Justin Steele's Return Creates A Big Cubs Decision At The Perfect Time

With playoff aspirations on the line, the Chicago Cubs consider unleashing Justin Steele from the bullpen despite his recent return from elbow surgery.

The Chicago Cubs may be getting Justin Steele back at the exact moment they need another arm the most.

Steele, who has been out all season after elbow surgery in 2025, has spent the last couple of weeks ramping up in rehab games with Triple-A Iowa. The results have only gotten better. By the time he reached his final outing on September 18, he had put together his sharpest showing yet: 2.0 scoreless innings, no hits allowed, five strikeouts and just one walk.

That was enough for Craig Counsell to sound encouraged on Tuesday. He called it a "great sign."

Counsell went a step further, too, and left the door open for a return before the playoffs. With five games remaining before the Wild Card round, the Cubs are at least considering Steele as a possible piece this weekend.

"He's an option, I guess is the best way to say it," Counsell told reporters (h/t Marquee Sports Network). He's going to throw bullpen tomorrow.

I think the plan is for him to be an option this weekend, possibly. We'll just kind of see what this weekend has in store for us and what this weekend gives us to make a decision."

If Steele does get into a game, it will be his first appearance since his start on April 7, 2025. The plan, for now, is almost certainly to use him out of the bullpen. The Cubs have not stretched him out enough to send him back into a starting role this season, and asking him to handle that kind of workload now would be too much.

Even the idea of bringing him back carries risk. He has looked healthy in the minors, but that is still a tiny sample against a very different level of competition. Chicago would be sending him straight into a tense stretch with Wild Card seeding still unsettled.

At the same time, the Cubs are running short on alternatives. Their bullpen has continued to let games slip away late, and Tuesday night brought another example in extra innings against the Miami Marlins. Chicago had a chance to clinch the playoffs in the series opener and could not finish the job.

That reality makes Steele even more valuable. The Cubs know what he can look like at his best, and they also made it clear at the trade deadline that they expect to be in the mix for a postseason run. In that sense, the logic is simple: if Steele can help, why not use him?

Still, Counsell is expected to handle the situation carefully. The Cubs have no interest in rushing Steele back into the wrong spot or putting him in a spot that could lead to another setback, physical or otherwise.

The next few days could get messy, especially with Boston’s weather expected to be so bad that the two teams have already set a doubleheader to guard against a postponement. That only adds to the importance of having Steele available. With this bullpen, and with rain in the forecast, the Cubs can use every option they can get.

In Other News...

Cubs Wild Card Rotation Suddenly Hinges On One Concerning Injury

Kevin Gausmans status has suddenly become one of the biggest questions hanging over the Cubs as they look ahead to the postseason. The right-hander hurt his left shoulder while making a defensive play against the Miami Marlins, and manager Craig Counsell confirmed the injury after the game. Gausman later said the shoulder felt weak afterward, which is hardly the kind of update a team wants to hear with October approaching.

Now the Cubs are left to wait and see how the next few days unfold. His availability for the postseason will depend on how the shoulder responds, and that puts extra attention on a rotation spot that looked a lot more settled before this setback. For a team trying to line up its pitching for a Wild Card run, the timing of the injury makes the coming monitoring period especially important. [Read more 🡒]

Former Cubs Architect Is Suddenly Back In A Front Office Spotlight

Jason McLeod, a familiar name from the Cubs rebuild years, has popped back into the front-office conversation in a way that should catch the attention of anyone who watched Chicago climb from a long-term project into a contender. Now a special assistant and vice president of baseball operations with the Arizona Diamondbacks, McLeod was mentioned in an anonymous MLB agent survey as a preferred candidate for a general manager job, with the responses grouping him alongside other executives and managers as a strong leadership fit.

For Cubs fans, it is a reminder that the people who helped shape that era are still getting noticed around the industry. There has been no confirmed move or official job opening tied to McLeod, and his future at the top of an MLB front office remains speculative for now, but the mention alone is enough to put him back on the radar in a league that is always searching for the next well-regarded operator. [Read more 🡒]

Cubs Clinched October But Their Biggest Wild Card Fight Remains

The Cubs have already checked the biggest box by punching their ticket to October for the second straight season, and they did it with a 2-1 win over the Marlins that kept them firmly in the postseason picture. But even with a playoff berth secured, there is still plenty at stake over the final stretch, because Chicago is headed for the Wild Card round and remains locked in a tight race for the best possible seeding.

Midseason moves were made to steady the pitching and give this roster a better chance to survive the grind of a short series, and those decisions now look even more important. The Cubs also hold tiebreakers over the Padres and Phillies, a potentially valuable edge if the race stays this close, which means the standings around them could matter just as much as anything happening inside Wrigley over the next few days. [Read more 🡒]