The Cubs are staring at an offseason full of hard calls, and two names sit on very different sides of the fence.
Seiya Suzuki looks like the one Chicago can’t really afford to let get away. Shota Imanaga, on the other hand, sounds like the kind of arm the Cubs may be ready to move on from.
Suzuki has given the Cubs exactly what they want from a middle-of-the-order regular: steady production, real pop, and enough defensive growth to make his spot in right field easier to justify. Over five seasons in Chicago, he has been a reliable offensive piece, posting a career .823 OPS since arriving in the majors in 2022. The power has followed too, with Suzuki topping 20 homers in four straight years and setting a new career high with 32 in 2025.
What really changes the conversation is how he’s developed in the field. Suzuki came into MLB with Gold Glove recognition from overseas, but that didn’t show up right away in his first seasons. This year, though, he put together a career year in right field, and that makes the idea of paying to keep him a lot more palatable.
His bat has stacked up well against the rest of the league’s right fielders too. He ranked fifth in wRC+ and OPS+ at 131, fourth in on-base percentage at .368, sixth in OPS at .841, sixth in home runs with 26, sixth in RBI with 86, and sixth in runs.
If Chicago lets Suzuki walk, there’s no obvious replacement waiting to step in and match what he’s already been giving them. The alternatives would be a cheaper external add or a less experienced prospect who hasn’t produced at Suzuki’s level yet. Keeping him would also buy time for future players like Josiah Harthshorn and Ethan Conrad to develop without being rushed into bigger roles.
That matters even more with the Cubs already facing the possibility of plenty of turnover elsewhere on the roster. Suzuki may not be the long-term answer, but he still helps them win right now, and his game keeps trending in the right direction. Toronto is reportedly among the teams keeping an eye on him this winter, which only raises the stakes for Chicago.
Imanaga’s case is the opposite. He has been a favorite with fans and has shown flashes of dominance, but the expectation is that the Cubs won’t bring him back unless the price drops into team-friendly territory. His struggles have outweighed the good stretches, and the organization never got enough from him when it mattered most.
There was some thought he might be in the mix for the playoffs after finishing strong, but that didn’t happen. The Cubs gave him a shot last year, and it still didn’t work out. In fact, much like Edward Cabrera this year, Craig Counsell stayed away from him for the rest of the postseason.
For a pitcher making more than $20 million, Chicago would need far more certainty in October than Imanaga has provided. Unless he’s willing to come back on a deal that makes sense for the Cubs, the signs point to a rotation that looks very different next season.
In Other News...
Javier Assad Gives Cubs One Tough Payroll Decision Ahead
Jed Hoyers comments about November set the table for another busy stretch on the Cubs front office calendar, and not just because the winter meetings are approaching. With the current collective bargaining agreement set to expire in December, Chicago is staring at a roster-planning period where timing matters as much as talent. The club already has 12 players who are arbitration-eligible for the 2027 season, and most of them are expected to be tendered contracts, including Justin Steele and Edward Cabrera.
The squeeze comes from the few decisions that are not nearly as straightforward. Arias and Austin are obvious non-tender candidates this offseason, but the bigger challenge is how the Cubs sort through the middle of the roster when payroll flexibility is at a premium. It leaves Hoyer and his staff trying to balance future value against immediate costs, and it is exactly the kind of lineup-and-budget puzzle that can shape the tone of a winter before the first move is even made. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Face One Defining Youth Question As Roster Changes Loom
With the Cubs eliminated from the playoffs, the focus is already shifting from the present tense to what comes next, and there is no shortage of roster work ahead. Chicago has several players it can imagine as part of the next wave, including Pedro Ramirez, Braxton Garrett and Kevin Alcantara, but the winter is shaping up to be more than a simple retool.
A number of familiar names are likely headed for different outcomes, with Edward Cabrera among the players viewed as likely to be moved on from. Add in multiple free agents and options that are not expected to be exercised, and the Cubs are staring at a stretch in which the front office will have to sort out not just who stays, but which young player ends up being the one who defines the next stage. [Read more 🡒]
Ian Happ's Cubs Future Just Became A Real Offseason Debate
The Cubs head into the winter with a familiar kind of squeeze, one that mixes sentiment with roster math. Ian Happ has been part of the core long enough to matter beyond the box score, and there is at least a path to keeping him on a team-friendly deal after another season that reinforced both his production and his value in the clubhouse. But Chicago also has bigger-picture needs, and the front office is already weighing where its money has to go if it wants to shore up the pitching staff.
Seiya Suzuki complicates that calculation in a different way. He is younger, his offensive profile may carry more appeal on the open market, and the Cubs may not be able to treat both outfielders as long-term priorities if the budget gets tight. So the offseason question is not simply whether Chicago likes Happ or Suzuki, but which one best fits the roster, the payroll, and the urgency of the fixes still needed elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]