Billy Carlson’s thumb injury might have slowed his first pro season, but it also set up a timely return for a White Sox organization that suddenly has a different kind of problem on its hands.
The 10th overall pick in the 2025 MLB Draft was always going to need patience. Chicago drafted the high school shortstop knowing the glove was ahead of the bat, even if some scouts saw offensive upside too. Carlson entered pro ball with a reputation as the best defensive shortstop in the class, and the early returns at the plate have shown both the promise and the unfinished business.
In his first month, Carlson hit .233/.359/.314. He picked it up in May, batting .293 with a .425 on-base percentage, but the power has still not shown up. He has yet to hit his first minor league home run, and the thumb injury that landed him on the injured list on May 23rd put the rest of his debut season on pause.
That pause lasted nearly two months. Once he came back after the All-Star break, Carlson looked ready to jump right back in.
In a three-game weekend series, he went 5-for-9 with a double, triple, six RBIs and five walks. The power still isn’t there, but the bat has shown enough life to suggest he can handle pro pitching.
Billy Carlson has an RBI in each of his first 3 pro games for the Single-A @Kcannonballers!
The @whitesox 2025 first-rounder delivers a pair of run-scoring knocks Saturday: pic.twitter.com/nifLf4yIMr
- MLB Pipeline (@MLBPipeline) April 5, 2026
That development matters because Carlson’s name is already floating around trade chatter. The White Sox are looking for pitching help, and with their first three picks in the 2026 draft all middle infielders, the organization has built serious depth at the position. That makes a player like Carlson easier to imagine as part of a deal for controllable pitching.
His injury had complicated that possibility. Now that he’s healthy and producing again, the door is a little more open. It also helps that he’s playing well.
If the White Sox were making the call, Carlson probably wouldn’t go anywhere for a rental. The kind of return that would make sense would have to help for multiple seasons. Even so, he looks more movable than Caleb Bonemer, who already ranks as a top 25 prospect in baseball.
The bigger picture is pretty clear. With Roch Cholowsky, the first overall pick, also in the system and the big league infield looking set for the foreseeable future, finding enough at-bats for all of the young talent won’t be easy. That’s the kind of depth good teams want, but it also creates real choices when the front office needs to address other spots.
Losing Carlson would sting, especially this early in his development. But teams trying to win championships can’t treat every prospect as untouchable. They also can’t count on player development alone to solve every hole on the roster.
The White Sox have a clear opportunity to reach the postseason in 2026, and that gives them a chance to be aggressive. If trading Billy Carlson helps put them in the best position to win, it’s the kind of move they may have to consider.
In Other News...
White Sox Suddenly Face Another Catching Setback With Kyle Teel
The White Sox are trying to keep their catching situation steady again after Kyle Teel was sidelined, a reminder of how quickly one position can shift for a club still sorting out its roster. Edgar Quero was brought back up to give the staff another option, and Drew Romo is getting the start Tuesday night against the Rangers as the team looks for a workable rotation behind the plate.
For now, the plan appears to be a shared workload between Romo and Quero, with playing time likely to follow performance as much as anything else. Chicago can at least lean on a pitching staff that has held its own and an offense that has shown some life, but another interruption at catcher adds a little more uncertainty to a team that could have used a cleaner stretch. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox Hit Another Low Point In Blowout That Got Bizarre
Noah Schultzs night in Texas quickly turned into one of those games the White Sox would like to erase from the record book. The young right-hander was tagged for 11 hits and 10 runs in 3 2/3 innings, and Chicago never recovered in a 10-0 loss that left the Sox out-hit 18-3 and shut out for the eighth time this season.
The damage kept spreading after Schultz exited, with Trevor Richards and Tyler Schweitzer unable to stop the bleeding as the Rangers kept stacking traffic and extra bases. By the time the game reached the late innings, the White Sox were already deep into damage control, and the bizarre part was not just how lopsided it became, but how many different ways it unraveled. [Read more 🡒]