Craig Counsell didn’t leave much room for mystery Monday night. When the Cubs started Kevin Alcántara in left field against Dodgers left-hander Justin Wrobleski, with Ian Happ beginning the game on the bench, it looked like a clear sign of where this was headed. Happ eventually entered as a pinch-hitter in the sixth once Los Angeles turned to a right-handed reliever, and that seems to be the pattern Chicago plans to follow.
This is not a straight benching. It’s a platoon, and it’s the direction the Cubs are taking for the rest of the regular season’s final stretch. When a left-handed starter is on the mound, Tyrone Taylor is expected to get the nod in left field in Happ’s place.
Counsell confirmed that plan Tuesday on The Score, saying Taylor will start against Tarik Skubal and that the Cubs will try to cut down on Happ’s plate appearances against lefties the rest of the 2026 season.
The numbers make the move easy to understand. In 125 plate appearances against left-handed pitching in 2026, Happ is hitting .158/.232/.298 with a 34.4 K% and a 48 wRC+.
Since May 20, he’s gone just 8-for-60 against lefties, with 25 strikeouts in 65 plate appearances. That’s a rough enough run to force a change, and Taylor’s track record against left-handed pitching gives Chicago a much cleaner answer.
Before the trade, Taylor had posted a .301/.311/.589 line with five homers and a 146 wRC+ against lefties. That kind of production is exactly why his addition in the Clay Holmes trade matters here.
The Cubs didn’t wait around for a perfect internal fix because the alternatives weren’t nearly as simple. Pedro Ramirez, for all the appeal of giving him a look, would have been thrown into the outfield with very little experience.
Matt Shaw could have helped in this role too, since he has excelled against left-handed pitching in his career and could theoretically carry his defensive skills from right field to left. But Shaw has been out with a wrist injury since June 28.
That leaves Taylor as the practical choice, and it gives Counsell a more reliable platoon option than rolling the dice on a rookie. Alcántara did go deep on Monday, but the 24-year-old has struggled in his limited MLB time, so the Cubs are choosing the safer path with a player who has already shown he can punish left-handed pitching.
In Other News...
Clay Holmes Already Feels Like A Cubs Decision That Could Linger
The Cubs did important work at the trade deadline by landing Kevin Gausman and Clay Holmes without surrendering top prospects Josiah Hartshorn and Jaxon Wiggins, a balancing act that matters now and later. Holmes, in particular, stands out because this is not just about filling a short-term hole in the pitching staff. Around the club, he is already being viewed as someone who could fit into the rotation picture beyond this season, which gives the move a different kind of weight than a typical deadline rental.
For now, though, the immediate question is more basic: when is Holmes ready to help in Chicago, and in what capacity? Conversations about his recovery and the best way to bring him back are still ongoing, which leaves the Cubs in a holding pattern even as they look to make the most of the deadline haul. The bigger decision on Holmes may come later, once the team has a clearer sense of how he looks and how he fits, but he has already become one of those acquisitions that can shape more than a pennant race. [Read more 🡒]
Kyle Tuckers Wrigley Return Gave Cubs Fans One More Reason To Pile On
Wrigley Field had not changed much by the time Kyle Tucker walked back into it, but the reception sure had. Cubs fans made their feelings known throughout his return, turning a familiar setting into a hostile one for a player who once wore their uniform and was supposed to be part of the next era on the North Side.
The backdrop only sharpened the reaction. Tucker had already become a source of frustration for Cubs fans because of the way his 2025 season unfolded, and his first year with the Dodgers after signing a massive contract has not exactly quieted the noise either. Los Angeles is still chasing a championship, but for Cubs supporters, Tuckers latest trip to Wrigley was another chance to pile on. [Read more 🡒]