The Cubs thought they had addressed their biggest October question when Jed Hoyer swung for Kevin Gausman and Clay Holmes at the deadline. At the time, that made sense.
Chicago had already been burned by the Michael Soroka experience a year earlier, so the appetite for another shaky bet was low. Gausman, after all, was the established arm.
Holmes came with the kind of late-season promise teams love to chase.
But the first day of October changed the conversation fast.
Chicago is out, Gausman’s Game 2 Wild Card start came while he was clearly less than 100 percent, and Holmes never even got into the series. Both are headed for free agency, leaving Hoyer with a rotation to rebuild again - and not just around those two. Matthew Boyd, Shota Imanaga, Colin Rea and David Peterson also need to be replaced.
Gausman acknowledged afterward that he wanted more out of himself in Game 2 and said the early damage gave San Diego momentum. He added:
"I really wish I could have been 100% & gone out there with a little bit more. But I had what I had & tried to give it everything I had."
While that played out in Chicago, Tyler Mahle was quietly writing a much different October story.
Mahle, who had been a fringe rotation piece with the Giants before a summer trade to the Braves for Anthony Molina, settled in as a regular starter down the stretch. Over nine starts with Atlanta, he posted a 1.99 ERA and a 0.957 WHIP, then carried that form straight into his first MLB playoff start on Wednesday.
He was one of the few bright spots in the Braves’ Wild Card loss to the Phillies, working seven innings of one-run ball and striking out six. That outing made him the first Braves starter to allow 0-1 runs and work at least seven innings in the playoffs since Max Fried did it in 2020, back when Fried was still with Atlanta and now is a Yankees ace.
The contrast is hard to miss. Mahle delivered when the stakes were highest.
Gausman and Holmes, at least for Chicago’s purposes, did not. Holmes never threw a pitch in the series, and Gausman, despite flashes, never quite looked like the front-of-the-rotation answer the Cubs were hoping for.
His 4.33 FIP in nine starts and Holmes’ 4.09 ERA in nine starts tell the story: some good moments, but not enough sustained dominance.
There’s also a bigger question hanging over all of this. Even if the Cubs had been the team to land Mahle, would he have become the same pitcher he was after the deadline?
That’s not a given. Chicago has had some success turning bullpen projects into something more, but the disastrous Edward Cabrera attempt raises real doubts about whether the organization can consistently unlock mid-tier arms - or even pitchers with better stuff who still need help putting it together.
In Other News...
Pete Crow-Armstrong Just Put Cubs Fans On Notice About October
The Cubs return to the postseason ended quickly against the Padres, and the disappointment was felt most sharply among the lineups biggest names. Chicago was outscored 12-2 across the Wild Card Series, and Pete Crow-Armstrong, one of the clubs most important bats during the regular season, never found his footing at the plate while the games tightened and the margin for error disappeared.
Crow-Armstrong was blunt about his role in the setback, acknowledging that he did not contribute in October the way he had hoped after a strong year. For a young player whose growth has helped shape the Cubs outlook, the series served as an early reminder that regular-season production does not always carry over when the calendar flips, and he made clear the disappointment was as personal as it was team-wide. [Read more 🡒]
Ian Happ Just Turned A Painful Cubs Question Into A Real One
The Cubs postseason ended abruptly with a sweep by the Padres in the National League wild-card series, but the more lingering story may be what comes next for Ian Happ. The veteran outfielder has spent his entire 10-year MLB career in Chicago, and with free agency arriving this offseason, his future now sits at the center of one of the teams most emotional questions.
Happs reaction made clear this is not a routine roster decision for the Cubs or for the player. Dansby Swanson also spoke about Happs impact on the club and their friendship, underscoring how much he means inside the room as well as on the field. There is already speculation that a reunion could still happen, possibly on a hometown discount, but for now the real issue is whether one of the organizations most familiar faces is about to test a market that has suddenly made his value a real conversation. [Read more 🡒]
Jed Hoyer Faces Painful Cubs Calls As Brewers Gap Still Looms
The Cubs season ended with a playoff berth, but the gap between being relevant and being a true October threat still hangs over the winter. Jed Hoyer now has to sort through a roster that got the club into the postseason without convincing anyone it has reached World Series territory, and that means some uncomfortable calls are coming as he tries to keep the core moving forward without standing pat.
Several familiar names are already part of the offseason conversation, with Matthew Boyd, Kevin Gausman, Hunter Harvey and others mentioned as possible departures or trade candidates. For a front office that has spent the year trying to balance present value with longer-term planning, the real challenge may be deciding which pieces are worth carrying into 2027 and which ones are better used to reshape the roster before the Brewers edge feels even wider. [Read more 🡒]