed just how electric he can be, but the question is whether he can do that every five days for five or more innings. His longer outings in relief were uneven at times, and that uncertainty only grows if he’s asked to stretch out even more.

Then there’s the fastball. Taylor’s 100-plus mph heater is the engine of his game. If he moves into the rotation, the White Sox will have to find out whether that pitch holds its edge over a starter’s workload or loses some of the velocity that makes him so dangerous.

The move would also leave Chicago with another hole to fill at the back end of games. Someone has to close, and the options could come from inside the organization or from outside it. Adrián Morejón, David Bednar if either pitcher declines the qualifying offer, and Raisel Iglesias were all mentioned as names that could fit the role, though each would come with a significant price tag.

For now, the simplest argument is the one Taylor already made in the bullpen: he was excellent there last season. That’s why the switch feels so bold.

Smith, meanwhile, remains on a different track. The No. 5 overall pick was drafted to be a long-term starter, and that still looks like the eventual plan.

But he needs more major league seasoning first. After 22 games, including playoffs, and a 1.29 ERA, he could still end up as a classic closer or a multi-inning, high-leverage weapon in the same kind of role Taylor filled in 2026.

However it shakes out, one thing is clear: the White Sox pitching staff is going to look a lot different in 2027.

In Other News...

White Sox Fans Have Every Right To Be Furious Over Murakami

MLB handed out its 2026 Rookie of the Year awards, with Kevin McGonigle taking the American League honor and Sal Stewart winning in the National League, but the conversation around the vote had a familiar edge for White Sox followers. Munetaka Murakamis season was part of the debate because his traditional numbers stacked up well against the field, even as the voting process seemed to draw different lines in each league.

For White Sox fans, the frustration is less about the winners than the way Murakami was treated in the process. The first baseman put together a season that should have kept him squarely in the mix, yet he was left outside the finalist group, a result that only sharpened the sense that the standards were not applied evenly. [Read more 🡒]

White Sox Prospect Watch Just Got More Complicated In Arizona

The Arizona Fall League has already become a useful checkpoint for the White Sox, with seven prospects assigned to the Glendale Desert Dogs as the organization takes another look at some of its better young talent against advanced competition. The mix has included both position players and pitchers, and the early returns have given the front office a little more to weigh as the fall schedule rolls on.

Roster movement has only added to the intrigue. Glendale has had to adjust because of injuries, and Tommy Vail is now in the mix after the club made a change on the pitching side. Meanwhile, some White Sox prospects have already wrapped up their fall work after productive stretches, while others are still getting innings and at-bats in recent games, leaving the picture in Arizona a little less settled than it looked at the start. [Read more 🡒]

White Sox Could Cash In Prospect Depth At A Crucial Time

The White Sox are heading into an offseason where adding to the major league roster could mean parting with some of the prospect depth that has helped make the system more interesting. Chicago is expected to be active on the trade market, and with holes to fill and a farm system that includes more than one possible chip, the front office has some real decisions to make about how aggressively it wants to push now versus later.

Among the names drawing attention are shortstop Billy Carlson, right-hander Tanner McDougal and infielder William Bergolla Jr., all of whom could fit into trade discussions because of the teams depth and its need to improve in the big leagues. Carlson and McDougal in particular stand out as the kind of players other clubs would ask about, while Bergolla adds another layer to a group that gives Chicago options if it decides the right deal is worth moving on. [Read more 🡒]