The Cubs’ Edward Cabrera problem is no longer just about October.
What looked like a possible late-season bullpen fix has turned into a much bigger headache for Chicago, because the move hasn’t just failed to solve Cabrera’s blister issue - it has also deepened doubts about what kind of pitcher he can be for this team at all.
Tuesday’s 12th inning was a rough snapshot. Caleb Thielbar had already surrendered the lead by the time Cabrera got into the game, and Cabrera only made things worse. He allowed three runs on two hits and two walks in less than an inning.
That kind of outing only sharpens the obvious conclusion: Cabrera does not look like a fit for the Cubs’ playoff roster. Craig Counsell will need every reliable bullpen arm he can get, and Cabrera has simply not given Chicago enough to trust him in that spot, aside from the 14 innings he opened the season with.
But the bigger issue is what this means for the trade itself. Chicago dealt Owen Caissie for Cabrera with the idea that he could become the kind of top-of-the-rotation starter the Cubs have been chasing for the last two years. So far, the returns have gone the other way.
The numbers tell the story. Cabrera struck out 25.8% of the hitters he faced in his final season with the Marlins.
That figure has dropped to 20.3% with the Cubs this year. His walks are up 2% from last season, and his groundball rate has fallen by 3%.
A look at his Baseball Savant page only adds to the concern. Outside of fastball velocity, there isn’t much in the profile that suggests a pitcher capable of anchoring a rotation.
The Cubs have spent this season emphasizing Cabrera’s arm angle, and there has clearly been a change from where it was with the Marlins. Whether that adjustment came from Chicago or whether Cabrera developed a hitch in his delivery on his own remains unclear.
Either way, the work ahead is obvious. The Cubs need to figure out Cabrera this offseason, because this season is already gone.
That becomes even more urgent with a number of free agents expected to leave the rotation after the year. If Cabrera does not get back on track next season, the trade will start to look like a major miss for Jed Hoyer and Co.
In Other News...
Cubs Could Turn To An Unexpected Playoff X-Factor Or Two
The Cubs are weighing a few less obvious names as they shape their playoff roster for the National League Division Series, a reminder that October often rewards flexibility as much as star power. Justin Steele has given the club a reason to think about left-handed help after showing promise in a rehab outing, while Justin Dean offers a different kind of value as a speed-first outfielder who has mostly filled a pinch-running role.
Gavin Hollowell is also in the conversation after working back from a shoulder injury and turning in strong rehab appearances. None of these choices is set in stone, but the possibility of carrying an extra arm or a specialist runner speaks to how the Cubs are trying to cover specific postseason needs, even if the final decisions are still to come. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Fans May Need To Watch Carter Hawkins This Offseason
The Red Sox spent the day locking in their baseball leadership, with manager Chad Tracy getting a three-year contract extension after stepping in on an interim basis in April and executive Craig Breslow having club options exercised for the 2029 and 2030 seasons. It was a clear sign Boston wants continuity at the top, and it also quietly sharpened the broader front-office market for anyone around the league keeping an eye on possible movement.
For Cubs fans, the ripple effect could be worth watching. Chicago executive Carter Hawkins is already being mentioned as the kind of name that can surface when front office openings start to appear, and this kind of shuffle only adds to the possibility that his offseason could become more interesting than expected. If the Red Sox are settling in, other clubs may soon be looking for the same sort of stability, and that is where Hawkins starts to enter the conversation. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Face Awkward Fenway Twist With Playoff Stakes Still Rising
A late-September trip to Fenway Park was already going to carry some postseason feel for the Cubs, but the weather has turned it into something messier. Chicago and the Red Sox were supposed to play a three-game set from Sept. 25 to 27, only for an expected noreaster in Boston to push the clubs toward a Friday doubleheader and likely a final game on Saturday.
For the Cubs, the timing matters because both teams are already in the Wild Card field, yet neither has locked down its seeding. Heavy rain and strong winds are hanging over the weekend forecast, which means the series could be shaped as much by the skies as by the standings. Even in a game that counts, there is still room for a little Fenway oddity, and this one has all the makings of a September grind. [Read more 🡒]