Cubs Suddenly Have A Bigger Matt Shaw Problem Than Expected

In a strategic roster move prompted by injury, the Chicago Cubs are giving another chance to former standout Kevin Alcantara despite past concerns.

The Chicago Cubs have brought Kevin Alcantara back to the roster, a move that comes after the club had seemed to cool on the 23-year-old outfielder in recent weeks.

Alcantara’s path with the Cubs has been a strange one since the 2024 season ended. An injury situation pushed him into his debut during the final week of that year, but the team still made a point of finding him playing time. The same general pattern followed in 2025, when he appeared in only 10 games for Chicago.

Earlier this season, the Cubs turned to Alcantara when their offense was struggling, but the usage never really turned into much. He logged just 10 plate appearances and was mostly deployed as a pinch-runner, which led to some mental mistakes on the bases. Since then, Justin Dean has filled that role and handled it well, which is about all you can ask from a spot that doesn’t offer much playing time.

That backdrop made Sunday’s game a little more notable. Dean pinch-hit for Matt Shaw in a meaningful plate appearance, and after the game Craig Counsell said Shaw had been taken out because of wrist soreness. That set up the roster move the Cubs made today.

It also says something about where the Cubs stand with Moises Ballesteros. Rather than recall their Opening Day DH, they’re keeping him with the Iowa Cubs so he can keep getting regular work as the team’s catcher. A return still seems likely at some point this season, but not until there’s a clearer path to give him consistent plate appearances.

Shaw’s situation is now the bigger concern. Jesse Rogers reported that the injury is a mild sprain in Shaw’s left wrist, and he noted that Shaw is headed for an injured list stint.

The timing matters. Since coming back from a back injury, Shaw had started to settle into a semi-regular role in the lineup.

Over his last 43 plate appearances, he hit .257/.395/.457 with a 143 wRC+. While Dansby Swanson - when he’s not facing Mets pitching - and Alex Bregman have both been in rough stretches, the hope was that Shaw could become a meaningful piece for the Cubs going forward.

Now the injury may ripple beyond the lineup. It could force Jed Hoyer to rethink how he handles the trade deadline, because even if the Cubs had no intention of dealing their former first-round pick, having Shaw available likely made them more comfortable with the idea of trading Pedro Ramirez. With Shaw sidelined, that may no longer be the case.

In Other News...

Dansby Swanson Just Made The Cubs Deadline Pressure Even Clearer

The Cubs have spent much of this month staring straight at the same problem: the pitching staff is thin, and the injuries are not letting up. With five starting pitchers on the injured list, Chicago has already had to patch things together, even after bringing in David Peterson to help stabilize the rotation.

Dansby Swanson helped make the deadline mission sound even clearer by confirming what the standings and the injury report have already suggested. Jameson Taillon is still not projected back until closer to the All-Star break, and if Chicago is going to stay on course through the second half, the front office may have to add more than just another arm before the deadline arrives. [Read more 🡒]

Cubs May Already Have A Carson Kelly Backup Plan Brewing

Carson Kellys strong season has only sharpened the question the Cubs will have to answer later: how hard can they push to keep him when free agency arrives? He has given them exactly what they wanted behind the plate, but Chicago has a roster to build around more than one position, and pitching and outfield help are part of the conversation too.

If Kelly walks, the Cubs are not starting from zero, and they may not have to rely solely on the open market to solve it. There are internal catching options to sort through, and the long view could also run through the draft, where Chicago may be looking at a future successor rather than treating the position as an immediate emergency. [Read more 🡒]

MLBs Latest Idea Feels A Little Too Perfect For The Cubs

Major League Baseballs leaked collective bargaining proposal has already stirred up the usual debate over how much freedom star players should have, and how much control teams should keep once the bidding starts. The outline includes a tighter free-agency system, with shorter maximum contract lengths for players changing teams and for players staying put, plus a push to raise the league minimum salary based on service time.

For Cubs fans, the eye-catching part is how neatly it fits the way Jed Hoyer has run the front office for years. Chicago has long been built around flexibility rather than the kind of sprawling commitments that define the top of the market, which is why names like Kyle Tucker, Shohei Ohtani and Juan Soto never felt like realistic fits in the first place. If this proposal ever becomes real, it could make the Cubs preferred path look a lot less like a choice and a lot more like the new rules of the game. [Read more 🡒]