The signs point in one direction for Shota Imanaga and the Cubs, and Patrick Mooney didn’t leave much room for interpretation.
On the latest episode of North Sider Territory, the Cubs beat writer said Chicago appears ready to move on from the veteran left-hander this winter. Mooney tied that feeling to a string of decisions that, in his view, show the organization no longer sees Imanaga as a dependable front-line starter.
“It's just clear they don't trust him to that level.” 👀 @PJ_Mooney believes the writing is on the wall for Shota Imanaga in Chicago, with the Cubs' recent decisions suggesting the organization is ready to move on from the veteran left-hander. pic.twitter.com/w8iVbenaZE
- North Side Territory (@NSideTerritory) October 8, 2026
The Cubs’ choices tell the story: they didn’t trust Imanaga last October, and they passed on his three-year option before eventually settling on a qualifying offer. Mooney also suggested Imanaga may be better off finding a home ballpark that is less unforgiving to the fly-ball style that has hurt him at times in Chicago.
That issue showed up in a major way this season. Imanaga gave up a career-high 35 home runs, second-most in MLB behind only Phillies veteran Aaron Nola.
Even with that, the overall investment still worked out well for Jed Hoyer. Imanaga’s peak came in his rookie season, when he finished fourth in Rookie of the Year voting and fifth in Cy Young balloting. Over three seasons, he logged nearly 500 innings and posted a 3.45 ERA with a 1.038 WHIP.
The expectation after that 2024 breakout was that Chicago had finally found its ace. Instead, Imanaga’s second season turned uneven, and the clearest sign of the Cubs’ waning confidence came in last year’s NLDS. With Game 5 on the line against the Milwaukee Brewers, Craig Counsell went with a bullpen game, a decision that sent a blunt message about where Imanaga stood.
Imanaga responded professionally and eventually returned after a messy offseason that dragged on longer than expected. He started slowly this year, then settled in over the final stretch, finishing 2026 on a strong note with a 2.25 ERA in five September starts.
Still, the sense now is that the comeback won’t lead to another run in Chicago. In a thin starting pitching market, Imanaga should have a path to a new multi-year deal. It just doesn’t look like that deal will come from the Cubs.
In Other News...
Cubs Face Familiar Jed Hoyer Question As October Needs Grow
As the Cubs keep sorting through what October exposed and what still has to be fixed, the conversation is already turning toward the offseason and the kinds of upgrades Jed Hoyer might chase. The pool of possible help from the remaining playoff teams gives the front office some familiar options to sift through, with pitching and lineup depth both standing out as obvious areas to address.
The speculative targets include arms and bats from clubs still playing meaningful games, which is part of what makes the exercise useful even before free agency and the trade market fully open up. Chicago can dream on bigger names if they become available, but the real challenge is finding the right fit without overcommitting, especially with the team still trying to turn October appearances into something deeper. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Offseason Pitching Plan Is Starting To Make Real Sense
The Cubs offseason is starting to look a lot less abstract and a lot more focused, with pitching clearly at the center of whatever comes next. Chicago is expected to make a meaningful overhaul on the mound, and the logic behind it is easy to see after a season in which the rotation never felt fully settled. With several current arms carrying uncertainty into the winter, the front office has a clear area to address if it wants to stabilize the roster.
Michael King has emerged as the kind of target that fits the assignment, giving the Cubs a realistic option if he reaches free agency after this year. He brings the kind of recent performance teams can build around, including a strong regular season and a postseason run that only added to his appeal. The only real question now is how aggressive Chicago wants to be in turning that fit into a signing, especially with more than one rotation spot still in flux. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Pitching Reset Could Hinge On One Rare International Arm
The Cubs are staring at another offseason pitching overhaul, with a long list of arms either headed for free agency or reaching option decisions. For a staff that needs help in several places, that has put a premium on finding pitching outside the usual domestic market, and Kaima Taira has quickly emerged as one of the more intriguing names to watch.
A rare international left-hander with a strong track record in Japan, Taira is viewed as a potential fit for Chicagos needs at just the right time. If he is posted when expected in early November, the Cubs and every other interested club will have only a short window to make their case before the lockout interrupts the market, turning his availability into one of the more important early tests of the winter. [Read more 🡒]