The Cubs’ bullpen mess has given Jed Hoyer plenty of heat this season, but the David Peterson trade is the kind of move that reminds you why front offices keep hunting for value in the margins.
Peterson, a veteran left-hander the Mets pushed aside earlier this year, landed in Chicago in June and has quietly become one of the most useful arms on the staff. He made his Cubs debut on June 27 and has settled in as a stabilizing force for a rotation that needed one.
On Monday at Wrigley Field, Peterson helped the Cubs beat the Atlanta Braves 7-3. He worked six innings, gave up one run, allowed three hits and struck out seven.
The lone run charged to him came after Javier Assad inherited a runner in the seventh inning. Peterson picked up the win, and the outing was another reminder that the raw ERA doesn’t always tell the whole story.
Through 14 games with the Cubs, including 13 starts, Peterson has a 4.15 ERA with 61 strikeouts in 69.1 innings. That number is decent, not dazzling.
But the deeper look is where the trade starts to shine. Of the 32 earned runs he’s allowed in Chicago, 16 came in just two games that totaled 7.1 innings.
In his other 12 appearances since the trade, Peterson has put up a 2.32 ERA across 62 innings.
Monday was also the 10th time this year that Peterson has held an opponent to two earned runs or fewer. In 11 of his 13 starts with the Cubs in 2026, he’s limited the other team to three runs or less.
The rough spots have been real - he was hammered for 10 runs in 3.2 innings against the St. Louis Cardinals on July 3, and the Milwaukee Brewers tagged him for six runs in 3.2 innings more recently - but outside those two outings, he’s been exactly what Chicago needed.
Before the deal, Peterson had thrown 68 innings for the Mets and carried a 6.09 ERA while bouncing between the bullpen and the rotation. His profile fit the Cubs’ roster perfectly. He’s a groundball pitcher, and Chicago’s infield defense is described as the best in MLB.
That’s been the pattern with Hoyer. Time and again, he’s targeted pitchers other clubs no longer seem to value and found ways to get more out of them in Chicago.
It’s also easy to understand why Cubs fans were frustrated when the Peterson deal went down. Many wanted a bigger splash. Instead, Hoyer landed a pitcher who was largely dismissed at the time and has already outperformed the expectations attached to him.
And Peterson isn’t the only example. At the trade deadline, Hoyer also dealt for Peterson’s former teammate Clay Holmes, who may not carry the biggest name, but has been a stud since joining the Cubs.
For all the frustration around the bullpen and the injuries that forced the Cubs to use the most pitchers in the 2026 season, there’s still real value in building a staff this way. Chicago has had its issues finding relief help in free agency, but this front office has shown it can add quality to the rotation. Peterson is the latest proof.
In Other News...
Kevin Alcntara May Have Just Reopened His Cubs Roster Path
Late in the 2026 season, Kevin Alcntara has started getting work at first base for Triple-A Iowa, a move that could give the Cubs another reason to keep him on the radar heading toward 2027. The 22-year-old outfielder has long been viewed as one of the organizations more interesting young talents, but adding a new position changes the conversation around him, especially for a club that values flexibility and needs to keep finding ways to fit right-handed depth onto the roster.
For Chicago, the timing matters. Alcntara is out of minor-league options, so the Cubs cant simply stash him in Iowa again if he shows enough to belong in the majors, and first base is an area where the team may want a capable bench piece behind Michael Busch. With some upcoming free-agent departures potentially thinning the mix, Alcntaras versatility could be more than a side note now, it might be the clearest path back to Wrigley when roster decisions get serious. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Suddenly Have A Matthew Boyd Problem At The Worst Time
The Cubs are running out of time to sort out their October rotation, and the picture behind Clay Holmes is looking far less stable than it seemed a few weeks ago. Holmes still appears to be the leading candidate to start Game 1, but Chicago had hoped the rest of its playoff plan would settle more cleanly around Matthew Boyd and Kevin Gausman as dependable follow-up options.
Instead, both pitchers have raised concerns at the same moment. Gausman has struggled to find his footing since arriving in Chicago, and Boyd has faded over his recent outings, leaving the Cubs with a late-season decision that carries more weight than anyone would like. With the postseason approaching, the question is not just who gets the ball after Holmes, but whether the Cubs can trust the rotation order they thought they were building. [Read more 🡒]
Craig Counsell Just Raised The Stakes For Edward Cabrera
Edward Cabrera is back with the club after being reinstated from the injured list and shifting into the bullpen, though the right-hander did not get into the recent series against the Pirates. Even so, his return has already become a talking point because Craig Counsell framed him as more than just another arm in relief, pointing to the possibility of a bigger postseason job if the Cubs need it.
Counsells comparison to Roki Sasakis impact out of the Dodgers bullpen last October gives the idea some real weight, but Cabrera also arrives with questions attached. His recent metrics have been uneven, with a high home run rate and pitch effectiveness trending in the wrong direction, which leaves Chicago balancing the upside of his stuff against the risk that comes with it. [Read more 🡒]