Davis Martin’s rough outing against the Red Sox did more than spoil the White Sox’s first game after the trade deadline. It also pushed the club’s starting-pitching plan back under the microscope.
Martin was tagged for nine earned runs, and the damage was front-loaded: a brutal first inning that left the White Sox digging out from the start. He’s now sitting on a 7.76 ERA since the beginning of July, and over his last five starts he’s allowed 23 runs in 25 ⅔ innings. He managed to settle in enough to finish five-plus innings, but the early collapse was too ugly to ignore.
Martin said pitch-tipping might have been part of the problem.
“We’re going to go back and see what the tip is and how long we’ve been doing it and if that’s going to answer some questions,” said Martin, who allowed nine earned runs in the game and has given up 23 in his last 25 ⅔ innings, covering five starts. “If it doesn’t, we still have to make some better pitches. But it would explain some things.”
Injured catcher Kyle Teel spotted the issue from the dugout and let Martin and new catcher Joey Bart know.
The inning immediately brought back memories of Lucas Giolito’s Patriots’ Day meltdown in 2021, when he surrendered six runs in the first and then two more after Tony La Russa sent him back out for the second. Giolito had also faced pitch-tipping chatter after that game, though he wasn’t the one who brought it up publicly.
His own explanation that day pointed elsewhere.
“The big thing was leaving my changeup up, and it didn’t have good action, based on the replays and stuff I saw,” he said. “They didn’t miss them.”
That’s the danger of trying to read too much into one bad inning, even if the Red Sox do carry a reputation for spotting and relaying tips. Pitch-tipping can show up in all kinds of ways, as Sean Newcomb noted earlier this season when he told Jesse Rogers that teams could tell whether he was going to throw a fastball by how fast he was chewing his gum.
Still, Martin’s next start - currently lined up for the Reds series next week - figures to say more than any postgame theory. It also leaves a familiar White Sox voice hanging in the background. Chris Denorfia is the coach who is supposed to have tipping in his lane, and this would be a good time to hear from him.
Martin’s struggles also sharpen the pressure around the White Sox’s newest rotation addition, Luis Castillo, who is set to make his debut Thursday. Chris Getz may have been trying to avoid paying up for a rental starter and keep the focus on 2026, but the trade he made brings its own kind of scrutiny.
Castillo isn’t arriving as a clean, plug-and-play solution. He’s a pitcher who needs tweaks.
And that’s really what defined Getz’s deadline. The White Sox were one of the busier teams over the last week, but most of the action amounted to depth upgrades rather than a move that changed the conversation. The one deal that will stick in the memory is the Castillo trade.
Chicago took on the $30 million left on Castillo’s contract, gave up a real prospect to get him, and added an aging starter who has a 5.06 ERA this season. Boston Smith’s exact defensive home isn’t clear, but there’s no mystery about the bat: he can hit. Seattle is happy to have him.
The rest of the roster looks better than it did a week ago. Huascar Brazobán bolsters the bullpen.
Brenton Doyle helps round out a Gold Glove platoon in center. Joey Bart covers a need behind the plate while Kyle Teel is hurt.
But none of that was enough to offset the questions around Castillo.
Luis Robert Jr. was supposed to be the player the Mets acquired to avoid living through the same White Sox experience. Instead, they ended up replaying the whole thing.
There was the long injury absence, the production that never quite matched the talent, and then the deadline stalemate. Robert drew some interest, but not enough to create a real market once the money was factored in. He is owed $5.9 million for the rest of this season, plus $2 million for a buyout on a team option next year worth $20 million.
In retrospect, the White Sox should have moved him after the 2023 season. But the truth is the same now as it was then: any return would have felt light because Robert still hadn’t put together two healthy seasons, let alone two productive ones.
When the White Sox eventually dealt Robert to the Mets for Luisangel Acuña and Truman Pauley while New York paid full freight, the outcome felt anticlimactic after years of rumors. But at least there was an outcome.
The best time to trade Robert was yesterday. The second-best time was today - until today was gone.
In Other News...
White Sox Still Have One Rotation Battle That Could Shape The Stretch Run
Following the trade deadline, the White Sox have largely settled into the shape of their postseason push, but one rotation spot remains unresolved and it could end up mattering plenty down the stretch. The club has a handful of candidates it can lean on, including Erick Fedde, Jose Urquidy, Shane Smith and David Sandlin, giving Chicago a mix of experience, health questions and upside as it sorts out how to cover the back end of the staff.
Drew Thorpe is still working his way back, with his rehab and innings build-up pointing to a return later rather than sooner, while the rest of the group brings its own set of uncertainties. For a team trying to line up its pitching as the season tightens, this is the kind of decision that can quietly shape whether the rotation holds together when the games start to feel heavier. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox Just Made Austin Hays An Afterthought In Their Outfield Shakeup
The White Sox kept reshaping their outfield picture this week, designating Everson Pereira for assignment and adding Brenton Doyle from the Rockies as they continue sorting out who fits into the long-term mix. In the process, Austin Hays has been pushed to the edge of the roster, a sign of how quickly Chicagos outfield plans have moved on from a player who never really got a chance to settle in.
Hays time with the Sox has been disrupted by injuries, and the club has now moved him onto release waivers after a brief stay that included a trip to the injured list. He is expected to clear, given the salary still attached, but the situation leaves open the possibility that another team could take a look later if he gets healthy and becomes available again. [Read more 🡒]