Shohei Ohtani may still sit at the center of the National League MVP conversation, but when ESPN asked MLB players to weigh in, Pete Crow-Armstrong ran away with the room.
That’s the clearest sign yet that the Chicago Cubs center fielder has become a real threat to Ohtani’s bid for a third straight NL MVP Award. Betting markets have bounced back and forth all summer, with the two trading places as the favorite.
Publicly, it looks tight. Among players, it wasn’t close.
ESPN’s Jesse Rogers surveyed more than 20 players from nine teams, leaving out players from the Cubs and Dodgers. Crow-Armstrong collected 15 votes.
Ohtani got four. Two players said they would split the award.
The appeal of Crow-Armstrong is easy to see. He’s not just piling up numbers in one lane; he’s affecting games everywhere.
He sits near Ohtani at the top of the National League in OPS, OPS+ and wRC+, and he leads the NL in the latter category. He’s also second in the league in stolen bases and tops all MLB defenders in outs above average.
That blend of offense, speed and defense has made a strong impression on players around the league.
“He hasn’t slowed down and on top of that, he’s arguably the best fielder in all of baseball,” Chicago White Sox pitcher Trevor Richards told ESPN. “He’s a complete player. That’s for sure.”
Cleveland Guardians first baseman Rhys Hoskins pointed to the same thing: Crow-Armstrong is on the field every day, and that matters.
“In the true sense of the word, the guy that plays every day probably makes more of an impact on the team every single day,” Hoskins said. “Anyone that’s watched PCA or the Cubs over the last two months, this guy is the best player on the field every time he’s on the field.”
Crow-Armstrong also has a shot at a 40-home run, 40-stolen base season, and that kind of production paired with elite defense in center field gives him a very real case against a player with Ohtani’s profile.
Still, Ohtani is hardly out of the picture. The Dodgers star remains one of the game’s most feared hitters, and if he gets back on the mound and pitches the way he did before his knee soreness forced him off July 3, the race could swing again in a hurry. Before that injury, he was among MLB’s best pitchers through 14 starts.
That two-way ceiling is exactly why some players still side with Ohtani.
“A half season of Cy Young-level pitching and what he does offensively, no one has done that on both sides of the ball,” White Sox pitcher Sean Burke told ESPN. “He gets my vote.”
Ohtani has already begun a throwing progression, which gives him a chance to return before the regular season ends. How much he pitches, and how effective he is, may end up deciding everything.
Reds pitcher Emilio Pagán said he would choose Crow-Armstrong if the season ended today. But if Ohtani comes back in a real starting role and works deep into games, Pagán’s view could change.
“If he doesn’t pitch again in a real starter’s role, then I’d vote for PCA still,” Pagán said.
That’s the tension in this MVP race. Ohtani’s case is familiar and terrifying: elite power, plus front-line pitching, all in one package. Crow-Armstrong’s case is built on a different kind of total value - damage at the plate, pressure on the bases and run prevention in center field.
Kansas City Royals slugger Jac Caglianone told ESPN that Crow-Armstrong’s defensive impact could come close to what Ohtani gives from the mound. With their offensive numbers so close, that makes the choice harder than it looks on paper.
There’s also the simple reality that Ohtani has won four MVP Awards since 2021, and some players seem eager to reward a different face this time. Crow-Armstrong is pushing hard enough to make that possible.
Ohtani may still enter the final month as the betting favorite. But if the players surveyed are the best guide, the vote would go to Crow-Armstrong right now.
In Other News...
Cubs Move Quickly To Address Dansby Swansons Infield Absence
The Cubs wasted little time shoring up their infield after losing Dansby Swanson, claiming Gabriel Arias off waivers from the Mets to give the roster another option in the middle of the diamond. To make room on the 40-man roster, Chicago moved Phil Maton to the 60-day injured list, a reminder of how quickly one injury can force a series of moves behind the scenes.
There is also a little more help on the horizon. Matt Shaw has started a rehab assignment with Iowa and could be back with the Cubs soon, which gives the club a possible internal boost even as it leans on outside depth for the moment. For a team trying to stay steady without Swanson, these are the kinds of short-term fixes that can matter before the bigger lineup questions sort themselves out. [Read more 🡒]
Javier Assad Keeps Saving The Cubs And Fans See The Problem
Javier Assad has become one of those pitchers the Cubs keep leaning on whether the setup is ideal or not, and Wednesday was another example. After Kevin Gausman exited with a thumb cramp, Assad came in and covered three scoreless innings of relief, giving Chicago the kind of steady bridge work that helped set up a walk-off win over the White Sox. It was the sort of outing that makes his value obvious even if the path to getting there has been anything but smooth.
Assads season line keeps looking useful, with a 3.46 ERA and opponents hitting just .231 against him, even as some of the underlying metrics hint at a less secure profile. The bigger issue for the Cubs has been keeping him in one place long enough to rely on him, since roster needs have sent him back and forth between the majors and Triple-A. For a team trying to piece together every inning, he has still looked like an important arm to have around. [Read more 🡒]
Shota Imanaga Is Forcing A Cubs Decision At The Worst Time
Shota Imanagas season has reached a tricky stage at exactly the wrong moment for the Cubs. Even with his fastball velocity back where it had been in a recent start, the left-hander has been running into a troubling string of loud contact, and the home run problem has started to outweigh the comfort of seeing the velocity tick up again.
For a club that is trying to sort out playoff rotation spots, Imanagas next few outings carry real weight. The Cubs need to know whether he can turn better raw stuff into better results, because the postseason picture is tightening and his role is no longer something they can take for granted. [Read more 🡒]