Cubs Offseason Could Decide More Than Just Seiya Suzuki's Future

With financial flexibility ahead, the Cubs face critical decisions that could redefine their payroll strategy and team dynamics, especially surrounding Seiya Suzuki's future.

The Cubs’ 2026 outlook looks strong enough to fuel real optimism, but the bigger question hanging over the organization is what happens after that - and whether Seiya Suzuki is part of the answer.

Chicago still has work to do if it wants to catch the Brewers in the NL Central, but the club is sitting on the best offense and defense in baseball, and its pitching staff has taken a major step forward since the trade deadline. More help is expected back from the injured list, too, which only adds to the sense that this team could be a problem for anyone in October.

The longer view is where things get trickier. The Cubs were wise to extend Nico Hoerner earlier this year, but they’re also staring at a wave of free agency that could strip away a big chunk of the roster.

Ian Happ, Carson Kelly, Shota Imanaga, Clay Holmes and Kevin Gausman are all on that list, and none of those departures would be small. Still, Suzuki stands out as the most important name of all.

He was unexpectedly part of trade chatter earlier this summer, and the Cubs ultimately kept him. That decision mattered, because Suzuki has been one of the most reliable hitters in the sport.

He ranks 22nd among MLB hitters this year in wRC+, and over the last four seasons his 130 wRC+ is tied with Pete Alonso and Rafael Devers. Add in the defensive gains he’s made this year, and it gets harder to imagine Chicago being better off with him somewhere else.

That said, every front office has to think ahead, and the Cubs’ biggest offseason need is still obvious: pitching. Their rotation picture for next year looks deeper on paper than it does in reality.

Justin Steele will be returning after not having started a game in nearly two years. Ben Brown has yet to make even 10 regular-season starts at the big league level because of injuries.

Edward Cabrera has dealt with injuries and ineffectiveness all year. Cade Horton might not pitch at all, and Braxton Garrett, a deadline pickup, is more of a roll of the dice than a sure thing.

Along with Javier Assad and Colin Rea, that group makes up the Cubs’ entire rotation mix heading into 2027. If Chicago wants enough starting pitching to survive next season, it’s going to need multiple additions there, and those moves won’t come cheap. That’s been the argument from a lot of observers, including The Athletic’s Sahadev Sharma: the Cubs won’t spend enough to keep Suzuki if they also have to pour money into the rotation.

But the financial picture might not be as tight as that sounds. The Cubs have more than $120 million coming off the books this offseason.

Yes, some of that will go to raises for Hoerner and Pete Crow-Armstrong as their extensions kick in, along with arbitration-type salaries for players like Michael Busch. Even so, there should still be room to bring Suzuki back and address the pitching staff.

That plan gets tougher only if Chicago decides to chase an ace in the Tarik Skubal mold. But the Cubs’ recent behavior suggests that isn’t the route they’re likely to take.

They passed on Dylan Cease and Max Fried in recent years, which points toward a different kind of approach - middle-tier free agents and trade additions, not the top of the market. If that remains the strategy, there’s no reason they couldn’t keep Suzuki and still upgrade the rotation.

There’s one more wrinkle, though: other position-player decisions could change the math. Even there, the Cubs appear to have some flexibility. Owen Ayers looks close to being the clear successor to Carson Kelly behind the plate, and if Ian Happ has a down year, it becomes easier to imagine Matt Shaw and Pedro Ramirez collectively covering that production than replacing Suzuki’s bat.

In Other News...

Cubs Add Veteran Catching Depth As One Roster Question Looms

The Cubs have added another layer of catching insurance, signing veteran Austin Wynns to a minor league contract and sending him to Triple-A Iowa. After being outrighted by the Texas Rangers and electing free agency, Wynns gives Chicago an experienced option behind the clubs major league catchers as the season moves toward its stretch run.

Wynns also arrives with a practical benefit that matters this time of year: he would be eligible for postseason play if the Cubs add him to the roster before September. With the calendar tightening and roster questions always lurking at catcher, the move gives Chicago a little more flexibility while leaving the bigger decision in the background. [Read more 🡒]

Ben Brown Setback Leaves Cubs With A Stretch Run Problem

Ben Browns return was already shaping up as one of the more important health watch items on the Cubs late-season docket, and now it has taken a step in the wrong direction. The right-hander had been working back from a stress reaction in his neck, but live bullpen sessions brought the symptoms back and made them worse, forcing the team to slow things down and rethink the plan.

The Cubs said Brown will travel back with the club to consult with doctors, which pushes any possibility of a 2025 return farther down the road. For a team trying to balance the stretch run with the bigger picture, the focus now shifts to making sure the recovery path protects Browns long-term health, even if it leaves Chicago with one less pitching option in the short term. [Read more 🡒]

Cubs Look Ready For October But Two Issues Could Change Everything

The Cubs have put themselves in a strong position for October by finding a steadier offensive rhythm, with Pete Crow-Armstrong and Alex Bregman helping drive that consistency. Add in a pitching staff that has looked sharper since the trade deadline, and this has the feel of a club that did what it needed to do over the summer to put real playoff expectations back on the table.

Still, a couple of late-season questions are hanging over the roster in ways that could matter once the games tighten up. Matthew Boyd and Shota Imanaga have both stumbled recently, which leaves some uncertainty in the front of the rotation, and Dansby Swansons recovery from an oblique strain complicates the Cubs playoff roster picture with his return timeline still uncertain as October approaches. [Read more 🡒]